Butter Tarts
$22.50 CAD
$25.00 CAD
Butter Tarts – Build Your Own Box | Award-Winning • 6 Per Box
Butter Tarts – Build Your Own Box | Award-Winning • 6 Per Box
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Couldn't load pickup availability
Guaranteed Safe Checkout
SAVE 10%
BUNDLE & SAVE
Pick your favourites. Three boxes. One easy bundle.
Gourmet Cookies
$22.50 CAD
$25.00 CAD
Fatties
$29.70 CAD
$33.00 CAD
Bundle price
$74.70 CAD
$83.00 CAD
YOU SAVE
10% • $8.30 CAD
Bundle savings are automatically applied.
BIG FLAVOUR. PREMIUM INGREDIENTS. BUILT TO IMPRESS.
Build Your Perfect Box
Mix the flavours you want instead of settling for someone else’s assortment.
Full-Size & Generously Filled
Deep, gooey butter tarts with plenty of filling in every bite — never mini.
Classic + Creative Flavours
Choose timeless favourites alongside signature and seasonal flavours.
Baked & Packed Fresh
Made fresh in small batches and carefully packed for pickup, delivery or shipping.
❝ Real Reactions from Real Customers ❞
Real Words. Real Reactions. Real Reviews.
Butter Tart Flavours
Swipe to see more flavours →
Butter Tarts – Build Your Own Box | Award-Winning • 6 Per Box FAQ
Loading FAQs…
Ingredients & Allergens
Nutrition Information:
Looking for nutrition facts? View our complete Nutrition Guide →
Great presentation of delivery. And very tasty butter tarts. The ones with raisen are my favorite.
Buttery and flaky. But I found them a bit to sweet. I am looking forward to trying your thick cookies!
Wow, these buttertarts are AMAZING!! The flavour & texture is perfect. Such a wonderful treat!! Thank you so much!!
The cookies are a perfect partner for a cup of coffee or tea. They are soft and have so much flavour. Self control is needed to limit myself to just one a day.
I
The fatties cookies are spectacular! And the butter tarts are their awesome selves, as usual
1
Easy to order and received it pretty quick.
The butter tarts was amazing good balance between crust and filling
I am sorry but they were awful. The insides were tolerable but the pastry was like eating cardboard. The flavour basically ruined the whole tart. Not enough butter or pastry. I literally tried one bite of each one of the flavors and had to throw them out. I was really looking forward to these as butteryarts are my favourite and was very disappointed.
Leah, thank you for giving our butter tarts a try. We understand you were looking forward to them, especially as butter tarts are a favourite of yours. While ours weren’t to your taste, we appreciate you sharing your honest feedback about the pastry and filling.
The tarts were really quite good. Thoughtful packaging to endure the shipping. If Carla’s products were available in-store I would likely purchase again. Otherwise, I did think it was an expensive purchase that I likely won’t make again because of the expense. They were good though!
Let’s see I started with the combination of butter tarts, which were excellent then a few selected brands then my last order and this was my third order, pecan butter tarts. I have never tasted better butter tarts ever in my whole life.
Just got my order and they are soooo good. Generous filling, great flavor, and not over priced. Will definitely be ordering again
Delicious product. Price is a little too much to have it delivered would be ideal if we had one in Winnipeg. But the variety was nice
Absolutely love Carla’s Cookie Box! Everything I’ve tried has been delicious, fresh, and full of flavour. So many amazing flavours to choose from! I can’t wait to try more! The butter tarts are to die for! I’ve been dreaming about them since the last time I had one, so I had to order more! ❤️
Cookies were great , My grandkids loved them , I’m a butter tart lover 😊
The butter tarts were amazing. They beautifully packed. I had ordered them for my birthday and they arrived well before my birthday. They froze beautifully. Some of the best butter tarts I have ever eaten.
The butter tarts were too big and they were so sweet that the flavours did not come through.
The best butter tarts that I’ve ever had! Perfect buttery crust and delicious fillings, full of flavour.
I can't eat many of them. So I give them away.. Everyone loves them..
Incredible butter tarts! Really enjoyed the seasonal favourites! All the butter tarts are always incredible! Such a special treat! Thank you!!
Unfortunately by the time I received order the crust was soggy and the inside chewy. Not very fond
I would not be inclined to order again. They did not deliver order in time of my event and their communication and ability to resolve issues are very poor
The cookies were amazing, 1 is filling and soft.
Great for on the run, especially since each ine is wrapped individually.
I was very disappointed in the raising butter tarts!! I ordered 12 of the raisins butter tarts. The pastry was not baked, tasted raw! Also, the filling wasn't very tasty, not at all gooie! And when I emailed them telling them about my issu3s, I haven’t heard back from them I was very disappointed in these since I was so looking forward to leaving them.
