Award-Winning Gourmet Butter Tarts – 6 Per Box

Shop Irresistible Gourmet Sweets at Carla's Cookie Box

Award-Winning Gourmet Butter Tarts – 6

Award-Winning Gourmet Butter Tarts – 6 Per Box

$22.00$27.00

🥧 Award-Winning Gourmet Butter Tarts – a Canadian classic with a gourmet twist.
Rich, gooey, and unforgettable, in every bite.
Handcrafted proudly in Canada.

  • SIX Award-Winning Handcrafted Gourmet Butter Tarts per box
  • Use Locally Sourced Ingredients
  • Supports Local Farmers

Traditional Pack: Plain, Pecan, Raisin

Fan Favourites Pack: Plain, Pecan, Salted Caramel, Toffee, Peanut Butter & Chocolate Chip, Nutella

Baker’s Choice: Plain, Pecan, Caramel Glazed Walnut, Turtle, Toffee, Surprise Butter Tart

Seasonal Flavours: See Description Below

  • SHIPPING and Pick up are on Wednesdays and Fridays only
  • Pick your SHIPPING or Pick up date upon checking out
  • Check the Shipping price at your cart without checking out
  • Click the link for more shipping information
The shipping experience just got better with our summer cold packing system. Your products are packed in a metallic bag and with ice packs.
Send Your Recipient a Handwritten Card
Jordan S.
Jordan S.
@jordans
A client sent us this subscription as a thank-you and now we’re hooked. We’ve already ordered it for others.
Chris D.
Chris D.
@chrisd
Bought six of these amazing butter tarts recently at the Kitchener Christmas market. So many different and unique varieties, and now I
Rosemary S.
Rosemary S.
@rosemarys
All of your butter tarts are my favourite but salted caramel is my most favourite

Description

🥇 Award-Winning Gourmet Butter Tarts – Handmade in Toronto, Delivered Across Canada

If you’ve been searching for the best gourmet butter tarts in Canada, you just found them. Our award-winning butter tarts are handcrafted in Toronto using locally sourced ingredients and a perfected small-batch recipe that’s earned us top honours at markets, festivals, and food shows across Ontario. Whether you’re ordering for a gift, dessert table, or personal indulgence, these tarts are guaranteed to impress.

Right from the first bite, you’ll notice the difference: a golden, flaky crust with a rich, gooey centre that melts in your mouth. We use only real Canadian butter, whole liquid eggs, and absolutely no preservatives—just the kind of quality you expect from a small, independent Toronto bakery. Want to build your own box? Pair your order with a Mini Butter Tart Platter, Soft Gourmet Cookie Platter, or our Chocolate Fudge Brownie Platter for the ultimate dessert lineup.

How to Order Our Signature Butter Tarts

Carlas Cookies line
Carlas Cookies Bakery

You Pick Your Treat

Choose your butter tart format – classic clamshell packs, gift boxes, or party platters made for sharing.

Carlas Cookies Deliver

We Bake & Pack Fresh

Pick your preferred flavours or go with our bestsellers. You can also add a message card or upgrade to premium packaging.

Carlas Cookies Enjoy

You Enjoy Every Bite

We bake fresh in Toronto using real Canadian butter and ship across Canada or prepare for local delivery and pickup.

🍁 Baked in Toronto – Canada wide Delivery – Guaranteed Fresh

We partner with a trusted network of Canadian couriers to deliver your Gourmet Butter Tarts on time, every time — whether it’s heading to a downtown office, a remote team, or multiple branches. Each box is packed with care to ensure your desserts arrive fresh, secure, and beautifully presented, no matter the season or destination.

💬 Have specific needs or want to tailor a custom or corporate order? FAQ or contact us directly — we’ll help create a plan that fits you or your team perfectly.

🍯 What Makes The Gourmet Butter Tarts Award-Winning?

There’s a reason these butter tarts fly off the table at every event. They’re:

  • Made with a signature gooey filling from scratch
  • Baked in small batches for consistent quality
  • Packed with premium Canadian-sourced ingredients
  • Crafted with a flaky, never-soggy pastry crust
  • Free from preservatives or fillers

They’ve been featured in curated gift boxes, dessert markets, and pop-ups across the GTA—and customers keep coming back for more.

Pecan Butter Tart in butter tart platter
Fan Favourites award-winning Butter Tarts in Butter Tart Subscription and order tracking

🍪 Gourmet Butter Tarts Flavours That Deliver

We offer a rotating mix of bestsellers, depending on seasonal availability:

  • Plain – Smooth, rich, and timeless
  • Pecan – Roasted crunch on top of buttery filling
  • Raisin – A classic twist with plump raisins
  • Nutella – Chocolate hazelnut meets Canadian tradition
  • Salted Caramel – Buttery, sweet, and slightly salty
  • Toffee – Deep caramelized flavour and soft finish

If you’re looking for even more variety or seasonal releases, try our Butter Tart Platter or Personal Dessert Subscription for rotating monthly drops.

📦 How It’s Packaged

  • Toronto-area delivery or pickup: Tarts come in a clamshell container—fresh, unwrapped, and presentation-ready.
  • Canada-wide shipping: Each tart remains in the clamshell but is wrapped and cushioned in a sturdy shipping box for safe delivery.
  • Want a gift upgrade? Add our signature pink CCB gift box at checkout for a polished final touch.

Orders are carefully packed from our Toronto kitchen and always arrive fresh and ready to enjoy.

🎁 Perfect For:

  • 🎂 Birthdays, holiday tables, and bridal brunches
  • 🏢 Staff appreciation, client gifting, and office events
  • 💌 Thoughtful deliveries to friends, family, and colleagues
  • 🛋️ Dessert nights, coffee breaks, and “just because” moments
  • ✈️ Gifts that ship beautifully across Canada

For large gatherings, events, or corporate packages, consider combining your order with our Mini Butter Tart Platter or Individually Packaged Treats for easy distribution.

🛒 How to Order Gourmet Butter Tarts

✔️ Select your desired flavour mix
✔️ Choose your delivery or pickup option
✔️ Optional: Upgrade to gift box packaging
✔️ Add a message card at checkout
✔️ Enjoy Canada’s most iconic tart—done the right way

salted caramel butter tart in Shop Now: Explore an Exquisite Collection at Carla's Cookie Box

Specialty Butter Tart Packs:

Traditional Pack: Plain, Pecan, Raisin
Fan Favourites Pack: Plain, Pecan, Salted Caramel, Toffee, Peanut Butter & Chocolate Chip, Nutella
Baker's Choice: Plain, Pecan, Caramel Glazed Walnut, Turtle, Toffee, Surprise Butter Tart

Seasonal Flavours:

January & February: Plain, Chocolate Dipped Strawberry, Cherry Pie, Dulce de Churro, Chocolate Lindt, Brownie Explosion
March & April: Plain, Eggies, Blueberry Pie, Lemon Coconut, Rocky Road, Cookies N Cream
May & June: Plain, Churro, Canadian duo, Raspberry White Chocolate, Chocolate lovers, Chocolate coconut
July & August: Plain, Strawberry Sundae, Apricot, Cherry Pie, Lemon Zest, Blueberry Pie
September & October: Plain, Caramel Glazed Walnut, Apple Pie, Pumpkin Pie, Cinnamon Bun, Chocolate Lovers
November & December: Plain, Raspberry White Chocolate, White Chocolate Reese's Cup, Turtle, Cookies & Cream, Cappuccino

FAQ: Award-Winning Gourmet Butter Tarts

Are these full-size butter tarts?
How many tarts come in a box?
Can I choose the flavours?
Are seasonal flavours available?
Is gift wrapping available?

Additional information

Additional information

Weight 3 lbs
Dimensions 10 × 8 × 3 in
Ingredients

Brown Sugar, Butter, Cider Vinegar, Eggs, Flour, Ontario Maple Syrup, Salt, Vegetable Shortening

Add On Ingredients

Caramel, Chocolate Chips, Coconut, Lemon Curd, Nutella, Peanut Butter, Pecans, Raisins, Raspberry Sauce, Sea Salt, Strawberry Sauce, Toffee, Walnuts

Customer Review

5.0
Based on 90 reviews
5 star
100
100%
4 star
0%
3 star
0%
2 star
0%
1 star
0%
1-5 of 90 reviews
  1. KC

    Best butter tarts ever!

  2. SC

    Those tarts are amazing , we order for the first time and everyone we shared with was thinking the same , they are delicious !! Anyone thatÕs hesitating , donÕt and treat yourself

  3. R

    All of your butter tarts are my favourite but salted caramel is my most favourite

  4. SL

    OMG itÕs worth every bite. Delicious and fresh.

  5. CD

    Bought six of these amazing butter tarts recently at the Kitchener Christmas market. So many different and unique varieties, and now IÕve been sharing this with friends telling them they have to try it!

Shipping Info

How do I choose my pickup or shipping day?

During checkout (just before you enter your payment info), you’ll see an option to choose either shipping or pickup. Once selected, a calendar will appear for you to pick your preferred pickup or shipping date. Note: Your shipping date is not your delivery date unless you’re located in Toronto, Vaughan, or Brampton. 🎥 Watch this quick video for a full explanation: Shipping Explained Still have questions? Visit our full FAQs page.

Related Products

Allergy Alert! All Items are made in a facility that handles: peanuts, tree nuts, soy, milk, eggs, wheat and any other known allergies.