Shopping Cart


Want to chat? blog face carla


Email Us:

An automated email message will be delivered to you within 10 minutes.  If you do not see it in your inbox please check your spam/junk mail. Make sure to whitelist our email address to ensure you receive updates on your order and other important information.


Home of the Award-Winning Gourmet Butter Tart

It’s Not Just a Butter Tart, It’s an Experience

Baker's Choice

Carla’s Cookie Box Has Been Featured on:

Looking to carry our products in your store or are you purchasing some corporate gifts?

Send us an email today for special pricing!


Where You’ve Seen Us

Media gallery

Featured Items

Shop Safely and Confidently

light bulb outlined hand drawn tool

Corporate Solutions

Give us a budget and we will come up with a solution.

chatting speech bubbles hand drawn bubbles couple


Quick Shipping to Your Home or Office

shopping cart sketch

Contactless Pickup

Contactless Pickup Available Twice a Week.

light bulb outlined hand drawn tool

Safety First

Order your goods on our Secure website.

Pick A Category

Shop Award-Winning Butter Tarts

  • $19.00$48.10 Buy Now
  • $0.00 / month for 3 months Subscription 3-month total subscription including Shipping at $99.00 Buy Now


In honour of our brother, Paul, who was killed by a DRUNK DRIVER in August 2019, 10% of June’s online sales will be donated to MADD Canada.

Shop Now to help us make a difference with Impaired Driving laws.

paul and carla

Real talk from our customers

Carla's Cookie Box
Based on 184 reviews
Carla's Cookie Box
Based on 44 reviews
Debbie T.
00:41 24 Jul 22
Just tried your pecan butter tart. It was delicious
Justin H.
09:11 25 Apr 22
Claude Sabine G.
15:03 24 Apr 22
Edwin T.
22:55 16 Apr 22
My first time ordering from Carla’s Cookie Box and everything from the customer experience to the treats themselves was top notch! I ordered somewhat last minute, but Carla was able to ensure I was able to pick up my order at the scheduled time. The cookies and tarts I ordered were also some of the best I’ve ever had. I’ll be sure to order from here in the future. Thank you Carla!read more


Popular Gifts

Premium Local Ingredients

We use locally sourced ingredients from our local farmers.

Next Day Shipping Available

Pick your SHIPPING date on checkout, Conditions Apply

International Shipping

We Ship Across CANADA + USA

100% Secure Checkout

Licensed, Foodsafe Certified, BBB Accredited, Insured, FDA Approved