Home of the Best Award-Winning Gourmet Butter Tart

It's Not Just a Butter Tart, It's an Experience.

Home of the award winning gourmet butter tart
Home of the Best Award-Winning Gourmet Butter Tarts
Gourmet Butter Tartsfrom $20Shop Gourmet Butter Tarts Now
Indulge in 12 handcrafted M&M gourmet cookies
Soft Gourmet Cookiesfrom $30Shop Soft Cookies Now
Brownie on Home page
Chocolate Fudge Browniesfrom $18Shop Fudge Brownies Now

Where You've Seen Us

Pick A Category

Award-Winning Gourmet Butter Tarts of the Month – November & December

In November & December, we feature: Plain, Boston Cream Donut, Cookies & Cream, Cappuccino, White Chocolate Reese Peanut Butter Cup and Turtle
nov & dec butter tarts of the month

Real talk from our customers

Excellent4.8 Based on 233 reviews from review us onBarbara D.Barbara D. ★★★★★ Carla’s buttertarts are the best I’ve ever had! The crust is light and flaky and the flavors are amazing. They make a perfect hostess gift or anytime gift and people are always excited when I show up with themJen N.Jen N. ★★★★★ Christina F.Christina F. ★★★★★ The absolute best butter tarts …the salted caramel is a must try for everyone . My favourite!!❤️Jen F.Jen F. ★★★★★ Amazing Tarts – never disappointed!!Steve B.Steve B. ★★★★★ Most delicious buttertarts EVER!Justin M.Justin M. ★★★★★ Most amazing butter tarts I’ve ever hadwayne D.wayne D. ★★★★★ Just like Moms, these butter tarts are outstandingMargaret G.Margaret G. ★★★★★ I am a native Torontonian living in the US and whenever I come home to visit family, my “must have” is always butter tarts. I thought I found my favourite but after discovering Carla’s it’s game over! This is the only one I crave now so much that I’m going to order it to be shipped to the west coast so I can share this delicious and nostalgic treat with all my American foodie friends! 😍VanessaVanessa ★★★★★ I tried their butter tarts at a fair, AMAZING. Love this spot. I hope they have a storefront one day because I would definitely stop by on the odd day I get a craving!js_loader

Premium Local Ingredients

We use locally sourced ingredients from our local farmers.

Canada & USA Shipping

We Ship Across CANADA + USA. Pick your SHIPPING date on checkout.

International Licensed

Foodsafe Certified, FDA Approved, BBB Accredited, Licensed & Insured

100% Secure Checkout

PayPal Secure Checkout, SSL Certified, Trusted Site Secure