Gourmet Butter Tart Subscription Box – 3 months
$0.00 / month for 3 months Subscription 3-month total subscription including Shipping at $99.00 Subscribe and Save

Gourmet Butter Tart Subscription Box – 3 months

$0.00 / month for 3 months Subscription 3-month total subscription including Shipping at $99.00

It’s Not Just a Butter Tart, It’s an Experience

Three months Features:

Receive SIX Award-Winning Handcrafted Gourmet Butter Tarts per month for THREE consecutive months!

Scroll down to the description for details.

Choose your favourite flavours and add them to your cart today.

(11 customer reviews)

Choose your month 1 butter tarts

Choose your month 2 butter tarts

Choose your month 3 butter tarts

Add a handwritten on your order for your receiver

Guaranteed Safe Checkout

Subscription Boxes Gourmet Butter Tart – 3 months

Receive SIX Award-Winning Handcrafted Gourmet Butter Tarts per month for THREE consecutive Months!

Our 3-month Award Winning Gourmet Butter Tarts Subscriptions make a GREAT gift.

How it Works:

You are charged an initial 3-month minimum subscription, including shipping. After that, we may add additional shipping for distant areas.

After three months, your credit card will be charged each month for a pack of SIX Award-Winning Gourmet Butter Tarts plus Shipping.

You can cancel AFTER the 3-month minimum subscription.

Shipping Butter Tart Subscriptions FYI:

When you sign up for a butter tart subscription, we will send you your first month’s subscription immediately, or on the date you indicate. After that, subscriptions will follow once a month in the middle of the month (about the 15th of the month).

Gift for Someone Else?

If your butter tart subscription is a gift, you can print the gift certificate at the bottom of this message.

Ensure to include the mailing address, phone number and email address of your recipient and the date you send the gift certificate to them.

Once you give them their subscription Gift Certificate (keep scrolling to find it below), your recipient can email us to redeem their subscription.

Ingredients Include:

  • 100% Butter
  • 100% Ontario Maple Syrup
  • Brown Sugar
  • Eggs

Butter Tart Flavours

Traditional Pack: Plain, Pecan, Raisin

Fan Favourites Pack: Plain, Pecan, Salted Caramel, Toffee, Peanut Butter & Chocolate Chip, Nutella

Baker’s Choice: Plain, Pecan, Caramel Glazed Walnut, Turtle, Toffee, M&M’s

Summer Sizzler: Plain, Brownie Explosion, Cherry Cheesecake, OH! Henry, Boston Cream Donut, M&M’s

3 month GC 1

Allergy Alert!

Although we have items that do not have nuts in them, our facility does therefore we are NOT a nut-free environment. 

All Products are made in a facility that contains Peanuts, Tree nuts, wheat, dairy and any other known allergen.

pecan butter tart
gift wrapping

Shipping + Pickup!

Our shipping is quite extensive and unique, just like us! We ship all across Canada and the USA.

Upon checkout, choose your SHIPPING date, NOT delivery date.

If you are shipping your items in the GTA, click the LOCAL SHIPPING FAQ for more information.

If you are shipping your products to other parts of Ontario, Canada or the USA, please click SHIPPING INFORMATION for more information. 

Please click PICKUP for our pickup options. 

Additional information

Weight 2 lbs
Dimensions 10 × 9 × 3 in

Brown Sugar, Butter, Cider Vinegar, Eggs, Flour, Ontario Maple Syrup, Salt, Vegetable Shortening

Add On Ingredients

Caramel, Chocolate Chips, Coconut, Lemon Curd, Nutella, Peanut Butter, Peanuts, Pecans, Raisins, Raspberry Sauce, Sea Salt, Strawberry Sauce, Toffee, Walnuts


Carla's Cookie Box


Carla's Cookie Box



11 reviews for Gourmet Butter Tart Subscription Box – 3 months

  1. Hamza B.

    Just wanted to reach out say that the tarts were absolutely amazing. Didn’t last more than a few hours. Great product, great service.

  2. Heather B.

    We received the tarts the next day and they are now gone! Delicious!!

  3. James F.

    My parents have loved the tarts they have tried so far (it was there Christmas gift).

  4. Cheryl T.

    OMG your buttertarts are delicious!!

  5. Katie M.

    We would like plain for the remainder of our subscription, please. Thanks so much! They are delicious.

  6. Seda F

    The butter tart delivery came today so thank you! There was so much excitement in the house! We had our first couple tonight and they were REALLY good!! Unanimously delicious from the whole family!

  7. Julie T.

    it was just hard to decide what to eat first!! lol. They are delicious!! 😋

  8. Frank D.

    Received Month 1 Classic tarts -delicious

  9. Pat F.

    I received the order with thanks. Also I appreciate the great customer service. Love your butter tarts. They are the best!!!! Pat

  10. Christina I

    Absolutely love love loved my whole experience with Carla! Butter tarts are a 10/10! I got the 3 month butter tart subscription for my boyfriends birthday instead of a cake b/c he hates cake and LOVES butter tarts. We got the pecan, cherry cheesecake, and originally apple pie, but unfortunately at the third month there were none left for the apple pie and Carla emailed well in advance letting me know, and picking another flavour! Overall 10/10! Butter tarts were a large size and soooo gooey! Delicious!

  11. Jonathan

    Such a creative idea. I gave these to my son 2 years in a row for Christmas!

Add a review

Shipping Info

We offer both delivery and pickup options.
Once you checkout, you can choose which method you would prefer, your preferred date and for pickup, you can choose your time.
Click on the FAQ link below to get more information on shipping information, picking up options and ordering instructions