Gourmet Butter Tarts
Rating:
Platter – Delicious Mini Gourmet Butter Tarts – 60
Original price was: $180.00.$170.00Current price is: $170.00.
Rating:
Platter – 40 Gourmet Butter Tarts
Original price was: $140.00.$135.00Current price is: $135.00.
Rating:
Gourmet Butter Tarts + Chocolate Fudge Brownies
Original price was: $40.00.$38.00Current price is: $38.00.
Rating:
Gourmet Butter Tarts + Soft Chewy Cookies
Original price was: $40.00.$38.00Current price is: $38.00.
Small Batch Signature Cookies
Rating:
6 Gourmet Cookie Subscription – 6 Months
$144.00 $126.00 / upfront for 6 month cookie subscription with 13% off.
Does not renew.
Rating:
Platter – Ultimate Soft Gourmet Cookie Platters
Original price was: $120.00.$118.00Current price is: $118.00.
Brownies
Monthly Subscription
Rating:
6 Gourmet Cookie Subscription – 6 Months
$144.00 $126.00 / upfront for 6 month cookie subscription with 13% off.
Does not renew.
How It Works
You Choose
Select your favourite treats from our delicious range of goodies.
We Ship!
We bake, package, and offer tracking for your convenience. Choose to ship or pick up—your choice! Please note, shipping reflects the day we send your order, not the delivery date.
You Enjoy!
The moment you’ve been waiting for! Receive your order, sit back, and savour every delightful bite.
Catch Carla’s Cookies
On the Go!
Join us at our upcoming events to taste and purchase your favorite cookies. Check out where we’ll be next and come say hi!
-
November 28, 2024
Sherway Gardens Mall – Winter
Sherway Gardens Mall – Winter November 28 – December 1, 2024 Sweeten your day with Carla’s Cookie Box! Join us…
-
November 29, 2024
Sherway Gardens Mall – Winter
Sherway Gardens Mall – Winter November 28 – December 1, 2024 Sweeten your day with Carla’s Cookie Box! Join us…
-
November 30, 2024
Sherway Gardens Mall – Winter
Sherway Gardens Mall – Winter November 28 – December 1, 2024 Sweeten your day with Carla’s Cookie Box! Join us…
-
December 1, 2024
Sherway Gardens Mall – Winter
Sherway Gardens Mall – Winter November 28 – December 1, 2024 Sweeten your day with Carla’s Cookie Box! Join us…
A
Anna M
We were able to get these delicious and mouth watering goodness in the form of pecan butter tarts at the pop up market at the David Pecaut Square, near the Metro Hall.
J
Julianne Jones
It's no wonder they are award-winning; they truly deserve the recognition. We live in Toronto, but we chose to celebrate our wedding in NYC. We wanted to...
D
Diana Maltby
Yesterday’s Barrie Butter tart Festival was very enjoyable, starting at Homestead for snack and coffee. Out of all vendors, I thankfully chose Carla’s Cookie Box for my sugar fix.
M
Mary Beth Botz
Hands down, the best butter tarts ever! The filling melts in your mouth. Carla and her team take customer service to a whole new level. We ordered our tarts online, and they arrived right on time.
T
Toni Pickard
I ordered delivery of butter tarts to my granddaughter at college in Connecticut and am about to order others for my granddaughter at college in Manhattan.
D
Dennis W
I stumbled across some amazing butter tarts to die for at the " One of a Kind " Show. I tried an assorted set of butter tarts and of course...the classic pecan butter tarts are simply fantastic. These are so addictive and to support a local business woman is the cherry on top.
N
Nijat Bakili
This is the first time we ordered from here and got 12 full sized tarts and 12 mini tarts and they were great. Personally we enjoyed the regular sized tarts....
M
Michelle Sciaraffa
CARLA'S COOKIE BOX is a personal favorite of mine when I'm craving butter tarts. She offers many different flavors which are so good.
R
Roberto Furgiuele
This is the GTA’s and Toronto’s award winning butter tarts, brownies and cookies made by Carla’s Cookie Box.
Baked in the News
Savour a Sweet 10% Off!
Sign up for our newsletter and receive 10% off your first order. Get delicious updates, exclusive offers, and all the latest cookie news, freshly baked just for you!
