order now

1st Place at Butter Tart Festival

🍁 Proudly Canadian | 🥇 Voted Best in Toronto | 📦 Nationwide Fresh Delivery

Handmade in Toronto using locally sourced ingredients, Carla's Cookie Box crafts award-winning butter tarts, soft-baked cookies, and rich brownies. Perfect for corporate gifting, events, or personal treats — taste the homemade difference.

🛒 Shop Now
Blog
1st Place win for butter tarts

1st Place at Butter Tart Festival

Carla’s Cookie Box wins 1st place at the Paris Butter Tart Festival! Taste our award-winning, handmade tarts, crafted in Toronto & shipped Canada-wide.
Picture of Carla Mawyin

Carla Mawyin

Butter Tart Royalty: Carla’s Cookie Box Wins 1st Place at Butter Tart Festival in Paris!

Move over, pastry world — there’s a new butter tart champion in town!

This past weekend at the 2025 Paris Butter Tart Festival in Ontario, Carla’s Cookie Box proudly took home 1st Place in the butter tart competition. That’s right: we didn’t just show up — we conquered, crowned in buttery glory 🥇👑.

From the very first bite, our tarts stole hearts. The flaky, golden pastry, the gooey, rich filling, and that signature hint of magic (aka secret family recipe) wowed the judges and the crowd alike. As the sun beamed down over the festival tents, you could feel the energy and excitement swirling — a celebration not just of desserts, but of craft, passion, and pure, sweet indulgence.

What Makes Our Butter Tarts Award-Winning?

We believe butter tarts are more than a dessert — they’re a bite of tradition. Every tart we bake is handcrafted in Toronto with love, using locally sourced ingredients and a time-honored method that delivers the perfect balance of crisp shell and soft, runny center.

At the Paris festival, we stood among the best — but it was our classic butter tarts that rose to the top, winning over the judges and snagging that coveted gold medal. This win isn’t just about a trophy; it’s a celebration of everyone who’s supported us on this journey, from our customers to our community.

pecan butter tart in blog 1st place at butter tart festival
Carla - Privacy Policy: Your Trust and Security Matter to Us

Behind the Scenes: Butter Tart Festival Highlights

We laughed, we baked, we posed for photos (yes, even with floating heads — check our Instagram for proof 😄). But beyond the fun, what truly made the day unforgettable was the connection: meeting tart lovers from all over Ontario, hearing your stories, and watching your eyes light up with that first bite.

Paris, Ontario, you were electric. Thank you for cheering us on and making this festival one for the books!

What’s Next for Carla’s Cookie Box?

This win fuels us to dream even bigger. Expect to see them at more butter tart festivals and see more gourmet creations rolling out soon, from seasonal butter tart flavors to exclusive dessert subscription boxes shipped across Canada. We’re here to make sure every celebration, big or small, has a sweet, buttery crown on top. 

Ready to taste the magic yourself?
👉 Shop our award-winning butter tarts
👉 Join our dessert subscription club

1st Place win for butter tarts

Thank You for Believing in Our Dreams

From our small kitchen in Toronto to the festival spotlight in Paris, this journey has been powered by you — our loyal fans, customers, and dessert lovers. We can’t wait to share more sweet victories (and sweet treats!) in the months ahead.

Here’s to buttery days, golden tarts, and the best community we could ever ask for. See you at the next festival!

🍯🥧 With love,
The Carla’s Cookie Box Team

Handmade Desserts, Delivered from Toronto

At Carla’s Cookie Box, every treat is handcrafted with care in Toronto and shipped across Canada. From award-winning butter tarts to gourmet cookies and seasonal specialties, we’re here to sweeten your day—wherever you are.
shop our bestsellers

Carla’s Cookie Box

Let’s
Connect

proudly canadian logo
Client logo
bbb client logo

Start Here

Help

Shop

bbb client logo
Client logo

Follow Us On

Instagram Facebook X-twitter Google Linkedin-in Youtube Pinterest-p

© CarlaCookieBox 2025