Personal Dessert Subscription โ€“
Monthly Treats Delivered

๐Ÿ Proudly Canadian ๐Ÿฅ‡ Award-Winning ๐Ÿ“ฆ Canada & USA-Wide Shipping ๐Ÿ›๏ธ Preorder pickup available in Vaughan, ON
Need help ordering?

personal dessert subscriptions
Small Dessert Subscription โ€“ 6-piece butter tart and cookie subscription box
โ˜…โ˜…โ˜…โ˜…โ˜…

6 Desserts Shipped Monthly

๐Ÿช Our Sweetest Subscription Starter

Enjoy 6 fresh butter tarts or cookies delivered monthly.

  • โœ”๏ธ 6 desserts per month
  • โœ”๏ธ Choose 1 flavour each month
  • โœ”๏ธ Shipping calculated on subscription page
  • โœ”๏ธ Save 10% with a prepaid 3, 6, or 12-month plan

Starting at $60 for 3 months

Most Popular
12 gourmet desserts in Medium dessert Subscription Box
โ˜…โ˜…โ˜…โ˜…โ˜…

12 Desserts Every Month

๐Ÿฐ A Dozen Rich, Gooey Treats Delivered Monthly

Pick your plan and enjoy 12 fresh desserts in every box.

  • โœ”๏ธ 12 desserts per month
  • โœ”๏ธ Choose 2 flavours each month
  • โœ”๏ธ Shipping calculated on subscription page
  • โœ”๏ธ Save 10% with a prepaid 3, 6, or 12-month plan

Starting at $120 for 3 months

Large Dessert Subscription Box with 24 handcrafted butter tarts or cookies, locally made in Ontario and shipped monthly across Canada
โ˜…โ˜…โ˜…โ˜…โ˜…

24 Desserts Every Month

๐ŸŽ‰ Our Largest Box of Gourmet Treats

24 Premium Desserts – Ideal for gifting and events

  • โœ”๏ธ 24 desserts per month
  • โœ”๏ธ Choose 4 flavours
  • โœ”๏ธ Shipping calculated on subscription page
  • โœ”๏ธ Save 10% with a prepaid 3, 6, or 12-month plan

Starting at $240 for 3 months

๐Ÿช First time here? Start with the essentials

โ People Love Carlaโ€™s Cookie Box โž

Real Words. Real Reactions. Real Reviews.

Butter Tart Flavour Descriptions

Please Note: Not all butter tart flavours are available at all times. Flavours are rotated based on the season and availability.
Only the flavours shown in the flavour selection grid are currently available to order.
If a flavour is not visible in the grid, it is not available at this time.

Click the arrow beside any section to expand and explore our flavours.

All Butter Tart Flavours (A-Z):

All Flavours (Aโ€“Z)

โ€ข Apple Pie โ€“ Spiced apple chunks baked into the maple-rich butter tart filling.
โ€ข Apricot โ€“ Tangy apricot jam layered over soft and chewy maple filling.
โ€ข Boston Cream โ€“ Vanilla custard filling with chocolate drizzle on top of our tart shell.
โ€ข Brownie Explosion โ€“ Gooey brownie chunks and chocolate drizzle on a maple base.
โ€ข Canadian Duo (Nanaimo) โ€“ Chocolate coconut base with a creamy custard layer and maple topping.
โ€ข Cappuccino โ€“ Coffee-infused tart with a smooth, maple-butter base.
โ€ข Caramel Glazed Walnut โ€“ Golden caramel poured over crunchy walnuts.
โ€ข Cherry Pie โ€“ Maple base topped with tart cherry preserves.
โ€ข Chocolate Dipped Strawberry โ€“ Strawberry tart dipped in chocolate and Valentine sprinkles.
โ€ข Chocolate Lindt โ€“ Filled with premium Lindt chocolate layered over maple filling.
โ€ข Chocolate Lovers โ€“ Rich chocolate top over soft maple tart.
โ€ข Churro de Leche โ€“ Cinnamon-sugar tart topped with dulce de leche and a churro piece.
โ€ข Cinnamon Bun โ€“ Brown sugar filling topped with cinnamon icing or glaze.
โ€ข Cookies N Cream โ€“ Crushed chocolate cookies over vanilla cream on a maple base.
โ€ข Dulce de Churro โ€“ Spiced tart with dulce de leche and a churro stick (same as Churro de Leche).
โ€ข Eggies โ€“ Crushed mini eggs and sprinkles for a festive spring finish.
โ€ข Lemon Coconut โ€“ Tangy lemon curd topped with toasted coconut over maple base.
โ€ข Lemon Zest โ€“ Bright lemon curd topping over buttery tart shell.
โ€ข Nutella โ€“ Chocolate chip butter tart topped with a thick swirl of Nutella.
โ€ข Peanut Butter & Chocolate โ€“ Creamy peanut butter and chocolate chips in every bite.
โ€ข Pecan โ€“ Packed with pecan pieces inside the fillingโ€”not just sprinkled on top.
โ€ข Plain โ€“ Classic gooey butter tart with a buttery, flaky crust.
โ€ข Pumpkin Pie โ€“ Smooth pumpkin puree with cinnamon and spices over maple base.
โ€ข Raisin โ€“ Filled with juicy raisins that soak in the sweet maple base.
โ€ข Raspberry White Chocolate โ€“ Tangy raspberry swirled with creamy white chocolate.
โ€ข Rocky Road โ€“ Chocolate tart with marshmallows and crunchy bits.
โ€ข Salted Caramel โ€“ Sweet maple filling topped with a rich, salted caramel glaze.
โ€ข Strawberry Sundae โ€“ Topped with strawberry preserves and a hint of vanilla.
โ€ข Toffee โ€“ Buttery, chewy toffee blended into the maple-rich filling.
โ€ข Turtle โ€“ A rich mix of chocolate, caramel, and pecans for a candy-inspired bite.
โ€ข White Chocolate Reeseโ€™s Cup โ€“ Peanut butter and white chocolate with festive sprinkles.

Specialty Butter Tart Packs:

Traditional Pack

โ€ข Plain โ€“ Classic gooey butter tart with a buttery, flaky crust.
โ€ข Pecan โ€“ Packed with pecan pieces inside the fillingโ€”not just sprinkled on top.
โ€ข Raisin โ€“ Filled with juicy raisins that soak in the sweet maple base.

Fan Favourites Pack

โ€ข Plain โ€“ Classic gooey butter tart with a buttery, flaky crust.
โ€ข Pecan โ€“ Packed with pecan pieces inside the fillingโ€”not just sprinkled on top.
โ€ข Salted Caramel โ€“ Sweet maple filling topped with a rich, salted caramel glaze.
โ€ข Toffee โ€“ Buttery, chewy toffee blended into the maple-rich filling.
โ€ข Peanut Butter & Chocolate โ€“ Creamy peanut butter and chocolate chips in every bite.
โ€ข Nutella โ€“ Chocolate chip butter tart topped with a thick swirl of Nutella.

Bakerโ€™s Choice

โ€ข Plain โ€“ Classic gooey butter tart with a buttery, flaky crust.
โ€ข Pecan โ€“ Packed with pecan pieces inside the fillingโ€”not just sprinkled on top.
โ€ข Caramel Glazed Walnut โ€“ Golden caramel poured over crunchy walnuts.
โ€ข Turtle โ€“ A rich mix of chocolate, caramel, and pecans for a candy-inspired bite.
โ€ข Toffee โ€“ Buttery, chewy toffee blended into the maple-rich filling.
โ€ข Surprise Butter Tart โ€“ A rotating seasonal favourite handpicked by our baker.

Seasonal Flavours:

๐Ÿง January & February

โ€ข Plain โ€“ Classic gooey butter tart with real maple syrup.
โ€ข Chocolate Dipped Strawberry โ€“ Strawberry butter tart dipped in chocolate and Valentine sprinkles.
โ€ข Cherry Pie โ€“ Maple base topped with cherry jam for a fruity finish.
โ€ข Dulce de Churro โ€“ Cinnamon-spiced tart topped with dulce de leche and a churro stick.
โ€ข Chocolate Lindt โ€“ Filled with premium Lindt chocolate over our buttery maple base.
โ€ข Brownie Explosion โ€“ Topped with brownie chunk and chocolate drizzle on rich maple filling.

๐Ÿฃ March & April

โ€ข Plain โ€“ Our original soft-set tart with buttery maple goodness.
โ€ข Eggies โ€“ Spring sprinkle party with crushed mini eggs on maple tart.
โ€ข Blueberry Pie โ€“ Blueberry topping layered over sweet tart filling.
โ€ข Lemon Coconut โ€“ Tangy lemon curd and toasted coconut on maple base.
โ€ข Rocky Road โ€“ Chocolatey tart with mini marshmallows and crunchy bits.
โ€ข Cookies N Cream โ€“ Crushed cookies folded into vanilla cream atop the tart.

๐ŸŒผ May & June

โ€ข Plain โ€“ Always soft, buttery, and maple-sweet.
โ€ข Churro โ€“ Cinnamon-maple tart with a churro chunk on top.
โ€ข Canadian Duo โ€“ Inspired by Nanaimo barsโ€”chocolate, custard, coconut over a maple core.
โ€ข Raspberry White Chocolate โ€“ Tangy raspberry swirled with creamy white chocolate.
โ€ข Chocolate Lovers โ€“ Deep, fudgy chocolate over soft butter tart base.
โ€ข Biscoff โ€“ Buttery tart filled with creamy speculoos cookie spread.

โ˜€๏ธ July & August

โ€ข Plain โ€“ Our signature maple tart that melts in your mouth.
โ€ข Strawberry Sundae โ€“ Topped with strawberry preserves over our maple-butter centre.
โ€ข Apricot โ€“ Tangy apricot jam over soft and chewy tart filling.
โ€ข Cherry Pie โ€“ Cherry topping on a classic maple base.
โ€ข Blueberry Pie โ€“ Summer blueberries layered over maple filling.
โ€ข Lemon Zest โ€“ Tart lemon curd over the classic maple tart shell.

๐Ÿ‚ September & October

โ€ข Plain โ€“ Sweet maple tart in our signature buttery shell.
โ€ข Caramel Glazed Walnut โ€“ Toasted walnuts glazed in golden caramel over maple tart.
โ€ข Apple Pie โ€“ Spiced apple chunks embedded in gooey maple butter tart.
โ€ข Pumpkin Pie โ€“ Pumpkin puree with fall spices layered over our tart base.
โ€ข Cinnamon Bun โ€“ Brown sugar filling with icing or cinnamon-sugar topping.
โ€ข Chocolate Lovers โ€“ Rich chocolate top over the original maple tart.

๐ŸŽ„ November & December

โ€ข Plain โ€“ Simple, nostalgic, and always made with real maple syrup.
โ€ข Raspberry White Chocolate โ€“ Tangy raspberry swirled with creamy white chocolate.
โ€ข White Chocolate Reeseโ€™s Cup โ€“ Peanut butter and white chocolate over maple filling with festive sprinkles.
โ€ข Turtle โ€“ A rich mix of chocolate, caramel, and pecans for a candy-inspired bite.
โ€ข Cookies & Cream โ€“ Crushed cookies on vanilla cream and maple tart base.
โ€ข Cappuccino โ€“ Coffee-infused tart with a smooth, maple-butter base.
โ€ข Boston Cream โ€“ Vanilla custard filling with chocolate drizzle on top.
โ€ข Chocolate Lovers โ€“ Fudgy and rich, with chocolate layered on maple filling.

Personal Dessert Subscription Flavoursย 

At Carla’s Cookie Box, we understand that variety is the spice of life. That’s why we offer a range of monthly dessert delivery subscriptions to cater to your unique preferences.ย 

Butter Tart Flavours

Cookie Flavours

๐Ÿช Personal Dessert Subscriptions Made Sweet & Simple

Enjoy handmade treats delivered monthlyโ€”just the way you like them.

Choose your favourite desserts, select your subscription length, and weโ€™ll do the rest. Whether itโ€™s a solo indulgence or a family treat night, our personal dessert boxes bring joy right to your doorstepโ€”anywhere in Canada.

How Dessert Subscriptions Works

Carlas Cookies Bakery

You Choose

Choose a prepaid plan โ€” 3, 6, or 12 months, INCLUDING SHIPPING.
Pick your dessert flavours for each month. You can send it to yourself or as a gift.

Carlas Cookies Deliver

We Ship Monthly!

Once your order automatically populates in our system, we bake everything fresh, pack it with care, and ship your box once a month.
You'll get tracking info as soon as it leaves our kitchen.

Carlas Cookies Enjoy

You Unbox & Enjoy!

Open your box, take a bite, and let dessert day work its magic. Every month brings a new reason to smile (and snack)!

๐Ÿ Baked in Toronto – Canada wide Delivery – Guaranteed Fresh

We partner with a trusted network of Canadian couriers to deliver your Gourmet Desserts on time, every time โ€” whether itโ€™s heading to a downtown office, a remote team, or multiple branches. Each box is carefully packed to ensure your desserts arrive fresh, secure, and beautifully presented, regardless of the season or destination.

๐Ÿ’ฌ Have specific needs or want to tailor a custom or corporate order? FAQ or contact us directly โ€” weโ€™ll help create a plan that fits you or your team perfectly.

cookies-box

Subscription Timelines

We offer flexible subscription timelines to suit your needs:

3 Month

  • A great option to enjoy a season of sweet delights.

6 Month

  • Perfect for half a year of indulgence.

12 Month

  • The ultimate subscription for dessert enthusiasts, ensuring a year-long supply of our delectable treats.

A dessert subscription is designed to provide a seamless and enjoyable experience.

You can renew or cancel at your convenience through your account.

Why Choose Carla's Cookie Box?

Quality Ingredients

Quality Ingredients

We use only the finest Ontario, Canada locally sourced ingredients to ensure our desserts are of the highest quality.

Award-Winning Recipes

Award-Winning Recipes

Our butter tarts have received accolades for their exceptional taste and texture.

Convenience

Convenience

Enjoy gourmet desserts delivered to your door without the hassle of baking.

Flavour Selection

Personalized Subscriptions

Customize your subscription to match your unique taste and preferences.

Sustainable Packaging

Sustainable Packaging

We prioritize the planet by using environmentally friendly materials for all our packaging.

Give Joy All Year with Carlaโ€™s Cookie Box Gift Subscriptions

Looking for a gift that goes beyond one moment? Delight someone every month with Carlaโ€™s dessert subscription โ€” the thoughtful, delicious way to say you care. Whether it’s for a birthday, anniversary, or just-because surprise, each box of handmade goodies brings joy that lasts.

โ€” Because gifting isnโ€™t just about the treat โ€” itโ€™s about creating sweet memories.

Birthdays

Birthdays

Brighten someoneโ€™s special day with a monthly delivery of their favourite treats.

Holidays

Holidays

Share festive flavours during the holiday season with our customizable subscription options.

Thank You Gifts

Thank You Gifts

Show gratitude in the sweetest way possible.

Anniversaries

Anniversaries

Make every month memorable with a box of delicious desserts.

Join the Carla's Cookie Box Family Today!

Small Dessert Subscription โ€“ 6-piece butter tart and cookie subscription box
โ˜…โ˜…โ˜…โ˜…โ˜…

6 Desserts Shipped Monthly

๐Ÿช Our Sweetest Subscription Starter

Enjoy 6 fresh butter tarts or cookies delivered monthly.

  • โœ”๏ธ 6 desserts per month
  • โœ”๏ธ Choose 1 flavour each month
  • โœ”๏ธ Shipping calculated on subscription page
  • โœ”๏ธ Save 10% with a prepaid 3, 6, or 12-month plan

Starting at $60 for 3 months

12 gourmet desserts in Medium dessert Subscription Box
โ˜…โ˜…โ˜…โ˜…โ˜…

12 Desserts Every Month

๐Ÿฐ A Dozen Rich, Gooey Treats Delivered Monthly

Pick your plan and enjoy 12 fresh desserts in every box.

  • โœ”๏ธ 12 desserts per month
  • โœ”๏ธ Choose 2 flavours each month
  • โœ”๏ธ Shipping calculated on subscription page
  • โœ”๏ธ Save 10% with a prepaid 3, 6, or 12-month plan

Starting at $120 for 3 months

Large Dessert Subscription Box with 24 handcrafted butter tarts or cookies, locally made in Ontario and shipped monthly across Canada
โ˜…โ˜…โ˜…โ˜…โ˜…

24 Desserts Every Month

๐ŸŽ‰ Our Largest Box of Gourmet Treats

24 Premium Desserts – Ideal for gifting and events

  • โœ”๏ธ 24 desserts per month
  • โœ”๏ธ Choose 4 flavours
  • โœ”๏ธ Shipping calculated on subscription page
  • โœ”๏ธ Save 10% with a prepaid 3, 6, or 12-month plan

Starting at $240 for 3 months

Not ready to subscribe?

Try our most-loved treats before committing. Choose from butter tarts, cookies, or brownies โ€” handmade in Ontario and shipped Canada-wide.

Already know what you want?

Carlas-Cookie-Box-Mobile img
Carla's-Cookie-Box---Mobile-footer img
Carla's-Cookie-Box---Mobile-footer-img
Carlas-Cookie-Box Mobile img
Carlas-Cookie-Box Mobile img

Sign up for our subscriptions and receive 10% off your other website orders.

Savor a Sweet Arrow

๐ŸŽฅ How to Order & Shipping โ€“ Watch Before You Checkout

Got questions about how to place your order, pick a shipping date, or find answers to common questions?
Click on each video below for a quick walkthrough:

  • How to Order โ€“ Step-by-step guide to selecting your desserts and checking out with ease
  • Shipping Explained โ€“ Learn how pickup vs. shipping works, and how delivery timing is handled
  • FAQ Highlights โ€“ Get answers to our most commonly asked questions in under a minute

๐Ÿ“ฆ Note: Your shipping date is not your delivery date unless you choose HAND DELIVERY Toronto, Vaughan, or Brampton.

Need more help? Visit our full FAQ page anytime.

Personal Dessert Subscription
Frequently Asked Questions

We curate many different flavour boxes especially for you and the season. Check out our current dessert subscription box options for all the variety available.
Definitely. You can mix and match butter tart and cookie flavours each month directly on the subscription product page.
Flavours are selected at checkout, but if you're on a 3, 6, or 12-month plan, just reach out before your next box ships and weโ€™ll help you update your picks.
Yes! You can pause or skip any upcoming month from your account dashboard. Just make sure to do it before your box is processed.
Yes โ€” all our personal dessert subscriptions are prepaid. You choose 3, 6, or 12 months and pay once. No surprise charges, ever.
Yes! Our Canadian-made butter tarts and cookies freeze beautifully. Just thaw at room temperature when you're ready to indulge.
Absolutely. We introduce seasonal flavours like Pumpkin Spice, Red Velvet, Eggnog, and Cranberry Walnut throughout the year โ€” alongside your favourite classics.
Our butter tarts are oversized, and our cookies are full-sized and stuffed โ€” no mini samples. You can read more on our main FAQ page.
Of course! You can reorder the same plan or upgrade to a bigger box anytime on the Personal Subscriptions page.
Yes! Just enter the recipientโ€™s name and shipping address at checkout. You can even include a gift note for a sweet surprise.
We ship anywhere in Canada and the USA. Orders usually arrive within 2โ€“4 business days depending on the location.
Yes โ€” everything is handmade in Vaughan, Ontario using Canadian-sourced ingredients. We proudly support local.
Some of our flavours do contain nuts. While we offer nut-free options, we are not a nut-free facility. For more details, visit our FAQ page.
Yes โ€” you can upgrade from Small to Medium or Large anytime. Just contact our team and weโ€™ll adjust it for you.
Every box is filled with a curated selection of handmade Canadian desserts โ€” including butter tarts, cookies, and seasonal specialties. All full-sized. All indulgent.
Yes! You choose your flavours when you build your subscription. Need a change? Just message us before the next delivery and weโ€™ll make it work.
We carefully wrap your treats using food-safe protective packaging to ensure everything arrives fresh, beautiful, and damage-free.
Yes โ€” our prepaid dessert subscription boxes make perfect gifts. Add the recipientโ€™s address and your message during checkout and weโ€™ll handle the rest.
Just log into your account dashboard to pause, update flavours, or change your shipping details at any time.