Carla's Cookie Box - Home to Canada’s Award Winning Bakery

Home of the Award-Winning Gourmet Butter Tart

It’s Not Just a Butter Tart, It’s an Experience

Carla’s Cookie Box Has Been Featured on:

Breakfast Television
Cityline
Toronto Life
Recipient of the Canadian Business Review Board 2021 Best Business in Canada Award
An A+ member of the Better Business Bureau.
Ontario Made Member

PLEASE NOTE: As there are only two of us working on your orders and It is an extremely busy time of the year, there will be delays. We appreciate your patience and understanding.

Need some questions answered first? CLICK HERE

Order Your Holiday Baked Goods Today

Where You’ve Seen Us

Shop Safely and Confidently

Shop Butter Tarts

Best Award Winning Gourmet Butter Tarts
Rated 5.00 out of 5
$17.00 – $81.25 Buy Now
Mini Butter Tarts
Rated 5.00 out of 5
$13.50 Buy Now
Butter Tarts + Brownies Combo
Rated 5.00 out of 5
$30.00 – $39.00 Buy Now
Butter Tarts + Cookies
Rated 5.00 out of 5
$30.00 – $39.00 Buy Now
3 Month Butter Tart Subscription
Rated 5.00 out of 5
$95.00 Buy Now
6 Month Butter Tart Subscription
Rated 5.00 out of 5
$190.00 Buy Now

SHOP MADD – GRAD T-SHIRT CAMPAIGN

In honour of our brother, Paul, who was killed by a DRUNK DRIVER in August 2019, 10 dollars will be donated to MADD Canada from every MADD t-shirt purchase.

Shop Now to help us make a difference with Impaired Driving laws.

Real talk from our customers

Carla’s Cookie Box is a gem !! I have ordered cookies, butter tarts and customized Logo cookies and all have been fantastic ! Carla is so accommodating and her treats are amazing. Ordering and delivery is easy peasy too and you don’t wait days for someone to get back to you. Highly recommend for any occasion.

Tracy, Ross, FVP

Not only does Carla make the best cookies and butter tarts but she’s also the sweetest! I have celiac and haven’t had a butter tart for nearly a decade and it was beyond delicious! My 2 year old son normally just eats icing from cookie kits as he doesn’t care for the cookie but one bite of Carla’s cookie, he became a Cookie Monster! The cookies & tarts came nicely packaged with contactless drop off! Can’t wait to enjoy her sweets again!