• Fan Favourite
  • Nutella Slow Pull
  • Fan Favourite
  • Baker's Choice
  • Traditional
  • Seasonal - Jan & Feb
  • Seasonal - Mar & Apr
  • Seasonal - May & Jun
  • Seasonal - Jul & Aug
  • Seasonal - Sep & Oct
  • Seasonal - Nov & Dec
  • Plain
  • Pecan
  • Raisin
  • Peanut Butter & Chocolate Chip
  • Nutella
  • Salted Caramel
  • Turtle
  • Caramel Glazed Walnut
  • Biscoff
  • Raspberry White Chocolate
  • Toffee
1 22

Carla's Cookie Box

Butter Tarts – Build Your Own Box | Award-Winning • 6 Per Box

Butter Tarts – Build Your Own Box | Award-Winning • 6 Per Box

From $22.00 CAD

1. How Many Do You Need?
$22.00 CAD
$22.00 CAD
Sale Sold out
Shipping calculated at checkout.

Product Details

✨ Reviews 🍪 Flavour Description 👉 How to Order

🧁 Award-Winning Gourmet Butter Tarts – a Canadian classic with a gourmet twist.

Rich, gooey, and unforgettable, in every bite.

Handcrafted proudly in Canada.

Guaranteed Safe Checkout

Guaranteed Safe Checkout

Customers are saying

4.91 ★ (1507)
Verified
View full details

🥇 Award-Winning Gourmet Butter Tarts – Handmade in Toronto, Delivered Across Canada and the USA. Pickup available in Vaughan, ON.

If you’ve been searching for the best gourmet butter tarts in Canada, you just found them. Our award-winning butter tarts are handcrafted in Toronto using locally sourced ingredients and a perfected small-batch recipe that’s earned us top honours at markets, festivals, and food shows across Ontario. Whether you’re ordering for a gift, dessert table, or personal indulgence, these tarts are guaranteed to impress.

Right from the first bite, you’ll notice the difference: a golden, flaky crust with a rich, gooey centre that melts in your mouth. We use only real Canadian butter, whole liquid eggs, and absolutely no preservatives—just the kind of quality you expect from a small, independent  Toronto bakery . Want to build your own box? Pair your order with a  Mini Butter Tart Platter, Soft Gourmet Cookie Platter ,or our Chocolate Fudge Brownie Platter for the ultimate dessert lineup.

🍯 What Makes The Gourmet Butter Tarts Award-Winning?

There’s a reason these gourmet butter tarts fly off the table at every event. They’re:

  • Made with a signature gooey filling from scratch
  • Baked in small batches for consistent quality
  • Packed with premium Canadian-sourced ingredients
  • Crafted with a flaky, never-soggy pastry crust
  • Free from preservatives or fillers

They’ve been featured in curated gift boxes, dessert markets, and pop-ups across the GTA—and customers keep coming back for more.

🍯 What Makes The Gourmet Butter Tarts Award-Winning?

How It Works

You Pick Your Treat

Choose your desserts, then select Shipping or Pickup at checkout. A calendar will appear to select your preferred date.

We Bake, Pack Fresh & Ship

We ship fresh from Ontario every Wednesday & Friday. Shipping rates are calculated in real time at checkout — no surprises.

🏬 Pickup Option

Preorder pickup is available Tuesday–Friday in Vaughan, ON. Select Pickup at checkout to choose your date and time.

🍁 Baked in Toronto – Canada & USA Delivery – Guaranteed Fresh🍁

We bake our desserts in small batches in Toronto and ship across Canada and the USA using trusted courier partners, with real-time shipping rates shown clearly at checkout.

Packaging update:

We’ve decided to bake our butter tarts in individual tins and ship them in-tin to ensure minimal touchpoints, better protection, and maximum freshness during transit. This helps preserve the delicate crust and gooey filling from oven to doorstep.

As we complete this transition, some orders may still arrive gently unmolded. Both versions are baked fresh and are the same size, recipe, and quality.

Friendly reminder: Your shipping date is not your delivery date unless it’s a local hand delivery to Toronto, Vaughan, or Brampton.

Still Unsure? Watch This

🎥 Prefer watching instead of reading?

Here’s our 2-minute video explaining shipping, delivery timing, and pickup.

▶

Quick FAQ

Not at this time. Our tart shells are made with wheat flour. We are exploring gluten-free options, but cannot guarantee a gluten-free environment for those with severe sensitivities.

While we offer butter tarts made without nuts, our bakery is not nut-free. Cross-contamination is possible, so we advise caution for those with allergies.

No, we never use lard. Our crust is made with a premium blend of real butter and non-hydrogenated vegetable shortening for that golden, flaky texture.

Limiting flavours helps us keep orders fresh, fast, and beautifully packed. It ensures your box arrives on time, with perfect presentation and consistency—especially during busy seasons.

Yes! You can choose up to 3 flavours per box. To enjoy more flavours, feel free to mix and match across multiple boxes.

Each box includes 6 full-size tarts. Looking to stock up or gift? You can select multiple boxes at checkout.

Ingredients
Wheat flour, sugars (brown sugar, Canadian maple syrup, granulated sugar), butter (milk), eggs, vegetable shortening, apple cider vinegar, salt.

Allergen Information
Contains wheat, milk, and eggs. Made in a facility that also processes peanuts, tree nuts, and soy. Products are not nut-free and cross-contamination may occur.

Made with real Canadian maple syrup and butter.

BUY NOW