unicorn pyo
PYO Cookie
$25.00 Buy Now

PYO Cookie


Four Paint Your Own Cookies with skittles in each box!

Different Characters are available to choose from. Mini Brush included.

Pick your character and add it to your cart.

(1 customer review)

Add a handwritten message to your recipient

Select delivery location

Free Ontario shipping on all orders over $100

  • Licensed, Foodsafe Certified, BBB Accredited, Insured, FDA Approved
  • Order before 7 pm for next day dispatch
  •  Order TODAY & Pick your SHIPPING date on checkout
Guaranteed Safe Checkout

PYO Cookie

Painting your cookie has been all the rage in the last few seasons. The tiniest bit of water will turn your Skittles’ colours into a paint pallet.

Each of these handy little individually wrapped cookie kits comes with:

  • 1 Paint Your cookie
  • Skittles
  • a mini brush.

These Kits are perfect for any afternoon.

If the PYO Cookie is not enough for your crafter, check out The Ultimate DIY Kit.

Pick your Quantity, pick your theme and add to your cart today. 


Unique, Creative + Local!

We pride ourselves on being different and not following the crowd. So you will always find something unique and fun at Carla’s Cookie Box.

All of our ingredients are sourced locally, right here in Ontario, supporting Ontario Farmers.

Gifts for Everyone!

We offer gift packaging for a fee for some of our more popular gifts. We can wrap it up for you in a special way. There are many options for you to give your extra-special goods as gifts.

Marble Smash Heart - Valentine’s
gift wrapping

Shipping + Pickup!

Our shipping is quite extensive and unique, just like us! We ship all across Canada and the USA.

Upon checkout, choose your SHIPPING date, NOT delivery date.

If you are shipping your items in the GTA, click the LOCAL SHIPPING FAQ for more information.

If you are shipping your products to other parts of Ontario, Canada or the USA, please click SHIPPING INFORMATION for more information. 

Please click PICKUP for our pickup options. 

Allergy Alert!

Although we have items that do not have nuts in them, our facility does therefore we are NOT a nut-free environment. 

All Products are made in a facility that contains Peanuts, Tree nuts, wheat, dairy and any other known allergen.


Additional information

Weight 1 lbs
Dimensions 12 × 9 × 4 in

Carla's Cookie Box


Carla's Cookie Box


Butter, Corn Starch, Eggs, Flour, Icing Sugar, Salt, Sugar, Vanilla Extract

Country of Manufacture


1 review for PYO Cookie

  1. Eva Bosnjak

    Not only does Carla make the best cookies and butter tarts but she’s also the sweetest! I have celiac and haven’t had a butter tart for nearly a decade and it was beyond delicious! My 2 year old son normally just eats icing from cookie kits as he doesn’t care for the cookie but one bite of Carla’s cookie, he became a Cookie Monster! The cookies & tarts came nicely packaged with contactless drop off! Can’t wait to enjoy her sweets again!