It’s Not Just A Butter Tart, It’s An Experience
Next Day or Same Day Vaughan Pick Up Available in 2 Hours – Order Until 5pm:
NO SUNDAY DELIVERY
261 Millway Ave, Unit 14, Vaughan, ON
Order Today and We Home Deliver or Ship Next Day
FREE Home Delivery & Shipping in Toronto & Surrounding Areas When You Spend $50
FREE Shipping Outside of Toronto Area When You Spend $75
WE SHIP ALL ACROSS CANADA! 🇨🇦 and the USA 🇺🇸
All of our Products are made in a facility that contains Peanuts / Tree nuts, wheat, dairy, soy and any other known allergen
Butter Tarts
Award Winning Gourmet Butter Tarts.
You can’t go wrong here! We have a variety of flavours to choose from.
Other Desserts
From butter tarts, cookies, brownies to cannolis, cupcakes and brownies. If you have a sweet tooth, we have a treat for you!
Catering Packs
Variety of types catering packs to choose. Heat and eat full meals serving 6-8 people.
Family Owned & Operated
Rated Top 10 Butter Tarts in all of Ontario on Foodnetwork.ca! Whether you are looking for a traditional Butter Tart, a customized sugar cookie or anything in between, Carla is the person to bring that to life. Every product is made by hand in small batches using local, high quality ingredients. We keep everything VERY close to home. Send Carla a message to cater your next event!
Graduation / MADD T-Shirts On Sale ALL Summer Long
Carla’s Cookie Box has partnered up with MADD Canada. Each of her graduation T-Shirts will see $5 donated to MADD Canada.
Package it with Butter Tarts and MORE will be donated!
Our Clients Say
Everytime I see a butter tart I have to try it….I’ve probably had at least 50 different butter tarts and these are the most perfect. Oh my gosh they are incredible!!! If these were sold in Ottawa on a regular basis it would be sooooo dangerous! I would buy as many as my freezer could fit and eat one with every meal they are that good.
Julia Batchelor
Ordered for the first time. The whole family loved it. Great job Carla. Totally recommend. We got the Italian box and the Latino box. Food was really good. And the butter tarts! I didn’t think butter tarts could taste so delicious!
Charlie G
We had the Pecan Tarts and Salted Caramel Tarts and they were DEVOURED by my whole family! DELICIOUS! They have the best customer service as well!
Debbie Cordeiro
My kids teachers loved the cookie bouquets I gave then for valentines… Tasted amazing and looked amazing… Would recommend to everyone!!! Carla is so wonderful and helpful!
Tania Di Lillo Palmisano
Absolutely amazing!! I highly recommend – Carla’s cookies are soooo good!
