Award Winning Gourmet Homemade Butter Tarts

Our Gourmet Butter Tarts are Award Winning for good reason. We pride ourselves on making THE BEST Butter Tarts in the world by using all-natural ingredients. 

We don’t sacrifice quality for quantity and ensure every one of our Butter Tarts is handmade and baked to perfection.

Every batch of butter tart pastry is freshly made by hand with REAL butter by Carla, herself.

12 assorted butter tarts on home page
Show Filters
Show Filters

4.9
Based on 190 reviews
5.0
Based on 43 reviews
Jennifer T.
23:42 09 Jan 22
Rohit T.
03:13 04 Jan 22
If being a Master Chef is a thing, then Carla and her team are Master Bakers!I first learned of... Carla's Cookie Box during the 2020 holiday season. After having a chance to try one of Carla's cookie's, I decided to place a large corporate order (400+) of cookie decorating kits that involved nationwide shipping for the 2021 holiday season.Upon reaching out to Carla, she was very thorough in helping me choose the right option for my order, stayed within my budget, and ensured me that my order would hand delivered to each recipient that it was intended for. Additionally, she helped me customize the design of the cookie box.Carla and her team were so efficient and ensured every cookie was baked with care. The cookies were delivered on time to each recipient (within less than a week of placing the order) and tasted absolutely amazing!I'm so grateful to have met Carla and have worked with her. I would highly recommend Carla's Cookie's Box to anyone who is looking for a large custom order or just some treats to munch on. They are so good!Thank you Carla!!!read more
Azik A.
00:43 31 Dec 21
The absolute best cookies, brownies and butter tarts that we have ever had. The only thing better... than the baked goods, is the customer service. Thank you Carla.read more
Rhea E.
21:44 08 Dec 21