Customer Reviews

🍁 Proudly Canadian | 🥇 Voted Best in Toronto | 📦 Nationwide Fresh Delivery

Handmade in Toronto using locally sourced ingredients, Carla's Cookie Box crafts award-winning butter tarts, soft-baked cookies, and rich brownies. Perfect for corporate gifting, events, or personal treats — taste the homemade difference.

Shop Now
Review Us Png

Customer Reviews

Watch a real customer share their experience with Carla’s Cookie Box handmade butter tarts and gourmet cookies.

Carla’s Cookie Box Customer Review

Published July 12, 2026 · 42 seconds

See what a customer says after trying Carla’s Cookie Box handmade butter tarts and gourmet cookies, available for delivery across Canada.

Read video transcript

You can’t tell me that’s not the best butter tart you’ve ever seen in your entire life. I’m trying Carla’s Cookie Box butter tarts, and I cannot wait.

I’m starting with salted caramel. Oh my God—it’s so gooey, but it’s also so flaky. Toffee—that is heavenly. I’m going in for a full bite of this one. What? The peanut butter on top with the gooey centre—incredible.

Who thinks of making a Nutella butter tart? Carla does, and it’s fire. Look at the chocolate on top! This is pecan. It has some good crunch and some good gooeyness.

You can literally get these shipped to your doorstep anywhere in Canada. Trust me—go treat yourself. Visit carlacookiebox.com.