Award-Winning Gourmet Butter Tarts – 6

$20.00$26.00

It’s Not Just a Butter Tart, It’s an Experience

Click the arrows below for detailed information

Features
  • SIX Award-Winning Handcrafted Gourmet Butter Tarts per box
  • Use Locally Sourced Ingredients
  • Supports Local Farmers

Flavour Description

Traditional Pack: Plain, Pecan, Raisin

Fan Favourites Pack: Plain, Pecan, Salted Caramel, Toffee, Peanut Butter & Chocolate Chip, Nutella

**⚠️ Caramel has a HIGH probability of leaking when shipped; order with caution ⚠️ **

Baker’s Choice: Plain, Pecan, Caramel Glazed Walnut, Turtle, Toffee, Surprise Butter Tart

Seasonal Flavours: See Description Below

Shipping & Pick Up
  • SHIPPING and Pick up are on Wednesdays and Fridays only
  • Pick your SHIPPING or Pick up date upon checking out
  • Check the Shipping price at your cart without checking out
  • Click the link for more shipping information

(60 customer reviews)

Handwritten Card (+$4.50)

Add a handwritten card for a fee

This item is selling fast!
Guaranteed Safe Checkout

Award-Winning Gourmet Butter Tarts: A Sweet Delight

Indulge in the Perfectly Sweet Gourmet Butter Tarts

Experience the best homemade award-winning gourmet butter tarts in Canada. Each tart features a buttery, flaky crust and a rich, gooey filling. Perfect for gourmet butter tart delivery and ideal for corporate gifting or holiday gifts.

Enjoy the classic plain flavour or indulge in pecan and raspberry white chocolate variants.

Decadent Fillings to Satisfy Every Palate

Discover a tantalizing array of flavours with our gourmet butter tarts. Each tart is carefully crafted with various decadent fillings catering to different tastes.

From classic favourites like traditional butter, pecan, and raisin to unique variations like chocolate hazelnut, salted caramel, and coconut, there’s a butter tart for every palate. Experience the joy of biting into a sweet symphony of flavours that will leave you craving more.

FEATURES

  • SIX Award-Winning Handcrafted Gourmet Butter Tarts per box
  • Use Locally Sourced Ingredients
  • Supports Local Farmers

FLAVOURS:

Traditional Pack: Plain, Pecan, Raisin

Fan Favourites Pack: Plain, Pecan, Salted Caramel, Toffee, Peanut Butter & Chocolate Chip, Nutella – **⚠️ Caramel has a HIGH probability of leaking when shipped; order with caution ⚠️ **

Baker’s Choice: Plain, Pecan, Caramel Glazed Walnut, Turtle, Toffee, Surprise Butter Tart

pecan butter tart
Fan Favourites award-winning Butter Tarts in Butter Tart Subscription and order tracking

Craftsmanship and Quality Ingredients in Our Award-Winning Gourmet Butter Tarts

At Carla’s Cookie Box, we believe the secret to creating exceptional butter tarts lies in the craftsmanship and quality of ingredients. Our expert bakers meticulously prepare each tart by hand, ensuring that every aspect of the baking process is perfectly executed.

We source only the finest ingredients, from the creamy butter and fresh eggs to the luscious fillings and delicate pastry. Taste the difference that dedication and attention to detail make in every bite.

Seasonal Flavours:

January & February: Plain, Churro, Chocolate Dipped Strawberry, Cherry Pie, Brownie Explosion, Lindt

March & April: Plain, Eggies, Blueberry Pie, Lemon Coconut, Cookies N Cream, Rocky Road

May & June: Plain, Churro, Canadian duo, Raspberry White Chocolate, Chocolate lovers, Chocolate coconut

July & August: Plain, Strawberry Sundae, Mango, Raspberry White Chocolate, Lemon Zest, Blueberry Pie

September & October: Plain, Caramel Glazed Walnut, Apple Pie, Pumpkin Pie, Cinnamon Bun, Chocolate Lovers

November & December: Plain, Raspberry White Chocolate, White Chocolate Reese’s Cup, Turtle, Cookies & Cream, Cappuccino

Enjoy Our Award Winning Gourmet Butter Tarts Today

Don’t deny yourself the pleasure any longer! Join the ranks of discerning dessert enthusiasts and embark on a tantalizing journey through the world of our award-winning butter tarts. Explore our delectable selection today and savor the unparalleled joy that awaits. Place your order now and experience the epitome of butter tart perfection!

salted caramel butter tart in Shop Now: Explore an Exquisite Collection at Carla's Cookie Box

Additional information

Weight 2.5 lbs
Dimensions 10 × 8 × 2 in
Ingredients: No selection

Brown Sugar, Butter, Cider Vinegar, Eggs, Flour, Ontario Maple Syrup, Salt, Vegetable Shortening

Add On Ingredients: No selection

Caramel, Chocolate Chips, Coconut, Lemon Curd, Nutella, Peanut Butter, Pecans, Raisins, Raspberry Sauce, Sea Salt, Strawberry Sauce, Toffee, Walnuts

60 reviews for Award-Winning Gourmet Butter Tarts – 6

  1. Sonya G

    Omg! Had them at the ex they are the best thing ever.

  2. Eleanora G

    Wow best butter tarts on the market. The chocolate peanut butter AMAZING!

  3. Andrea B

    My daughter and I bought six tarts at the CNE
    and they were amazing! Worth the price and the pastry was light and flakey and the was so tasty.

  4. Samantha H

    Discovered these at the Bowmanville Applefest in 2019. Thank goodness we were able to find them again at the 2022 Applefest. These are hands down the best dessert EVER!!!! I was never really a butter tart fan until I tried one of these. They’re all good, but the Turtles one is to die for!

  5. Jessica A

    I think these are probably the best butter tarts in Ontario, and I follow her IG specifically to find out where she is to get my fix.

  6. Cindy M

    BEST butter tarts EVER! I dream of these.

  7. Spencer S

    Delicious is an understatement

  8. Michelle J

    The most delicious butter tarts with the greatest assortment of flavours

  9. Katie R

    The BEST butter tarts I’ve ever had in my life! Wherever Carla’s Cookie Box goes, I will follow 🙂

  10. Julez J

    I love love LOVE Carla’s. Catching them at the CNE, One of a Kind Show and various other shows has become a tradition for many years now . The butter tarts are killer and the cookies are 10/10! You’ll have hooked the moment you try anything.

  11. Katheryn M

    I discovered these at the one of a kind show. They are the best butter tarts I have ever had.

  12. Sylvia L

    OMG it’s worth every bite. Delicious and fresh.

  13. Chris D

    Bought six of these amazing butter tarts recently at the Kitchener Christmas market. So many different and unique varieties, and now I’ve been sharing this with friends telling them they have to try it!

  14. Andrew G.

    The first delivery of butter tarts was so good!

  15. Daryl D.

    Great, thank you; they confirmed that they enjoyed them very much (as always).

  16. Hamza B.

    Just wanted to reach out say that the tarts were absolutely amazing. Didn’t last more than a few hours. Great product, great service.

  17. Heather B.

    We received the tarts the next day and they are now gone! Delicious!!

  18. James F

    My parents have loved the tarts they have tried so far (it was there Christmas gift).

  19. Cheryl T.

    OMG your buttertarts are delicious!!

  20. Katie M.

    We would like plain for the remainder of our subscription, please. Thanks so much! They are delicious.

  21. Seda F.

    The butter tart delivery came today so thank you! There was so much excitement in the house! We had our first couple tonight and they were REALLY good!! Unanimously delicious from the whole family!

  22. Julie T.

    It was just hard to decide what to eat first!! lol. They are delicious!! ????

  23. Frank D.

    Received Month 1 Classic tarts -delicious

  24. Pat F

    I received the order with thanks. Also I appreciate the great customer service. Love your butter tarts. They are the best!!!! Pat

  25. Mandy B

    This brownie/butter tart hybrid was absolutely delicious and rich! The classic butter tart was good as well. I ended up eating the second one because it was so delicious even though I was so full ????.

  26. Lady Rose

    It was LOVE at first Butter Tart⁣

    ???? Sweet #gourmet butter tart made by @carlacookiebox comes in an assortment of delicious flavours. ⁣

    ???? These goodies are moist, flaky, and boy are they good⁣ (worth the cheat day too ????)

  27. Recipeverifier

    Pumpkin, Salted Caramel, Apple Pie, Pecan, Peanut Butter and Nutella Swirl … Carla’s Cookie Box … Delicious Butter Tarts ????????????????????????

    Thanks @carlacookiebox for the great butter tarts ????

  28. Kerry M

    My own kind of beautiful includes carlacookiebox butter tarts. Decadent & delicious…quite possibly the best thing ever ????

  29. Cherie J

    What would you do if your butter tart order arrived with half of a few already eaten? …asking for a Friend ????????‍♀️⁣

    Seriously some of the best butter tarts I’ve ever tasted!!!⁣

    Thank you @carlacookiebox for making these delights available during a f*%&ing pandemic!⁣

  30. Steve K

    I’ve often raved and recommended the best butter tarts in the world come from our friend Carla from Carla’s Cookie Box. Nice retirement spread from that wonderful woman who both Cyn and I adore. Go visit her webpage Carlacookiebox.com , like her Facebook page or follow her on Instagram and order…you will thank me.

  31. MaryAnn – Tennessee

    I got my Canadian Butter Tarts today! Thank you so much for this @wobblycat & @carlacookiebox. Love my Canadian friends & riders!
    @wobblycat now I know why you love them. They’re so darned addictive! ???? @carlacookiebox bakes the most wondrous yummies. ????

  32. Kemper

    These are the best butter tarts ever….
    Not overly sweet (just right) and the pastry is fantastic ????

  33. Taste Toronto

    We found the best butter tarts in the city, and we’re bringing them to your doorstep this weekend from the award-winning butter tart maker @carlacookiebox

  34. Flux

    I got these butter tarts by @carlacookiebox through @tastetoronto and let me tell you, these tarts hit different!!!

    So delectably scrumptious, my favourite was the maple bacon but honestly all the flavours were on point so wether you like sweet fruity flavours or rich chocolaty ones Carla has a treat for you! Follow her IG and get your order in if you want some of this goodness!

  35. Roseannaspeppers

    10/10 recommend.

  36. Karen P.

    Carla, you are the love of my life. My daddy would’ve loved the caramel walnut tarts so I’ve ordered some for myself for the weekend! Thank you!!!!!

  37. Heather H

    Carla’s butter tarts are amazing, honestly they are my fav! Carla is incredibly kind, and her customer service is top notch. I have missed seeing her at shows and markets!

  38. Victoria G

    Absolutely the best hands down! Butter Tarts are my favourite so I’m so happy I found this company who never disappoints and is always consistent with great flavours and freshness. Not to mention very easy to place an order and to receive in a timely manner!
    Highly recommended.

  39. Katherine H

    My family is very picky about our butter tarts and we were all pleasantly surprised to find out these ones checked all the boxes! The tart crusts were flaky in just the right way and melted in your mouth. The classic butter tart filling is sweet and plentiful, perfectly set. But the added flavours are where it is at! From caramels to nuts to chocolate, each special flavour was a masterpiece that made these butter tarts a must buy! Loved each one and as a bonus they freeze well, so we were able to freeze a pack to have in a few weeks. Definitely looking forward to buying these tarts again!

  40. ExpectBetterAtHome.ca

    I stumbled across some amazing butter tarts to die for at the ” One of a Kind ” Show.
    I tried an assorted set of butter tarts and of course…the classic pecan butter tarts are simply fantastic. These are so addictive and to support a local business woman is the cherry on top.
    I will have to order some more for the upcoming Xmas holiday dinners and get togethers. These butter tarts are going to be a big hit !!!

  41. Robin

    Best butter tarts in the world

  42. Sandra

    Just bought some butter tarts last night. Best I’ve ever had!!????

  43. Rosemary

    All of your butter tarts are my favourite but salted caramel is my most favourite ????

  44. Running Foodie

    Have you ever had a butter tart? If not, you are missing out! @carlacookiebox makes some of the best out there.
    Here we have the Toffee Gourmet Butter tart it is a soft and flaky pastry base with super soft and gooey caramelized butter filling. T is then topped with toffee ganache and toffee bits
    This dessert is such a decadent delight. It is extremely soft throughout with a harder exterior on the top. It is also perfectly balanced in sweetness and richness. This is a perfect dessert by all means. You get different textures and flavours in every bite.

  45. Maya

    I am celebrating with these mouthwatering butter tarts! But not just any butter tarts, award winning gourmet butter tarts from the butter tart Queen herself – Carla! I recently had the pleasure of checking out their Fall flavours, and can confirm they are amazing! ????

  46. Dianne P

    They’re delicious! We bought some at the Butter tart festival at the Paris fairgrounds. Wish we had purchased more!

  47. Shelley G.

    I picked up a bunch of tarts at the Paris Great Canadian Butter Tart Festival from an assortment of vendors and your tarts were THE BEST!!! I am super sad that I don’t live closer to Woodbridge and I am also sad that I only bought one half dozen that day! I will be much smarter next year. Please make sure you are there! Cheers

  48. Steph C

    Those tarts are amazing , we order for the first time and everyone we shared with was thinking the same , they are delicious !! Anyone that’s hesitating , don’t and treat yourself ????

  49. Krystyna S.

    Best butter tarts ever!

  50. Mel W

    Carla’s butter tarts are WORTH CROSSING OCEANS FOR ????????????

  51. Alicia W.

    Turtle is to die for.

  52. Stéphanie C.

    I was so happy when i saw this , place an order yesterday thank you so much for giving us the chance to taste them , it’s a Christmas gift or me????

  53. Shelley G

    TOFFEE! My fave!!!

  54. Sabrina

    Epic
    Of all the flavours, classic is the best! These butter tarts are HUGE and so beautiful. Brining them as a gift or potluck contribution would be perfect.

  55. Chris

    Delicious!
    Carla’s butter tarts are delicious! I tried every flavour and they were all fantastic. I highly recommend them.

  56. Michelle L.

    Out of this world
    Biting into this butter tart was like time stopping; the mad world disappeared and nothing mattered but what was happening with your tastebuds. It was like heaven. Reaching a higher plane. I’ve never had a butter tart so darn good. That salted caramel on top; I couldn’t speak, I just savoured. Unreal.

  57. Laurie M

    Best butter tart!
    Been searching for the perfect butter tart and this is it, plain or warmed with ice cream ????

  58. Danielle K

    I received my tarts yesterday and tried both the cannoli and toffee. So delicious and buttery ???????? can’t wait to try the rest

  59. Susan Bushell

    Just to let you know….the buttertarts already arrived today,!!
    That was quick this time
    The buttertarts look and taste amazing!!
    Delicious, super yummy treats!!
    You really have perfected the art of buttertart baking!!
    Thanks!!

  60. Joan

    My butter tarts arrived today and I am so happy I signed up. (Lol)
    You have a great business going and I tell my friends about it.
    You have a gift and I am so glad I get the “Toronto Star” paper to read about you.

Add a review

Shipping Info

HOW DO I CHOOSE MY PICK UP / SHIPPING DAY?

Upon Checkout (just before you add your credentials), there is a section to choose  shipping or pick up. Once you select your preference, there is a drop-down calendar to choose your pick-up/ SHIPPING date.

Please note that your shipping date IS NOT your delivery date unless you are in Toronto, Vaughan, or Brampton.

Watch the following video for clarification: SHIPPING EXPLAINED

For all other inquiries, please refer to the FAQs