6 Month Butter Tart Subscription - Fan Favourites
6 Month Butter Tart Subscription
$190.00 Add to cart

6 Month Butter Tart Subscription


Receive SIX Award-Winning Handcrafted Gourmet Butter Tarts per month for SIX consecutive Months!

This Price includes Shipping + Handling.

We may add Extra Shipping for distant areas.

How it Works:

For six (6) consecutive months, you will receive a half dozen (6) box of butter tarts of your choice once a month.

Choose your flavours and add them to your cart today.

(2 customer reviews)

Month 1 * 

Choose your month 1 butter tarts

Month 2 * 

Choose your month 2 butter tarts

Month 3 * 

Choose your month 3 butter tarts

Month 4 * 

Choose your month 4 butter tarts

Month 5 * 

Choose your month 5 butter tarts

Month 6 * 

Choose your month 6 butter tarts

Handwritten Card (+$3.50)

Add a handwritten card to your order for your receiver

Select delivery location

Free Ontario shipping on all orders over $100

  • Licensed, Foodsafe Certified, BBB Accredited, Insured, FDA Approved
  • Order before 7 pm for next day dispatch
  •  Order TODAY & Pick your SHIPPING date on checkout
Guaranteed Safe Checkout

6 Month Butter Tart Subscription? Really?

Yes! Really! We have monthly Butter Tart subscriptions!

Our 6-month Award Winning Gourmet Butter Tarts Subscriptions make a GREAT gift.

How it Works

When you sign up for a butter tart subscription, we will send you your first month’s subscription right away, or on the date you indicate. Subscriptions will then follow once a month for 3 or 6 consecutive months. 

With our subscriptions growing, we have had to split up our monthly deliveries. You will now receive your subscription on either week 1, week 2, week 3, or week 4 of the month, depending on when you purchased your subscription.

For example, if you purchased your subscription on June 13, you will receive your first month’s butter tarts on approximately June 14th (depending on where you live and delivery service. Each subsequent month, you will receive your butter tarts on week 2 of the month, approximately on Thursday or Friday.

Gift for Someone Else?

If your butter tart subscription is a gift, you don’t have to select their butter tarts for your recipient.

Pick plain as your butter tart flavour per month, add a note that your recipient will be emailing me to choose their flavours and go to checkout to complete the payment. 

Ensure to include the mailing address, phone number and email address for your recipient and the date you are sending the gift certificate to them.

Once you give them their subscription Gift Certificate, your recipient can email us with their six butter tart flavours. 

Ingredients Include:

  • 100% Butter
  • 100% Ontario Maple Syrup
  • Brown Sugar
  • Eggs

Choose your flavours and add them to your cart.

Butter Tart Flavours

Unique, Creative + Local!

We pride ourselves on being different and not following the crowd. So you will always find something unique and fun at Carla’s Cookie Box.

All of our ingredients are sourced locally, right here in Ontario, supporting Ontario Farmers.

Gifts for Everyone!

If you are gifting this pack, we can wrap it up for you in a special way. There are many options for you to give your extra-special goods.

individually packaged butter tart
gift wrapping

Shipping + Pickup!

Our shipping is quite extensive and unique, just like us! We ship all across Canada and the USA.

Upon checkout, choose your SHIPPING date, NOT delivery date.

If you are shipping your items in the GTA, click the LOCAL SHIPPING FAQ for more information.

If you are shipping your products to other parts of Ontario, Canada or the USA, please click SHIPPING INFORMATION for more information. 

Please click PICKUP for our pickup options. 

Allergy Alert!

Although we have items that do not have nuts in them, our facility does therefore we are NOT an allergen free environment. 

All Products are made in a facility that contains Peanuts, Tree nuts, wheat, dairy and any other known allergen.

BUtter Tart Trio - MIni Butter Tarts

Additional information

Weight 2 lbs
Dimensions 12 × 9 × 6 in

Brown Sugar, Butter, Cider Vinegar, Eggs, Flour, Ontario Maple Syrup, Salt, Vegetable Shortening

Add On Ingredients

Caramel, Chocolate Chips, Coconut, Lemon Curd, Nutella, Peanut Butter, Peanuts, Pecans, Raisins, Raspberry Sauce, Sea Salt, Strawberry Sauce, Toffee, Walnuts


Carla's Cookie Box


Carla's Cookie Box

2 reviews for 6 Month Butter Tart Subscription

  1. Sue

    Oh my what a delight to receive my second shipment of Carla’s awesome butter tarts. The tarts came quickly all the way from Ontario to a tiny town in BC and in perfect shape. I was amazed that they taste fresh as if they just came out if the oven. Carla uses a vacuum packing that maintains the freshness of the tarts.
    Hands down the yummiest butter tarts ever!! I just love trying all the interesting flavours!! I will definitely be ordering more of these delicious, gooey treats!!

  2. Jennifer Tann

    Hi Carla,
    We’ve received our first delivery and they are delicious!

Shipping Info

Ordering Instructions:

Welcome to Carla’s Cookie Box Store!

We are not a walk-in storefront, therefore we have put together a step-by-step instruction guide on the How to Order Online.

  • Click on your flavour selections (if applicable), type quantity in the box beside “ORDER NOW,” click “ORDER NOW.”
  • A side drawer will pop out at the side of the shop with your product and price 
  • From there, you can continue to shop by clicking the webpage outside of the cart or 
  • Continue to check out 

Checking Out

Fill Out Your Delivery Information:

  • Choose the date you would like your item SHIPPED OUT – NOT your delivery date. For more information on how long a shipment takes, CLICK HERE 
  • If you cannot choose your shipping date, then either we do not ship that particular item to your location, it is past the cutoff time, or we are not delivering that item to your area on that day.
  • We CANNOT guarantee a specific drop-off time for our deliveries as our local drivers drive for many local businesses and are out delivering all day and evening. For more information on deliveries, CLICK HERE. 
  • If you feel there is an error on the date, please either Clear Your Cache (instructions on clearing your cache on Mac Here  and Windows Here) or try in a Private Browser (instructions on a private browser on Mac Here and Windows Here)
  • We DO NOT want your cold-packed baked goods sitting in a UPS warehouse therefore we DO NOT ship out on a Friday.
  • Choose your pick up date
  • Choose your pick up time 
  • Continue to fill out your name, address, etc.…
  • Don’t forget to add your shipping phone number. 
Billing Details: 

Fill in your email address, name, address, shipping phone number.

Register your information to our website for easier access to your order details.

Shipping Details:

Click “Ship to a different address” if you are shipping to another person (not yourself).


You can enter coupons either in the cart or at the checkout.

Your Order:

Verify your items

Shipping Verification:

Verify your Shipping or Pick Up Option


Choose your payment option. We have THREE payment options. Etransfer, Credit Card or PayPal


If choosing E-transfer, your payment MUST be received within an hour of your order, or we will cancel your order.

Please add the order number in your comments section on your E-Transfer.

Terms & Conditions:

You must click on the Terms & Conditions 


CONGRATULATIONS! You have just placed your order on Carla’s Cookie Box

You will receive an email with your order details.
Check your spam if you do not see it.


To check on the status of your order please log into your account.
If you have not created one, you can still login with your email address and click on forgot password to reset your password.

You will get an email the day before your shipping/pickup date with your order verification.

Did you find this FAQ helpful?