September Butter Tart Flavours

🍁 Proudly Canadian | 🥇 Voted Best in Toronto | 📦 Nationwide Fresh Delivery

Try four September butter tart flavours from Toronto: apple, cinnamon bun, pumpkin, and walnut. Warm them briefly and enjoy with coffee or sharp cheddar.

By Carla M · September 16, 2025

Shop Now
September Butter Tart Flavours Blog - Carla's Cookie Box

Welcome fall with our delicious September butter tart flavours from Carla’s Cookie Box —handmade in Toronto and shipped fresh across Canada!

September Butter Tart Flavours

🍂 Celebrate September with Fresh Butter Tarts

September brings cooler days and the start of cozy dessert season!
At Carla’s Cookie Box, we’re baking up irresistible fall butter tart flavours perfect for back-to-school lunches, fall weddings, and cozy nights in.

  • Plain Butter Tart
  • Walnut Butter Tart
  • Apple Butter Tart
  • Pumpkin Butter Tart
  • Cinnamon Bun Butter Tart
  • Chocolate Lovers Butter Tart

Shop our online store to enjoy Toronto’s favourite butter tarts shipped across Canada!

Kick off fall sweetly—explore our September butter tart flavours today!

September Butter Tart Flavours
September Butter Tart Flavours