Product categories
- Brownies - Triple Threat Packs: Irresistible, Fudgy Delights (2)
- Butter Tarts: 2024’s Ultimate Must-Try Award-Winners (8)
- Cookies - Luxury Small-Batch Homemade Signature Collection (6)
- Corporate Gifts (9)
- Party Desserts & Gifts (8)
- Subscriptions - Gourmet Butter Tarts & Cookies (3)
- Wholesale Store Products (1)
Excellent
4.9
Based on 262 reviews
Kelly C.
Carla’s Cookie Box butter tarts hit the spot with a filling that’s just the right consistency—gooey but not too runny. The crust is decent, though a bit ordinary. Pro Tip: Heat them up for a better experience—the warmth enhances the flavors!
kaish A.
Delicious butter tarts!!
Ira S.
Carla’s butter tarts are incredible!!! It’s obvious why they are award winning. I had the privilege to get some at the CNE and I’m so glad I did. I tried to take a “before” picture, but couldn’t resist and had to take a couple of bites before I got home. All the flavours we got were so delish. It wasn’t just a butter tart; it was an experience! Highly recommend.
