Carla's Cookie Box
Butter Tarts – Build Your Own Box | Award-Winning • 6 Per Box
Butter Tarts – Build Your Own Box | Award-Winning • 6 Per Box
Couldn't load pickup availability
Product Details
🥧 Award-Winning Butter Tarts – hand-crafted in Toronto and delivered across Canada.
Rich, gooey, and unforgettable in every bite. Our butter tarts are intentionally soft and gooey — not firm or dry.
Some softer flavours may have slight natural sticking — a sign of their fresh, homemade texture.
Guaranteed Safe Checkout
❝ Real Reactions from Real Customers ❞
Real Words. Real Reactions. Real Reviews.
How It Works
You Pick Your Treat
Choose your desserts, then select Shipping or Pickup at checkout. A calendar will appear to select your preferred date.
We Bake, Pack Fresh & Ship
We ship fresh from Ontario every Wednesday & Friday. Shipping rates are calculated in real time at checkout — no surprises.
🏬 Pickup Option
Preorder pickup is available Tuesday–Friday in Vaughan, ON. Select Pickup at checkout to choose your date and time.
🍁 Baked in Toronto – Canada & USA Delivery – Guaranteed Fresh🍁
We bake our desserts in small batches in Toronto and ship across Canada and the USA using trusted courier partners, with real-time shipping rates shown clearly at checkout.
Packaging update:
We’ve decided to bake our butter tarts in individual tins and ship them in-tin to ensure minimal touchpoints, better protection, and maximum freshness during transit. This helps preserve the delicate crust and gooey filling from oven to doorstep.
As we complete this transition, some orders may still arrive gently unmolded. Both versions are baked fresh and are the same size, recipe, and quality.
Friendly reminder: Your shipping date is not your delivery date unless it’s a local hand delivery to Toronto, Vaughan, or Brampton.
Still Unsure? Watch This
🎥 Prefer watching instead of reading?
Here’s our 2-minute video explaining shipping, delivery timing, and pickup.
▶
Butter Tart Flavours
Quick FAQ
Nutrition Information:
Looking for calories, serving sizes and nutrition facts?
View our complete Nutrition Guide →
Award-winning, generously sized treats that customers said are "some of the best I've ever had." Most praised the delicious flavors, fresh quality, and variety. Some noted concerns: a few tarts tasted burnt, pastry lacked flakiness for some, overly sweet for certain palates, and occasional delivery delays. Price point considered high but justifiable as a special treat.
I ordered the butter tarts and they were absolutely fabulous. I also ordered the cookies and I love them as well. Your order came quickly. Can’t say how great your product is. I since ordered again.
Omg the butter tarts are to die for. I will be placing another order very soon.
Though these butter tarts cost me a lot of money (with shipping to Quebec) they were worth every single penny!! I had a craving for butter tarts because I used to eat them regularly in Alberta, but they’re hard to find here in Quebec. I know Ontario is known for their love affair with this special treat to the point of even having a yearly butter tart festival, so I used Google and found these guys. They are chock full of delicious, smooth and perfectly sweet filling. My wife and I savoured them, but also shared one with our favourite neighbour. I posted them on my social media and a few friends have already ordered as well. Yum yum yum…
Absolutely decadent and worth every penny!
Amazing tarts...such a variety to choose from. Delicious flavors, authentic ingredients and awesome pastry. Delivery was on point. Our package arrived the day it was supposed to and we left special instructions for delivery that were followed.
All around an excellent experience and a delicious product! Have already ordered for a second time :)
These were ALL exceptional - absolutely exquisite. I can understand why these butter tarts are awarding-winning. a must-try
I started to order a few times but finally did it. I was not disappointed. The butter tarts were so delicious and I’m a butter tart snob. lol. I was very happy with my choices. I ordered cookies as well. Also delicious 😋. My favourite cookie was the Reese cookie although all were really good!! Shipping was fast and efficient.
Carla’s butter tarts? Outrageously good. Like the kind of good that makes me question every life choice that didn’t lead me to them sooner good.
Are they expensive? Yes
Did I hesitate? No
Will I buy them again? Already did
Zero regrets. Only crumbs.
struggling to try and describe a #taste…and experience. They were better than I expected them to be ! Having them shipped to rural Manitoba , I didn’t expect them to arrive in pristine condition and tasting as fresh as if I just ordered them from the counter ! Definitely worth the cost when you are wanting to have the best butter tarts ever !
I was a little bit skeptical about ordering but after my order finally arrived on the West Coast and heated them up my skepticism was erased right away! They were absolutely deliciously decadent!
I absolutely recommend trying these Butter tarts at least once. Everyone should have the opportunity to experience THE AMAZING FAVORS that you will experience with these tarts. You will not be disappointed 🤗
they were so good, can't make up my mind which was the best!!!
The tarts were delicious! I got the cherry, turtle and raisin tarts. They weren't overly sweet, but just sweet enough. The raisins ones had so many raisins in them! Lots of filling in them too! Would recommend if you want to treat yourself as they are pretty pricey. Not sure if the price of $54 was a good price, but I do appreciate the work that goes into making them. Would recommend to give a try!
I can’t say enough about this delicious treat. They arrived at my home in a a box. They were perfect. I shared them with my family and loved seeing their faces as they bit into them.
They are a great gift or just enjoy yourself!
Got these as a gift for someone and they were over the moon about it. I got to share them as well and let me say they are worth EVERY penny even though pennies are discontinued :D The packaging was gorgeous too! I will be a repeat customer.
They were okay….
These tarts ate so good.
Hi Guy, thank you! We’re so glad you enjoyed the tarts and really appreciate the recommendation. It’s always nice to hear when someone enjoys them enough to want to share the word.
Thanks again for giving our butter tarts a try!
Absolutely, without a doubt, the best butter tarts I have EVER had. Arrived “on ice”, vacuum sealed and super fresh!!
Hi Kim, thank you so much! We’re so glad you loved the tarts. Hearing that they’re the best you’ve ever had means a lot to us, and we’re happy they arrived fresh and ready to enjoy.
We really appreciate you taking the time to leave this review!
They are really good, I enjoyed every flavour I tried my favorites being the peanut butter flavour and the nutella flavour.
I love the quality of your buttertarts. What i find appealing is your thick filling and the variety you offer.
Very delicious, rich and filling.
Hi Rue, thank you for the lovely review! We put a lot of care into making our butter tarts, so it’s wonderful to hear that you enjoyed them.
Thanks again for taking the time to share this with us. We hope to bake for you again soon!
They were amazing, tasted so good.will definitely buy again
Delicious! Best tasting butter tarts I have ever had!
