Shopping Cart

Free Shipping on Canada Orders over $100


Reviews help us grow and improve! Thank you to everyone that takes out time of their busy schedule to review Carla's Cookie Box.

Based on 164 reviews
Based on 42 reviews
Anastasiya Potapovych
05:04 19 Sep 21
These are literally the best cookies I’ve ever had. They are so soft, not overwhelmingly sweet and are a great size for sharing or enjoying all on your own. I tried the Nutella, chocolate chip, turtles and Oreo flavours. I also got the tarts but didn’t get to try them as they were a gift but from what I hear that are outstanding!! Can’t wait to order again
00:42 18 Sep 21
I was practically drooling when I saw the butter tarts on a FB photo, so I checked the website and placed an order. Will amend to review the product as soon as I pick it up. I would recommend adding an e-mail confirmation of the order (other than the proof of payment receipt from the payment process), as it would have been reassuring to know that my order was received.
Mark Fitzgerald
12:21 16 Sep 21
Gezan Wilson
20:56 17 Aug 21
The tarts are soft and delicious. The delivery is super quick. Cake bread is best in town I guess, it is soft.
Seraphina Brows & Beauty Training Academy
13:14 07 Aug 21
Delicious melt in your mouth butter tarts. I put them in my air fryer for about 8-9 minutes at 350 and it is just like an explosion of flavour that’s not too sweet. The perfect accompaniment to a delicious cup of tea.
Chantel Oliveira
01:19 04 Aug 21
Carla's cookie box blew me away! From the customer service right down the quality of the butter tarts. So ooey and gooey, just delish!! Highly recommended.
Marla Miller
02:18 02 Aug 21
OMG!!! These were the best butter tarts I have ever had. Carla was a pleasure to deal with and would highly recommend her butter tarts for any of your party’s or other events. Thank you again.Marla and Kayla Miller
AndreaD Stapley
22:56 01 Aug 21
These are THE best cookies and butter tarts ever!! My family loved them so much and they shipped fast thanks
Amal S
19:57 01 Aug 21
Best butter tarts ever
Amy CM
19:45 06 Jul 21
Carla’s Cookie Box has the BEST butter tarts. I used to think you could not have different flavours of this classic dessert but Carla’s talent proved me wrong! She also has great special occasion treats. She is also always supporting so many important causes so your treat purchases also help support the community!
23:34 29 Jun 21
This is our new favourite ‘treat’ place! I stumbled across it and am so happy I did!My daughter & her friends L💖VED their smash cakes for grad (filled with super yummy baked goods). We especially loved the super fast delivery & great packaging! We have already placed another order for a friend and I’m sure we will place many more in the future! 💖 Thanks again!
Louise Clifton
21:33 23 Jun 21
I ordered buttertarts from Carla’s Cookie Box for my hubby for Father’s Day. They were delivered promptly with a cute note attached. The buttertarts were the best we’ve ever had! I got 2 flavours- plain and toffee/caramel - don’t know how we managed to not eat them all!
Glen Hough
21:46 20 Jun 21
Got the mini bundle 6 assorted butter tarts and 6 classic brownies simply delicious..will be ordering again for sure
Elizabeth Parsons
12:47 20 Jun 21
Carla’s Cookie Box makes delicious treats! Carla is considerate and responsive to questions and, when possible, allows last minute changes. My personal favourite are The Fatties cookies (can’t go wrong with any flavour), but the butter tarts can’t be beat. She not only is a great baker, she’s a great person too - friendly and philanthropic!
12:23 20 Jun 21
Awesome. It’s ok to fall in love with these beauties.
Lidia Casciaro
21:23 06 Jun 21
Kanika Kapoor
17:12 18 May 21
Amazing high quality products! Wide variety of flavours to choose from. Highly recommended!!!!
Amanda Grossi
20:05 17 May 21
These butter tarts were the best I've had. I will definitely be ordering here again and telling my friends and family about it. The ONLY reason I didn't give 5/5 is because of the presentation. I bought some as a gift and the packaging looks no different than if you bought them in a store. I feel this would be the only downside to gifting these. I even wrote in the comments that they were a gift, so if there's some option to make them look nice, I'd like that. I think nicer packaging or even some bows or something would make these more giftable.That's really my only beef here. Everything else was perfect and I can't wait to order them again. Thank you Carla!
Ashley Doodnauth
15:00 17 May 21
Ordered 4 PYO cookies and they were a big hit with the little ones. Great engaging activity that was a delicious treat afterwards. Bonus, that they were much larger than anticipated! Looking forward to ordering more!
Van Parry
13:56 14 May 21
The fudge Brownies are amazing. Seriously. They're huge & they weigh a ton...I should too since I ate a box of them but somehow my clothes still fit. :)I received a subscription for my birthday and when I got the delivery I (hilariously) thought I'd never be able to finish them. Less than 24 hours later I was staring into the abyss of an empty box and scavenging for crumbs like some kind of junkie. Worth every impending pound 😉
Jonathan McLean
13:01 11 May 21
I ordered some things from Carla's to ship to a friend that had lost a family member. She was really helpful with selecting the right things which I greatly appreciated. There was some trouble with shipping that wasn't her fault and she took immediate action when I informed her. As a businessperson, she impressed me and definitely creates an ecosystem of trust with her clients. Thanks Carla
Joanne McCallum
15:36 07 May 21
I ordered buttertarts to send to our homesick Canadian daughter living in the US. I placed the order Monday and they received in New Jersey on Thursday. Everything went better than expected and the treats were delicious I understand. I will definitely order again.
Tamara Harries
13:38 28 Apr 21
First time ordering and won't be the last. Bought butter tarts, brownies and the big & thick cookies. Everything is fantastic- my mother says they are the best butter tarts she has had in her 80 years! Will be trying the gluten-free items next- it might make it a bit easier to finally switch as they sound like they are delicious. Everything was packaged with care and arrived in perfect condition! Will be recommending to all of my friends and one day will make the drive out there.
Tracy Ross
14:28 22 Apr 21
Carla's Cookie Box is a gem !! I have ordered cookies, butter tarts and customized Logo cookies and all have been fantastic ! Carla is so accommodating and her treats are amazing. Ordering and delivery is easy peasy too and you don't wait days for someone to get back to you. Highly recommend for any occasion.
Eva Bosnjak
19:04 17 Apr 21
Not only does Carla make the best cookies and butter tarts but she’s also the sweetest! I have celiac and haven’t had a butter tart for nearly a decade and it was beyond delicious! My 2 year old son normally just eats icing from cookie kits as he doesn’t care for the cookie but one bite of Carla’s cookie, he became a Cookie Monster! The cookies & tarts came nicely packaged with contactless drop off! Can’t wait to enjoy her sweets again!
Maria Bevacqua
14:43 11 Apr 21
I had an amazing customer experience with Carla’s Cookie Box. Carla went above and beyond to ensure my order got to a very special friend on time. Let me just say that my friend was more then impressed with her special treats. I would recommend Carla’s cookie box for her outstanding tasty product and exceptional customer service.
Isabel zeppieri
14:43 05 Apr 21
Carla provided exceptional service. I ordered a Easter Chocolate chip cookie gram and it was absolutely beautiful, and exactly what I was hoping for. The feedback given to me, was that it was the BEST cookie he has ever had. Professional, courteous and prompt service. Thanks Carla, I will definetely be ordering from you soon.
Elliot Whyte
17:37 22 Mar 21
Great customer service!
17:29 19 Mar 21
Carla is my go to for gifts for family and friends. She’s an amazing lady and an amazing baker!Her butter tarts are my absolute favourite - don’t tell my mother-in-law!
Kate Martin-Donaldson
20:20 16 Mar 21
I ordered one of Carlas Cookie Smash Hearts for my daughter’s 7th Birthday. After I miscalculated the delivery date, Carla herself personally made sure the surprise was delivered to my doorstep on time!My daughter loved the unique gift, it was delicious, fresh and personalized, truly a smash hit!I thank you for your personal touch!
Rob Dozois
01:53 15 Mar 21
Ordered from here a few times, the brownies are delicious and the butter tarts are amazing!! Especially love the Apple pie butter tart!! Ordering is easy and next day home delivery, what could be better!
Nav Singh
14:18 11 Mar 21
Walter Kemp
11:41 09 Mar 21
Bought the cookie, brownie and butter tart combo for our granddaughter for her birthday, everything was, in her words, "SO GOOD".Comments on the butter tarts were, "best ever" and she has eaten butter tarts from all over the place, frequents many bakeries in Toronto and Waterloo and Carla's were Number One.Thanks for helping to make her birthday just that little bit better.Wally and Lorraine Kemp
Nick Brons
04:18 08 Mar 21
addictive and delicious, I can see why they butter tarts are award winning
Sonia Varma
02:07 08 Mar 21
The big + thick cookies are amazing, my work staff loved them 🙂
Robert Lloyd
18:35 27 Feb 21
Smash heart was a huge success with my daughter and the the little bits I was able to sneak myself were delicious. To add, a tip of the cap to Carla as she was incredibly responsive and gracious during what is possibly her busiest time of year to any queries posed. Amazing confections, amazing customer service.
Sonia Varma
13:55 26 Feb 21
The cookies are fantastic - I really enjoy buying them as gifts - I'm receiving consistently high praise (a rare response from the picky palates of my friends/coworkers!). My parents do not eat sweets, but they made the artisan cookies disappear. I like the ease of ordering and picking up, it fits my busy schedule well and it's contactless. I can't wait to order more, and I wonder what other varieties of big&thick cookies will pop up!
Violet Fiszer
23:30 25 Feb 21
This was the first time I ordered from Carla’s. I was was a bit hesitate how the order would arrive as I will in Ottawa. First of all it came the next day and it was well packaged. The cookies and tarts were perfect. I come from a family that knows their butter tarts and these tarts are fabulous. Thick luscious filling , tender crust. The cookies are tasty too. Definitely would recommend Carla , especially if you are an butter tart aficionado, you won’t be disappointed.
Kirsten T
15:21 25 Feb 21
The best gluten free butter tarts !
Andrew Dorcas
20:33 23 Feb 21
First time customer, but definitely won't be my last. I bought a large Smash Heart and it was so easy. Online ordered. Messaged Carla on FB Messenger with some requested 'special' requests. She was great to work with. Curbside pickup was easy and ahead of schedule. Highly recommend Carla's Cookie Box.
Tim Farmer
01:19 22 Feb 21
01:13 19 Feb 21
I sent sweets and cannoli to my brother and his family. They were beyond impressed and love the sugar rush!!! Terrific service thank you for making my family so happy.. #SugarRush
Daniela Morales
23:50 18 Feb 21
Amazing desserts, amazing service.Bought a smash heart pack to gift on Valentine's Day and it was the best decision ever! The heart was beautiful and delicious, it was full of sweets inside. The best part of it all was the extra desserts it came with. Just WOW :)On top of that, I had accidentally chosen pickup instead of shipping and Carla's team made sure I got it delivered on time.Would buy again and 100% recommend to anyone who is looking for a fun, delicious and beautiful gift for a loved one.
Marisa N
16:45 18 Feb 21
Cinzia Lisi
16:28 18 Feb 21
Craig Hurl
14:23 18 Feb 21
The shipment of butter tarts to the US were delivered on time and in perfect condition. The recipients couldn't believe how amazing they were. Thanks for making the order / shipment easy to complete.
Nadia Cerelli-Fiore
04:03 18 Feb 21
I have been enjoying Carla's treats for years because they are simply delicious. Butter tarts are my favourite, especially the nutella swirl, but I also favour her cookies. So easy to order and delivery to my front door, perfection!
Deb McLean
08:10 17 Feb 21
I ordered these cookies for my sister from the Uk, she said they were delicious and they were delivered on time for her birthday. Thank yo Carla, I would definitely use you again.
Ann Shin
12:21 16 Feb 21
We ordered their Smash Heart package and absolutely loved everything in it! What a wonderful surprise for the family - beautiful presentation, the chocolate butter tart is to die for, and the huge Smash Heart was gorgeous, made of delicious chocolate with a raspberry chocolate drizzle - you could taste the berry in the chocolate! Cakepops were soft inside, the best texture we've ever tasted. Thank you Carla!
Anna Feltrin
23:32 23 Nov 20
We ordered 6 variety of tarts and 6 gluten- free tarts.
Both of my children have had to change to a gluten free diet because of health issues in the past year. They loved their variety of tarts. They said they tasted as good as they remember regular tarts tasted.
Our tarts were excellent. They were so full and so delicious.
We have had Nutella, pecan, regular. All are very good.
I will gladly order again.
Lisa G
23:59 30 Oct 20
I ordered six butter tarts today oh my god they were absolutely delicious 😋 The Nutella butter tarts omg to die for that’s how good they tasted. I would definitely order again thank you!! Job well done!
Brittany Burling
13:39 04 Oct 20
It was a pleasure meeting you yesterday Carla!

Ive been wanting to try the butter tarts for literally a good year and yesterday the tart God’s answered my prayers and made it work when my girls shopping weekend landed us at Vaughn mills for the pop up!

Let me just say these butter tarts were so worth the wait and hands down best I’ve ever tried ever!

So glad i finally got to try and experience them!
I am officially addicted to them!
Charlie G
21:29 17 Apr 20
Ordered for the first time. The whole family loved it. Great job Carla. Totally recommend. We got the Italian box and the Latino box. Food was really good. And the butter tarts! I didn’t think butter tarts could taste so delicious!
Debbie Cordeiro
14:46 06 Apr 20
We had the Pecan Tarts and Salted Caramel Tarts and they were DEVOURED by my whole family! DELICIOUS! They have the best customer service as well!
Michele Field
18:53 15 Mar 20
Sooooo tasty!!!!! Can never just xeat one!
Sue Mc Burkimsher
14:32 12 Mar 20
Our daughter and son in law got us a 3 month subscription for Carla's buttertarts and I am here to say they are the BEST we've ever had. What a perfect gift for parents who really don't need anything but the kids still want give on special occasions. Fabulous gift!!
Tracey Sebastian
01:04 10 Dec 19
I am already sad that my butter tarts are gone. I have returned two days in a row, they are just that yummy. Chocolate peanut butter and salted caramel butter tarts 😍 Seriously the best butter tarts ever! Where are you next weekend?
Donna Webb
19:56 08 Dec 19
Greatest Butter tarts ever!!
Judy Joannou
01:25 06 Dec 19
Just had a peanut butter and chocolate butter tart at the Ottawa Original Craft show, thought I died and went to heaven. Thanks Carla!
Julie Stone Gauthier
21:05 08 Nov 19
I ❤️ their Tarts. I’d give them ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️’s
Susan Adams
15:15 12 Oct 19
Is at Balls Falls this far the best I have ever had...WOW!!!
Anna Maria Reali
15:13 27 Sep 19
Omg I’m hooked on Carla’s tarts, bought 6 more yesterday at RBC market... I brag about these and you can tell so homemade.
Jennifer Brown
13:55 22 Sep 19
butter crunch buttertart!! so delishhhhhhhh
Shannon Thornton-Weir
23:05 16 Sep 19
Maybe the best butter tart I have ever eaten and that peanut butter chocolate one is absolutely decadent.
Kareena Smith
01:42 07 Sep 19
Amazing selection and absolutely delicious!
Nancy Ball Rideout
17:51 04 Aug 19
The best butter tart ever I had a butter crunch toffee butter tart ,I'm going back to Kempenfest tomorrow to get more ,
Katherine Constantin
16:19 29 Jun 19
Just had several types of butter tarts with my husband and sons at the Stouffville Strawberry festival; All the butter tarts were amazing :)!!!
Darlene Parke
21:59 24 Jun 19
We bought paintable cookies for our adult only Easter dinner and everyone had a blast👍😀
Kerry Thomas
19:57 22 Jun 19
Phenomenal butter tarts. Great pastry and the filling is perfect.
Emily Woznuk
21:30 26 May 19
Your buttertarts are delicious! o.m.g the chocolate chip peanut butter butter tarts are to die for! Absolutely delicious!
Holly Darling-Gibson
03:47 25 May 19
I bought 2 butter tarts at the Milton Handmade Market and they were delicious😋. The shells are amazing and the inside ingredients are to die for!
Denise Testa
22:11 12 May 19
omg. I bought 6 buttertarts at the 'not your mothers craft show'... no one will be able to compare. Holy crap they are perfect!
Corey Parker
14:55 11 May 19
Just bought a couple at the Lucan "Not your mother's craft show" best butter tarts I have ever had.
Jamie Samantha
13:59 20 Jan 17
I'm basically obsessed with everything this woman makes. She is wonderful to work with and her baked goods are also so creative and tasty.
Amanda Jobin
20:38 05 Nov 16
Great macaroons! Saw her at The Royal today. Thank you.
Phil Hogg
19:29 09 Oct 16
Sara Kütt
00:45 01 Oct 16
Seen Carla at Markham Fairgrounds. He cookies are so cute and yummy !!!!
Priscilla Paul
03:50 22 Feb 16
Lidia Tucci
02:18 22 Feb 16
Great to have such talented bakers in the area. Delicious & creative. ☺️
Elsa Morgillo
02:12 22 Feb 16
Melissa O'Grady
02:06 22 Feb 16
Lyrae Wand
00:09 16 Feb 16
Tania Di Lillo Palmisano
03:13 15 Feb 16
My kids teachers loved the cookie bouquets I gave then for valentines... Tasted amazing and looked amazing... Would recommend to everyone!!! Carla is so wonderful and helpful!
Monika Allard
03:11 15 Feb 16
Rosa A MacDougall
01:55 15 Feb 16
Jouella Dsouza-Sok
20:58 14 Feb 16
These bouquets are so unique and so delicious. A great gift for any occasion.
Mackenzie Anne
19:42 14 Feb 16
Amy Rideout
19:05 14 Feb 16
Yummy cookies! Fantastic, funny and glowing lady! Was pleasure meeting Carla
Lori MacDonald-Blundon
17:10 23 Nov 15
Absolutely amazing!! I highly recommend - Carla's cookies are soooo good!
Sabrina D'Angicco DiTommaso
20:31 19 Nov 15

Fan Photos

Thank you so much for sending us these great photos!

We love when you send us photos or videos of yourselves enjoying our treats. If you navigate our site, you will start seeing some of the photos you all send me scattered within our product pages.

We are working on those videos as well, so keep checking back.

Much Love, Carla 

Shop Our Great Products Today

Free Canada Shipping

On Canada orders over $100: Conditions Apply

Next Day Shipping Available

Order TODAY & Pick your SHIPPING date on checkout

International Shipping

We Ship Across CA + USA

100% Secure Checkout

PayPal / MasterCard / Visa / AMEX