Top 5 Flavours Our Customers Can’t Get Enough Of

🍁 Proudly Canadian | 🥇 Voted Best in Toronto | 📦 Nationwide Fresh Delivery

Discover our top five best-selling flavours, with short notes on what makes each one special and how to pair them for the best taste.

By Carla M · August 10, 2026

Shop Now
A close-up of five clamshells of tarts in a display, featuring Maple Butter, Pecan Honey, and Sea Salt Chocolate flavors arranged on a wooden tray.

At Carla’s Cookie Box , we bake dozens of flavours throughout the year—but a few fan favourites keep our customers coming back again and again. Curious which ones made the list? Here’s a look at the top 5 flavours that have earned a permanent spot in our customers’ hearts (and dessert tables!).

Top 5 Flavours Our Customers Can’t Get Enough Of

🍪 The Power of a Fan Favourite

Every season brings exciting new creations, but there’s something special about a classic flavour that stands the test of time. When customers tell us they dream about our butter tartsor can’t stop ordering certain cookie boxes, we know we’ve hit a sweet spot—literally. Our top flavours often show up at weddings, corporate events, and even in The Kit’s feature on the best Canadian subscription boxes.

🎉 Top 5 Flavours Our Customers Can’t Get Enough Of

1. Pecan Butter Tart

Our Pecan Butter Tart is a customer favourite for a reason. Flaky pastry, rich gooey filling, and crunchy pecans make it the perfect sweet-and-nutty bite.

2. Classic Plain Butter Tart

No list would be complete without the original. Our Classic Plain Butter Tart is melt-in-your-mouth perfection with flaky pastry, buttery filling, and that signature gooey centre.

3. Turtle Butter Tart

This one is pure indulgence. Chocolate, caramel, pecans, and our classic butter tart filling come together for a rich, gooey, chocolatey treat.

4. Chocolate Chip Cookies

Simple, soft, and irresistible. Our Chocolate Chip Cookies are loaded with real chocolate and baked for that homemade-style bite everyone loves.

5. Chocolate Chip Fatties

Big, thick, and packed with chocolate, our Chocolate Chip Fatties are made for serious cookie lovers. They’re rich, soft, and unforgettable.

Top 5 Flavours Our Customers Can’t Get Enough Of
Top 5 Flavours Our Customers Can’t Get Enough Of

📦 How to Get Your Hands on Our Most Popular Flavours

All of these flavours—and more—are available in our online dessert shop. You can order individual platters, build your own dessert table, or subscribe to monthly corporate dessert subscriptions to keep the sweetness coming year-round. We deliver fresh across Toronto and ship nationwide, so no matter where you are in Canada, you can get a taste of Toronto’s favourite butter tarts and cookies.

🎥 See the Sweetness in Action

Want to see more behind-the-scenes baking magic? Check out our latest videos on YouTube and Instagram where you’ll find everything from baking days to event setups!

Ready to taste Toronto’s most loved desserts? Explore our collection of butter tarts, cookies, and brownies today—handmade with love and shipped across Canada!