Award-Winning • Handmade in Toronto
Canada’s Best Butter Tarts.
Gooey, handmade in small batches and shipped fresh across Canada and The USA
Ships fresh every Tuesday, Wednesday & Thursday
Award-Winning • Handmade in Toronto
Gooey, handmade in small batches and shipped fresh across Canada and The USA
Ships fresh every Tuesday, Wednesday & Thursday
Our Most Popular Butter Tart Boxes
Choose your perfect box — customize it or grab a ready-to-order favourite.
-
Build Your Own Butter Tarts (6-Pack)
Regular price $23.00 USD – $82.00 USDRegular price -
Single-Flavour Butter Tarts (6-Pack)
Regular price $23.00 USDRegular price
❝ Real Reactions from Real Customers ❞
Real Words. Real Reactions. Real Reviews.
Thick, Soft Gourmet Cookies
Baked fresh and packed with flavour in every bite.
-
Gourmet Soft Cookies
Regular price $23.00 USD – $82.00 USDRegular price -
Watch How We Bake & Ship Every Order
At Carla’s Cookie Box, our mission is simple — to handcraft desserts you can trust. Each butter tart and cookie is made with locally sourced ingredients and baked with care in small batches from our Toronto kitchen. We believe in honest ingredients, fresh flavour, and sharing a taste of home across Canada.
