Carla's Cookie Box
Prepaid Cookies Gift Subscription
Prepaid Cookies Gift Subscription
Couldn't load pickup availability
Product Details
6, 12, or 24 Prepaid Gift Cookies Shipped Monthly
A Thoughtful Cookie Gift Subscription
Give a delicious gift they can enjoy month after month with fresh cookies delivered right to their door.
- ✔️ 6, 12, or 24 cookies per month
- ✔️ Choose 1 to 3 flavours each month
- ✔️ Shipping calculated at checkout
- ✔️ Save 10% with a prepaid 3 OR 6 month plan
Guaranteed Safe Checkout
❝ Real Reactions from Real Customers ❞
Real Words. Real Reactions. Real Reviews.
How It Works
You Pick Your Treat
Choose your desserts, then select Shipping or Pickup at checkout. A calendar will appear to select your preferred date.
We Bake, Pack Fresh & Ship
We ship fresh from Ontario every Wednesday & Friday. Shipping rates are calculated in real time at checkout — no surprises.
🏬 Pickup Option
Preorder pickup is available Tuesday–Friday in Vaughan, ON. Select Pickup at checkout to choose your date and time.
🍁 Baked in Toronto – Canada & USA Delivery – Guaranteed Fresh🍁
We bake our desserts in small batches in Toronto and ship across Canada and the USA using trusted courier partners, with real-time shipping rates shown clearly at checkout.
Packaging update:
We’ve decided to bake our butter tarts in individual tins and ship them in-tin to ensure minimal touchpoints, better protection, and maximum freshness during transit. This helps preserve the delicate crust and gooey filling from oven to doorstep.
As we complete this transition, some orders may still arrive gently unmolded. Both versions are baked fresh and are the same size, recipe, and quality.
Friendly reminder: Your shipping date is not your delivery date unless it’s a local hand delivery to Toronto, Vaughan, or Brampton.
Still Unsure? Watch This
🎥 Prefer watching instead of reading?
Here’s our 2-minute video explaining shipping, delivery timing, and pickup.
▶
Cookies Flavours
Quick FAQ
Nutrition Information:
Looking for calories, serving sizes and nutrition facts?
View our complete Nutrition Guide →
Carla’s Butter tarts are the best ever. No wonder they are award winning. Not so keen on the cookies that complete the package! Will order again and highly recommend.
I love sweets but found these buttertarts overwhelmingly sweet, so much so that the interesting flavors were overshadowed and lost. The cookies were good, but nothing memorable or standout. Everything was presented nicely and looked delicious, but perhaps my expectations were too high.
Really tasty but they are a bit too big. Who knew you could have too big of a butter tart but I would rather have 12 at half the size. Taste was extemely good.
Worth every penny! I can’t wait for my next order to get here. Looking forward to the lemon!
These tarts are very big so make a very filling dessert, especially with a scoop of ice cream. I really loved the regular tarts but was not as thrilled with the toffee ones. I think I will just ask for the plain tarts in my monthly subscription
Tasty cookies and butter tarts.
The tarts are better than the cookies
Everybody loved them
This was an excellent assortment of cookies and butter tarts! They were the perfect dessert to bring to a family holiday gathering and were a huge hit. We received so many compliments, and everyone wanted to know where they came from. Everything was fresh, delicious, and beautifully made. I'll definitely be ordering again!
Be careful to note that the date you pick for shipping is NOT the date you will get your items. My items were picked up on that date but not delivered until two days later...any I only live 45 mins away from the store! Essentially I received two day old product that I paid a steep delivery fee for. Customer service was not helpful at all and didn't seem to care!
Took awhile as cross country shipping. A bit pricey as well. But reported as delicious
Out of this world delicious!!!
This is my third order. This time I felt the butter tarts had more moisture in the crust and maybe a bit oily?
Not a fan of the cookies. Not cooked
Cookies were not great. Butter Tarts were nice
Got a cookie and butter tart box for a friend. They loved it, so many options to choose and nothing broke on delivery across provinces.
I really enjoyed my order of gourmet butter tarts! Some of the best butter tarts I’ve ever had. The chocolate chip cookies were good too but prefer the tarts
Excellent and tasty treats.
Must try.
Bought a six month subscription as a Christmas gift and it was a great success! They love butter tarts and get excited as the delivery gets closer!
Such great service and most of all amazing flavours! I will be renewing the subscription! 5 stars!
Delicious butter tarts and cookies
Wonderful butter tarts. The business I took them too rate the 9.5/10
I really enjoyed the cookies. The tarts were delicious but didn't blow me away. The filling was very similar between tarts.
A little confusion about the delivery schedule but a wonderful set of butter tarts.
I gave as a birthday gift and the recipient said they were delicious
The chocolate chip cookies were absolutely delicious
Everything I ordered was absolutely fantastic!!
Whole family enjoyed your tarts and cookies. The butter tarts are not runny which I really liked. My son who can be picky loved the cookies. We have another order on the way soon!!
The plain and chocolate butter tarts were superb, the cherry tarts flavor slightly overwhelmed the tarts. The cookies were large and flavourful, though I would have liked a bit more chocolate. I guess my preference is chocolate chunk cookies. I'd like to see you do a three-chocolate-chunk cookie: dark, milk, white
Overall, we were very happy with our purchase, fine, home-made quality at a very reasonable price.
I received the order late. My neighbor just gave it to me now. I am freezing 3 immediately because it says it could last longer frozen. The one I tried now was delicious.
I ordered a tart / cookie combo for my son and his family who live out of town. I wanted to send them a special treat after they brought home their new twin babies from the hospital. So according to my son…the cookies were so good and the tarts were ‘unreal!’ I would say that warrants 5 stars!
Absolutely amazing highly recommended
