One box of gourmet desserts is tempting. More than one box can be even harder to resist—especially when choosing a larger quantity gives you a better overall value.
Whether you are stocking the freezer, feeding a family, planning a gathering or simply protecting yourself from the next dessert craving, our larger butter tart and gourmet cookie options make the sweeter side of math easy to understand.
Why Does Buying a Larger Dessert Box Cost Less?
Baking, packaging and preparing every order requires time and materials. When more desserts are prepared together in one order, some of those costs can be spread across a larger number of treats.
That allows us to offer better-value box sizes for customers who already know that six butter tarts or cookies may not be enough.
You are not receiving smaller products or a different recipe. You are simply choosing a larger quantity of the same handmade desserts while paying less than you would by purchasing several smaller boxes separately.
Save on 24 Award-Winning Butter Tarts
Four Boxes of Six Butter Tarts
SAVE $8Choose four boxes of six for a total of 24 full-sized butter tarts for $80. Buying four individual six-packs separately would total $88.
Twenty-four butter tarts may sound like a lot—until you begin deciding which flavours to order.
Our Build Your Own Butter Tart Box lets you select up to three flavours per box, making the larger option ideal for trying different combinations, sharing with family or preparing a dessert table.
You can keep traditional favourites on hand while also making room for chocolate, nutty, fruit-inspired or limited-edition flavours.
Save on a Dozen Gourmet Soft Cookies
One Box of 12 Soft Cookies
SAVE $4Choose a box of 12 gourmet soft cookies for $40 instead of purchasing two separate six-packs for a total of $44.
Our gourmet soft cookies are thick, soft-baked and loaded with flavour. A dozen gives you enough for sharing while still leaving a few for later.
The larger box works especially well for family movie nights, weekend gatherings, office treats, thank-you gifts or anyone who prefers having more than one cookie flavour available.
Depending on the current menu, you can choose from favourites such as Chocolate Chip, M&M, Reese, Toffee, Oreo, Biscoff and Nutella.
Save on 12 Thick and Indulgent Fatties
Two Boxes of Six Fatties
SAVE $2Choose two boxes of six Fatties for a total of 12 oversized cookies for $58. Purchasing two individual six-packs separately would total $60.
Our Fatties Cookies are the biggest, thickest and most indulgent cookies in our collection. These are made for serious cookie cravings.
Twelve Fatties are ideal when you want an impressive dessert for a party, a generous gift or a personal stash that can be enjoyed over time.
Since each cookie is rich and substantial, they can also be cut into smaller pieces and arranged on a sharing platter.
More Desserts Do Not Have to Be Eaten All at Once
Ordering more does not mean that every butter tart or cookie needs to disappear immediately.
Larger boxes are useful when you want desserts for several occasions or prefer keeping extras available for unexpected guests and sudden cravings.
- Keep butter tarts available for a quick after-dinner dessert.
- Save extra cookies for movie nights or weekend treats.
- Prepare a mixed dessert platter for visitors.
- Divide the order into smaller gifts for friends and family.
- Freeze extras and thaw them when you are ready to enjoy them.
For product storage, ordering and allergen information, visit our Customer Help and FAQ page.
Which Best-Value Dessert Box Should You Choose?
Choose the 24 Butter Tart Option When:
- You want to try several butter tart flavours.
- You are preparing a dessert tray or family gathering.
- You want a freezer stash of award-winning Canadian butter tarts.
- You need several small gifts from one larger order.
Choose the 12 Soft Cookie Option When:
- You want a classic cookie box for sharing.
- You are ordering for a family, office or small gathering.
- You want several flavours in one order.
- You prefer a thick, soft-baked everyday cookie.
Choose the 12 Fatties Option When:
- You want the largest and most indulgent cookie experience.
- You need an impressive dessert or gift.
- You want thick cookies that can be divided and shared.
- You already know six will not be enough.
Buy More Now and Thank Yourself Later
Sharing is always optional, but having an extra box nearby is rarely a bad idea.
The larger box sizes give you more desserts for gatherings, gifts, freezers and future cravings while providing better value than purchasing the same number of smaller boxes separately.
Explore our complete dessert shop to compare butter tarts, gourmet soft cookies and Fatties before choosing the sweetest deal for you.
Prices and product availability may change. Please check the individual product page for current options and pricing.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I need a discount code to receive the larger-box price?
No. Select the larger box-size option directly on the applicable product page. The available price will appear with your selection.
Can I choose different flavours in a larger box?
Yes. Flavour-selection limits are shown on each product page. Our Build Your Own Butter Tart Box allows up to three flavours per box, and cookie options vary according to the selected product.
Can I freeze extra butter tarts and cookies?
Yes. Our butter tarts and cookies can be frozen for later. Package them carefully and allow them to thaw before serving.
Are larger boxes suitable for gifts?
Absolutely. Larger quantities can be shared as one generous gift or separated into smaller gifts for several recipients.
Are shipping charges included in these prices?
Shipping is calculated separately during checkout based on the selected shipping method and destination.
