Your Cart


Want to chat? blog face carla


Email Us:

An automated email message will be delivered to you within 10 minutes.  If you do not see it in your inbox please check your spam/junk mail. Make sure to whitelist our email address to ensure you receive updates on your order and other important information.


Accreditations + Reviews

We take safety, compliance and trust VERY seriously at Carla’s Cookie Box that is why we think it is important to be completely transparent with our accreditations and reviews.



We are always completely honoured by the awards we receive. Whether it is from a small local town award or a big national award, we appreciate the acknowledgment of our work.


Reviews help us grow and improve! Thank you to everyone that takes the time out of their busy schedule to review Carla’s Cookie Box.

Add your own positive 5-Star review on Google today and I will send you a special discount code for your next purchase as a thank you. 

Bonnie C.
Amazing buttertarts bought at a show at the CNE. All flavours are awesome.
Chris D.
Bought six of these amazing butter tarts recently at the Kitchener Christmas market. So many different and unique varieties, and now I’ve been sharing this with friends telling them they have to try it!
sylvia L.
OMG it’s worth every bite. Delicious and fresh.
Kathryn M.
I discovered these at the one of a kind show. They are the best butter tarts I have ever had.
Julez J
I love love LOVE Carla’s. Catching them at the CNE, One of a Kind Show and various other shows has become a tradition for many years now . The butter tarts are killer and the cookies are 10/10! You’ll have hooked the moment you try anything.
Katie R.
The BEST butter tarts I’ve ever had in my life! Wherever Carla’s Cookie Box goes, I will follow 🙂
Jennifer Y.
Great butter tarts!
Michelle J.
The most delicious butter tarts with the greatest assortment of flavours
Spencer S.
Delicious is an understatement
Cindy M.
BEST butter tarts EVER! I dream of these.
Jessica A.
I think these are probably the best butter tarts in Ontario, and I follow her IG specifically to find out where she is to get my fix.That said, I’ll happily participate in a taste test if you think you can find any better :p
Samantha H
Discovered these at the Bowmanville Applefest in 2019. Thank goodness we were able to find them again at the 2022 Applefest. These are hands down the best dessert EVER!!!! I was never really a butter tart fan until I tried one of these. They’re all good, but the Turtles one is to die for!
Cherie A.
Best dessert I’ve ever had! I can’t wait to find Your booth at other craft shows and markets to try them all.
Alexandria Jasmin A.
Andrea B.
My daughter and I bought six tarts at the CNEand they were amazing! Worth the price and the pastry was light and flakey and the was so tasty.
Eleonora G.
Wow best butter tarts on the market. The chocolate peanut butter AMAZING!
Sonya G.
Omg! Had them at the ex they are the best thing ever.
Debbie T.
Just tried your pecan butter tart. It was delicious
Justin H.
Claude Sabine G.

Where You’ve Seen Us

Media gallery

Click the Media Links Below and Watch Our Features!

Breakfast Television Logo
Premium Local Ingredients

We use locally sourced ingredients from our local farmers.

GTA Hand Delivery Available

Pick your SHIPPING date on checkout, Conditions Apply

International Shipping

We Ship Across CANADA + USA

100% Secure Checkout

Licensed, Foodsafe Certified, BBB Accredited, Insured, FDA Approved