Award-Winning Butter Tarts & Gourmet Treats

It's Not Just a Butter Tart, It's an Experience

Homemade with Love, Delivered with Care

Simplifying Sweetness: Explore Our Top Award-Winning Butter Tarts

Real Talk From Our Customers

Based on 293 reviews
review us on
Alexis Ekblad K.
Oh my yum!!! We tried Carla’s Buttertarts at the Bowmanville Buttertart festival and they were AMAZING!!!!!! My only complaint is they aren’t closer to Whitby 😉
I look forward to buying more from them at the next festival.
Olga Y.
I tried the butter tarts at a fair in Aurora, it’s and without the gross ingredients. It’s addictive lol. Wished they were closer as I never heard of them before;)
J H.
Amazing thank you Carla .. we ubered 2x this week .. !! I have worked in bakery’s and never taste anything like your chocolate chip cookies!!
Brenda G.
Gg L
Always a crowd pleaser! Incredible flavours, fresh and nice size. Highly recommend!
Michelle S.
CARLA’S COOKIE BOX is a personal favorite of mine when I’m craving butter tarts. She offers many different flavors which are so good. I can’t actually pin point one favorite cuz there are so many good ones. Go ahead and support local small business and she’s also a huge supporter of MADD CAN go follow her story to find out.
Toni P.
I ordered delivery of butter tarts to my granddaughter at college in Connecticut and am about to order others for my granddaughter at college in Manhattan. These butter tarts are beyond delicious, they travel really well, and stay fresh a long period after arrival. Carla is very quick in responding to questions and as helpful as can be. I hope to continue supplying my granddaughters with these treats during their college careers, especially during times of high stress, experimenting with the cookies and brownies as well!
louiesie G.
The best butter tart I’ve ever tried in Toronto. Good for gifts and parties. ❤️
Linda P.

Award-Winning Gourmet Tarts of the Month – July & August

In July & August we feature: Plain, Strawberry Sundae, Apricot, Cherry Pie, Lemon Zest, Blueberry Pie
Jul & aug butter tarts of the month

Allergy Alert! All Items are made in a facility that handles: peanuts, tree nuts, soy, milk, eggs, wheat and any other known allergies.