No Walk-Ins — Please Pre-order Online Before Pickup 😊

Butter Tarts

🍁 Proudly Canadian 🥇 Award-Winning 📦 Canada & USA-Wide Shipping 🛍️ Preorder pickup available in Vaughan, ON
Need help ordering?

turtle butter tart
Assorted gourmet butter tarts from Carla’s Cookie Box in six flavours including classic, pecan, toffee, peanut butter, chocolate, and maple, arranged in a circular pattern on a white background
★★★★★

Butter Tarts – Build Your Own Box | Award-Winning • 6 Per Box

Price range: $22.00 through $80.00

Order Now
Butter Tarts – Single Flavour Quick Pick Box
★★★★★

Butter Tarts – Single Flavour Quick Pick Box

$22.00

Order Now
Gourmet butter tarts and chocolate chip cookies combo from Carla’s Cookie Box, featuring assorted butter tart flavours with soft baked cookies on a white background.
★★★★★

Gourmet Butter Tarts (6) & Chocolate Chip Cookies (6) Combo

$42.00

Order Now
Individually packaged gourmet butter tart from Carla’s Cookie Box in a gold foil cup with clear dome lid, sealed for freshness
★★★★★

Individually Packaged Award Winning Gourmet Butter Tarts

Starting @ $4

Order Now
Assorted butter tart platter from Carla’s Cookie Box with flavours including classic, chocolate, toffee crumble, and sprinkle-topped tarts arranged on a silver serving tray.
★★★★★

Platter – Delicious Mini Gourmet Butter Tarts – 60

Price range: $180.00 through $192.00

Order Now
Assorted gourmet butter tart platter from Carla’s Cookie Box featuring chocolate, toffee crumble, peanut butter drizzle, and classic flavours arranged on a silver tray.
★★★★★

Platter – 40 Award-Winning Gourmet Butter Tarts

Price range: $150.00 through $180.00

Order Now
Assorted gourmet butter tarts from Carla’s Cookie Box displayed on a wooden board, featuring chocolate, pecan, classic, toffee, and candy-topped flavours.
★★★★★

Bulk Corporate Butter Tarts – 12 Packs of 6 per Case

Bulk price $198/case - Min 2 cases

Order Now
Turtle Profile

Butter Tart Subscriptions – Delivered Monthly!

Click the Button Below!

Try one of our subscription boxes and get your favourite butter tarts delivered fresh every month — across Canada and the USA.

Shop Dessert Subscriptions!

📋 How to Order 💬 FAQ 📦 Shipping & Pickup Info

Shop More Desserts

❝ People Love Carla’s Cookie Box ❞

Real Words. Real Reactions. Real Reviews.

Gourmet Butter Tarts: 2025’s Ultimate Must-Try Award-Winners

Discover the ultimate indulgence with Carla’s Award-Winning Butter Tarts. Crafted with a buttery, flaky crust and rich, gooey filling, these tarts are available in various flavours, including plain, pecan, and raspberry white chocolate.

Perfect for corporate gifting, holiday gifts, or personal treats, these butter tarts are celebrated as Toronto’s best homemade butter tarts.

Order now for gourmet butter tarts delivered straight to your door.

Once you’ve added your treats, head to checkout to complete your order.

Assorted gourmet butter tarts from Carla’s Cookie Box in six flavours including classic, pecan, toffee, peanut butter, chocolate, and maple, arranged in a circular pattern on a white background

How It Works

Carlas Cookies Bakery

You Choose

Choose from our bestselling butter tarts, gourmet cookies, brownies, or giftable dessert boxes. Select your flavours, size, and any extras you’d like to include.

Carlas Cookies Deliver

We Ship!

We bake, package, and offer tracking for your convenience. Choose to ship or pick up—your choice! Please note, shipping reflects the day we send your order, not the delivery date.

Carlas Cookies Enjoy

You Enjoy!

From the moment it arrives, it’s all about indulgence. Unbox, snack, and savour every bite—whether you're gifting it or keeping it for yourself.

🍁 Baked in Toronto – Canada & USA Delivery – Guaranteed Fresh

We partner with a trusted network of couriers to deliver your Gourmet Baked Desserts across Canada and the USA — whether it’s heading to a downtown office, a remote team, or multiple branches. Each box is carefully packed to ensure your desserts arrive fresh, secure, and beautifully presented, no matter the season or destination.

🏬 Prefer to pick up your order? Preorder pickup is available Tuesday–Friday in Vaughan, ON for local customers.

💬 Have specific needs or want to tailor a custom or corporate order? FAQ or contact us directly — we’ll help create a plan that fits you or your team perfectly.

🎥 How to Order & Shipping – Watch Before Checkout

Questions about ordering, shipping dates, or FAQs?
Watch these quick videos:

  • How to Order – Step-by-step checkout guide
  • Shipping Explained – Delivery timing & method
  • FAQ Highlights – Quick answers to top questions

🚚 Shipping Info

We ship fresh from Ontario every Wednesday & Friday. 📦 Rates are calculated in real time—no surprises. 🇨🇦 We ship across Canada & the USA with ClickShip couriers.

🏬 Pickup Option

Preorder pickup available Tuesday–Friday in Vaughan, ON. Select Pickup at checkout to choose your preferred date and time.

Choosing Your Delivery or Pickup Date:
At checkout, select shipping or pickup. A calendar will appear for date selection.

🎥 Watch: Shipping Explained

📦 Reminder: Shipping date is not your delivery date unless it’s a HAND DELIVERY to Toronto, Vaughan, or Brampton.

Still unsure? Check our full FAQ or visit our Help Page.

General Customer Help & FAQ

If you're experiencing any issues, try refreshing the page, clearing your browser cache, or switching devices. Still need help? Please contact our team directly.
Due to the perishable nature of our products, we do not accept returns. For more details, view our Terms & Conditions.
Please email us with your order number and a photo of what you received through our Customer Support page. We'll work quickly to make it right.
I’m sorry to hear your order arrived damaged. We take great care in packaging every product to protect it during transit, but once it’s in the hands of the courier, it’s unfortunately out of our control..
You can reach us through our Contact page or by replying to your order confirmation email. We typically respond within 24–48 hours.
Orders can be modified or cancelled if we receive notice at least 72 hours before your delivery or pickup date. Please contact us for assistance.
We recommend ordering at least 5 days in advance. For busy holidays or custom events, order 1–2 weeks ahead if possible. You can view our full selection on the Shop page.

Orders & Shipping – Customer Help & FAQ

During extreme heat, we may delay shipments to preserve quality. You'll be notified by email if your order is affected. Also, you can choose Cold Packing when you place your order. For urgent questions, please contact us.
Standard shipping takes approximately 2–5 business days, depending on your location. Pickup and GTA delivery are usually faster. Check our Shop page for local options.
We partner with several trusted courier services depending on the destination. You'll receive a tracking link once your order ships. See details at Shipping Info.
We do not currently offer same-day delivery. However, please contact us if you have an urgent request — we’ll try our best to accommodate it.
Shipping rates are automatically calculated at checkout based on your location and the weight of your order. Orders over a certain amount may qualify for free shipping promotions.
At checkout, you can select your preferred pickup or shipping date. If you have a specific event date, please note it in your order comments or contact us.
Your account is automatically created when you place your first order. You will receive an email to set your password. Manage your orders anytime through the My Account page.
If your order hasn't shipped yet, please contact us immediately with the updated shipping information.
Yes! Pickup is available at our Vaughan location. Select "Pickup" at checkout, and we’ll email you detailed instructions. Find more info on our Contact page.
You'll receive a tracking link via email once your order is shipped. You can also view tracking updates by logging into your My Account.
While we cannot guarantee specific delivery times, you can leave a request in the order notes at checkout. We will do our best to accommodate special requests — or contact us to discuss options.
Yes, we offer corporate gifting and large order delivery services. Visit our Corporate Subscriptions page or contact us for personalized help.
No — for your security, we do not store any payment information. All transactions are processed securely by our trusted payment partners. Read more in our Privacy Policy.
Your credit card is charged immediately upon placing your order through our website.
Yes! We offer nationwide shipping for all our butter tarts, cookies, and brownies so you can enjoy our treats anywhere in Canada and the USA.
We currently ship across Canada and the USA. For international corporate orders, please contact us to discuss special arrangements.

Product Information – Customer Help & FAQ

Want a peek behind the scenes? Watch our kitchen in action on Instagram !
Yes, we offer wholesale partnerships for qualified retailers and food service clients. Please contact us for details and pricing information.
Our desserts stay fresh for 5–7 days when stored in an airtight container at room temperature. For longer storage, freeze them and enjoy later. Learn more about care instructions on our Shop page.
We are not a certified allergen-free facility. Cross-contamination is possible. Please contact us before ordering if you have specific allergy concerns.
No, we are not a nut-free facility. Some products may not contain nuts but are made in an environment where nuts are present. Always check our Shop page or contact us for more information.
At this time, we do not offer gluten-free desserts. Stay tuned for future updates by subscribing to our newsletter.
No. We proudly use Canadian butter and vegetable-based fats in all our recipes — never animal lard. Learn more about our ingredients on the Our Story page.
Yes! We offer monthly dessert subscriptions for personal and corporate clients. Explore options on our Personal Subscriptions page or Corporate Subscriptions page.