Shop | Carla's Cookie Box | It's Not Just A Butter Tart, It's An Experience |

Shop With Us!

Shop Today, Pick up Today – Order by 5pm:

261 Millway Ave, Unit 14, Vaughan, ON

Delivers / Ships Next Day

FREE Delivery & Shipping in Ontario When You Spend $50

Shop Today!

Same Day Pick Up – Order by 5pm

Delivers / Ships Next Day

FREE Delivery & Shipping in Ontario When You Spend $50

**All Products are made in a facility that contains Peanuts / Tree nuts, wheat, dairy, soy and any other known allergen**

Google Reviews:

carla's cookie box
5.0
Based on 49 reviews
See all reviews Write a review
Gordon Lee
22:32 11 Aug 20
I was first introduced to Carla’s Cookie box at one of the downtown pop up markets. Hands down some of the best butter tarts I’ve ever had! The shell is nice and not too thick and the inside is not runny at all. Always happy to support her when she’s downtown and have continued ordering on occasion for delivery at home!
Adriana Vicari
16:06 08 Aug 20
Professional and friendly! The butter tarts and brownies were a huge hit for my daughters birthday party. Quality, taste and great customer service. I would highly recommend Carla’s Cookie box to anyone looking to enjoy some sweet treats.
Michele Ponniah
00:35 07 Aug 20
Can't say enough great things about these tarts and this lovely lady! Carla puts her heart and soul into her creations, and they really are delicious! She uses local products and even the crusts of her butter tarts are buttery and delish! My favourites are definitely the peanut butter and the Nutella...but she has so many great ones to choose from! I love the tarts so much that I haven't tried the cookies or brownies yet, but they are next on my list. To top it all off, she's super sweet. Always willing to stop and chat with people even though she's elbow deep in butter tarts! Try them out, believe me, you won't regret it! 🙌🏽😍🤤
Lindsay Barclay
22:16 06 Aug 20
Every encounter with Carla has always been super positive. Add to that the best butter tarts i have ever had. Not your typical thick crust. Thin and crispy and lots of delicious filling.