Award Winning Butter Tarts of the Month


It’s Not Just a Butter Tart; It’s an Experience

Butter Tarts of the Month!

Baker’s Choice

  • SIX Award Winning Butter Tarts of the Month per box
  • Use Locally Sourced Ingredients
  • Supports Local Farmers

Flavour Description

Baker’s Choice:

  • Plain
  • Pecan
  • Caramel Glazed Walnut
  • Turtle
  • Toffee
  • Surprise Butter Tart

Shipping & Pick Up
  • SHIPPING and Pick up are on Wednesdays and Fridays only
  • Pick your SHIPPING or Pick up date upon checking out
  • Check the Shipping price in your cart without checking out
  • Click the link for more shipping information

Handwritten Card Message

Add a handwritten message to your recipient.

Guaranteed Safe Checkout

    Award Winning Butter Tarts of the Month

    Our Gourmet Butter Tarts are Award-Winning for a good reason. We make every batch of pastry by hand with REAL butter.

    6 Award-Winning Butter Tarts of the Month in each pack.

    Baker’s Choice: Plain, Pecan, Caramel Glazed Walnut, Turtle, Toffee, Surprise Butter Tart

    Our filling contains only REAL ingredients that you can find in your local grocery store.

    Featured on:

    Carla’s Cookie Box strives to have the BEST quality handmade artisanal baked goods.

    We ship across Canada and the USA, or you can PICK UP in Vaughan.

    Need some questions answered first?

    CLICK HERE for our Frequently Asked Questions Section!

    Ingredients Include:

    • 100% Butter
    • 100% Ontario Maple Syrup
    • Brown Sugar
    • Eggs

    Gourmet Butter Tart Flavours:

    Unique, Creative + Local!

    We pride ourselves on being different and not following the crowd. So you will always find something unique and fun at Carla’s Cookie Box.

    All of our ingredients are sourced locally, right here in Ontario, supporting Ontario Farmers.

    Gifts for Everyone!

    We offer gift packaging for a fee for some of our more popular gifts. We can wrap it up for you in a special way. There are many options for you to give your extra-special goods as gifts.

    Gift Box Carlas Cookie Box Carlas Cookie Box
    gift wrapping Carlas Cookie Box Carlas Cookie Box

    Shipping + Pickup!

    Our shipping is quite extensive and unique, just like us! We ship all across Canada and the USA.

    Upon checkout, choose your SHIPPING date, NOT delivery date.

    If you are shipping your items in the GTA, click the LOCAL SHIPPING FAQ for more information.

    If you are shipping your products to other parts of Ontario, Canada or the USA, please click SHIPPING INFORMATION for more information. 

    Please click PICKUP for our pickup options. 

    Allergy Alert!

    Although we have items that do not have nuts in them, our facility does therefore we are NOT a nut-free environment. 

    All Products are made in a facility that contains Peanuts, Tree nuts, wheat, dairy and any other known allergen.

    pecan butter tart Carlas Cookie Box Carlas Cookie Box

    Additional information

    Weight 3 lbs
    Dimensions 10 × 8 × 2 in
    Add On Ingredients

    Caramel, Chocolate Chips, Coconut, Lemon Curd, Nutella, Peanut Butter, Pecans, Raisins, Raspberry Sauce, Sea Salt, Strawberry Sauce, Toffee, Walnuts


    Carla's Cookie Box


    Carla's Cookie Box



    product height inches

    Gift Guide


    product length inches




    product width inches



    There are no reviews yet.

    Be the first to review “Award Winning Butter Tarts of the Month”

    Shipping Info

    We offer both delivery and pickup options.
    Once you checkout, you can choose which method you would prefer, your preferred date and for pickup, you can choose your time.
    Click on the FAQ link below to get more information on shipping information, picking up options and ordering instructions