Personal Dessert Subscription –
Monthly Treats Delivered
✅ Handcrafted in Toronto ✅ Free Shipping Canada-wide 🍪 Choose Your Flavours Monthly 🎁 Makes a Perfect Gift
Canada’s Sweetest Subscription Starter
🍪 6 Freshly Baked Desserts
Get 6 handcrafted butter tarts or cookies every month — made in Ontario, shipped nationwide
- ✔️ 6 dessert pieces/month
- ✔️ Choose 1 flavour per month
- ✔️ Shipping Included
- ✔️ Save 10% with a PREPAID 3, 6 or 12-month plan
Starting at $60 /month
Bestselling Size – A Dessert Box That Delivers
🍰 12 Rich & Creamy Desserts
Choose your flavours, pick your plan, and enjoy a fresh box of 12 every month
- ✔️ 12 desserts/month
- ✔️ Choose 2 flavours
- ✔️ Shipping Included
- ✔️ Save 10% with a PREPAID 3, 6 or 12-month plan
Starting at $120 /month
Our Biggest Box for the Biggest Cravings
🎉 24 Deluxe Gourmet Desserts
Perfect for hosting, gifting, or just having “a little extra.”
- ✔️ 24 dessert pieces/month
- ✔️ Choose 4 flavours
- ✔️ Shipping Included
- ✔️ Save 10% with a PREPAID 3, 6 or 12-month plan
Starting at $240 /month
How Dessert Subscriptions Works
You Choose
Choose a prepaid plan — 3, 6, or 12 months, INCLUDING SHIPPING.
Pick your dessert flavours for each month. You can send it to yourself or as a gift.
We Ship Monthly!
Once your order automatically populates in our system, we bake everything fresh, pack it with care, and ship your box once a month.
You'll get tracking info as soon as it leaves our kitchen.
You Unbox & Enjoy!
Open your box, take a bite, and let dessert day work its magic. Every month brings a new reason to smile (and snack)!
Personal Dessert Subscription Flavours
At Carla’s Cookie Box, we understand that variety is the spice of life. That’s why we offer a range of monthly dessert delivery subscriptions to cater to your unique preferences.
Our Seasonal Butter Tarts are below.
Butter Tart Flavours
Traditional Pack:
Plain, Pecan, Raisin
Fan Favourites Pack:
Plain, Pecan, Salted Carmel, Toffee, Peanut Butter & Chocolate Chip, Nutella
Bakers Choice:
Plain, Pecan, Caramel Glazed Walnut, Turtle, Toffee, Surprise Butter Tart
Seasonal Butter Tart Flavours
January & February:
Plain, Chocolate Dipped Strawberry, Cherry Pie, Dulce de Churro, Chocolate Lindt, Brownie Explosion
March & April:
Plain, Eggies, Blueberry Pie, Lemon Coconut, Cookies N Cream, Rocky Road
May & June:
Plain, Churro, Canadian duo, Raspberry, Chocolate Lovers, Chocolate Coconut
July & August:
Plain, Strawberry, Apricot, Raspberry, Lemon Zest, Blueberry
September & October:
Plain, Walnut, Apple, Pumpkin, Cinnamon Bun, Chocolate Lovers
November & December:
Plain, Boston Cream, White Chocolate Reese Cup, Chocolate Lovers, Cookies & Cream, Cappuccino
Subscription Timelines
We offer flexible subscription timelines to suit your needs:
3 Month
A great option to enjoy a season of sweet delights.
6 Month
Perfect for half a year of indulgence.
12 Month
The ultimate subscription for dessert enthusiasts, ensuring a year-long supply of our delectable treats.
A dessert subscription is designed to provide a seamless and enjoyable experience.
You can renew or cancel at your convenience through your account.
Delivery and Pickup
We proudly offer our monthly dessert delivery services across Canada and the USA, bringing our delicious treats to your doorstep no matter where you are. We also provide a convenient pickup option for our local customers in Woodbridge, Ontario. Simply select your preferred delivery or pickup method during the subscription process.
Why Choose Carla's Cookie Box?
Quality Ingredients
We use only the finest Ontario, Canada locally sourced ingredients to ensure our desserts are of the highest quality.
Award-Winning Recipes
Our butter tarts have received accolades for their exceptional taste and texture.
Convenience
Enjoy gourmet desserts delivered to your door without the hassle of baking.
Personalized Subscriptions
Customize your subscription to match your unique taste and preferences.
Sustainable Packaging
We prioritize the planet by using environmentally friendly materials for all our packaging.
Gift Subscriptions
Looking for the perfect gift? Our dessert subscriptions are a thoughtful and delicious way to show someone you care, whether for a birthday, anniversary, or just because, a monthly delivery of sweet treats will surely bring a smile to their face.
We even have Corporate Subscriptions!
Enhance your office environment or client relations with our corporate dessert subscriptions. Whether you’re rewarding employees, impressing clients, or elevating team meetings, our monthly dessert delivery options are a perfect fit.
Employee Appreciation
To boost morale and show your gratitude, treat your team to a monthly box of delicious cookies, brownies, or butter tarts.
Client Gifting
Build lasting relationships by sending a dessert subscription as a token of appreciation.
Office Meetings
Make your meetings sweeter with various indulgent desserts everyone will love.
Contact us for custom corporate packages tailored to your needs.
Celebrate Every Occasion with Carla's Cookie Box
A dessert subscription isn’t just for everyday indulgence – it’s perfect for celebrating life’s special moments.
Birthdays
Brighten someone’s special day with a monthly delivery of their favourite treats.
Holidays
Share festive flavours during the holiday season with our customizable subscription options.
Thank You Gifts
Show gratitude in the sweetest way possible.
Anniversaries
Make every month memorable with a box of delicious desserts.
A
Anna M
We were able to get these delicious and mouth watering goodness in the form of pecan butter tarts at the pop up market at the David Pecaut Square, near the Metro Hall.
J
Julianne Jones
It's no wonder they are award-winning; they truly deserve the recognition. We live in Toronto, but we chose to celebrate our wedding in NYC. We wanted to...
D
Diana Maltby
Yesterday’s Barrie Butter tart Festival was very enjoyable, starting at Homestead for snack and coffee. Out of all vendors, I thankfully chose Carla’s Cookie Box for my sugar fix.
M
Mary Beth Botz
Hands down, the best butter tarts ever! The filling melts in your mouth. Carla and her team take customer service to a whole new level. We ordered our tarts online, and they arrived right on time.
T
Toni Pickard
I ordered delivery of butter tarts to my granddaughter at college in Connecticut and am about to order others for my granddaughter at college in Manhattan.
D
Dennis W
I stumbled across some amazing butter tarts to die for at the " One of a Kind " Show. I tried an assorted set of butter tarts and of course...the classic pecan butter tarts are simply fantastic. These are so addictive and to support a local business woman is the cherry on top.
N
Nijat Bakili
This is the first time we ordered from here and got 12 full sized tarts and 12 mini tarts and they were great. Personally we enjoyed the regular sized tarts....
M
Michelle Sciaraffa
CARLA'S COOKIE BOX is a personal favorite of mine when I'm craving butter tarts. She offers many different flavors which are so good.
R
Roberto Furgiuele
This is the GTA’s and Toronto’s award winning butter tarts, brownies and cookies made by Carla’s Cookie Box.
Discover All Treats
Discover the ultimate indulgence with Carla’s Award-Winning Butter Tarts. Crafted with a buttery, flaky crust and rich, gooey filling, these tarts are available in various flavours, including plain, pecan, and raspberry white chocolate.
Perfect for corporate gifts, holiday presents, or personal treats, these butter tarts are celebrated as Toronto’s best homemade treats.
Order now for gourmet butter tarts delivered straight to your door.
Savour the taste of Carla’s Soft Homemade Cookies. These artisan baked goods are made with premium ingredients, offering a delightfully chewy texture and delicious flavours such as classic chocolate chip and red velvet.
Our cookies are ideal for holiday gifts or everyday enjoyment and are perfect for any occasion.
Order today and enjoy the convenience of gourmet cookie delivery.
Indulge in the decadence of Carla’s Chocolate Fudge Brownies. These rich, fudgy brownies are made with high-quality chocolate, providing a melt-in-your-mouth experience.
These brownies are perfect for satisfying your sweet tooth and make excellent corporate gifts or holiday treats.
Enjoy the best homemade brownies delivered fresh to your door.
Join the Carla's Cookie Box Family Today!
With our monthly dessert subscription, you’re not just receiving baked goods; you’re welcoming joy, quality, and indulgence into your life.
Whether indulging yourself, gifting a loved one, or sharing with colleagues, our dessert subscription options are the sweetest way to spread happiness.
Explore our subscription plans today and discover why dessert lovers across Canada and the USA trust Carla’s Cookie Box for their monthly dose of deliciousness.
Become a Subscriber and Save 10%
Sign up for our subscriptions and receive 10% off your other website orders.
