Your Cart


Want to chat? blog face carla


Email Us:

An automated email message will be delivered to you within 10 minutes.  If you do not see it in your inbox please check your spam/junk mail. Make sure to whitelist our email address to ensure you receive updates on your order and other important information.


Accreditations + Reviews

We take safety, compliance and trust VERY seriously at Carla’s Cookie Box that is why we think it is important to be completely transparent with our accreditations and reviews.



We are always completely honoured by the awards we receive. Whether it is from a small local town award or a big national award, we appreciate the acknowledgment of our work.


Reviews help us grow and improve! Thank you to everyone that takes the time out of their busy schedule to review Carla’s Cookie Box.

Add your own positive 5-Star review on Google today and I will send you a special discount code for your next purchase as a thank you. 

Alexandria Jasmin A.
Andrea B.
My daughter and I bought six tarts at the CNEand they were amazing! Worth the price and the pastry was light and flakey and the was so tasty.
Eleonora G.
Wow best butter tarts on the market. The chocolate peanut butter AMAZING!
Sonya G.
Omg! Had them at the ex they are the best thing ever.
Debbie T.
Just tried your pecan butter tart. It was delicious
Justin H.
Claude Sabine G.
Edwin T.
My first time ordering from Carla’s Cookie Box and everything from the customer experience to the treats themselves was top notch! I ordered somewhat last minute, but Carla was able to ensure I was able to pick up my order at the scheduled time. The cookies and tarts I ordered were also some of the best I’ve ever had. I’ll be sure to order from here in the future. Thank you Carla!
Marla M.
OMG!!! These were the best butter tarts I have ever had. Carla was a pleasure to deal with and would highly recommend her butter tarts for any of your party’s or other events. Thank you again.Marla and Kayla Miller
Tina B.
Dave and Shirley A.
Marta T.
Amber G.
Isabella A.
So delish
Terry C.
Kimerly T.
Bought a smash heart for Valentine’s for my partner and sadly the delivery person smashed it for us but Carla was so very kind that she sent us a new one! Her treats were delicious and customer service alone was 10/10. Thank you.
Debbie K.
As a former Ontarian now living in British Columbia I am always on the lookout for fabulous products to send as gifts to dearly missed family. I came across Carla’s Butter Tarts and was hooked. Everyone who receives a gift of these delicious treats raves about their quality & decadence. Best and most delicious discovery! So happy! Carla is truly The Queen of Tarts!
Jennifer T.
Rohit T.
If being a Master Chef is a thing, then Carla and her team are Master Bakers!I first learned of Carla’s Cookie Box during the 2020 holiday season. After having a chance to try one of Carla’s cookie’s, I decided to place a large corporate order (400+) of cookie decorating kits that involved nationwide shipping for the 2021 holiday season.Upon reaching out to Carla, she was very thorough in helping me choose the right option for my order, stayed within my budget, and ensured me that my order would hand delivered to each recipient that it was intended for. Additionally, she helped me customize the design of the cookie box.Carla and her team were so efficient and ensured every cookie was baked with care. The cookies were delivered on time to each recipient (within less than a week of placing the order) and tasted absolutely amazing!I’m so grateful to have met Carla and have worked with her. I would highly recommend Carla’s Cookie’s Box to anyone who is looking for a large custom order or just some treats to munch on. They are so good!Thank you Carla!!!
Azik A.
The absolute best cookies, brownies and butter tarts that we have ever had. The only thing better than the baked goods, is the customer service. Thank you Carla.

Where You’ve Seen Us

Media gallery

Click the Media Links Below and Watch Our Features!

Breakfast Television Logo
Premium Local Ingredients

We use locally sourced ingredients from our local farmers.

Next Day Shipping Available

Pick your SHIPPING date on checkout, Conditions Apply

International Shipping

We Ship Across CANADA + USA

100% Secure Checkout

Licensed, Foodsafe Certified, BBB Accredited, Insured, FDA Approved