Butter Tarts – Single Flavour Quick Pick Box

$22.00

(42 customer reviews)
CHOOSE 1 FLAVOUR - Each Box contains 6 tarts
Grand total

🥧 Award-Winning Butter Tarts – Single Flavour Quick Pick Box
Hand-crafted in Toronto, delivered across Canada.

Prefer to mix and match flavours instead? Visit our custom box page below.

Build Your Butter Tart Box →

You May Also Like

baker's choice for category page
★★★★★

Wholesale Award Winning Butter Tarts

Individually packaged gourmet butter tart from Carla’s Cookie Box in a gold foil cup with clear dome lid, sealed for freshness
★★★★★

Individually Packaged Award Winning Gourmet Butter Tarts

Assorted butter tart platter from Carla’s Cookie Box with flavours including classic, chocolate, toffee crumble, and sprinkle-topped tarts arranged on a silver serving tray.
★★★★★

Platter – Delicious Mini Gourmet Butter Tarts – 60

Corby Gilmore
Corby Gilmore
Verified ownerVerified owner
5/5
7 days ago
Diane Oelke
Diane Oelke
Verified ownerVerified owner
5/5

I was happy to be able to order my two very favourite butter tarts. As usual, the butter tarts were exceptionally fresh and delicious.

1 week ago
Ryan Johansson
Ryan Johansson
Verified ownerVerified owner
5/5
1 week ago

People Love Carla’s Cookie Box

Real Words. Real Reactions. Real Reviews.

🥇 Award-Winning Butter Tarts – Single Flavour Quick Pick Box

Craving one perfect flavour?
Our Single Flavour Quick Pick Butter Tart Box are handcrafted in Toronto using locally sourced ingredients and a small-batch recipe that’s earned top honours across Ontario. Choose your favourite flavour for a box of pure indulgence—no mixing needed!

Each tart features a golden, flaky crust and a rich, gooey centre made with real Canadian butter, whole liquid eggs, and zero preservatives—just the kind of quality you expect from a small, independent Toronto bakery. Prefer variety? Try our Build Your Own Butter Tart Box instead.

How to Order Our Signature Butter Tarts

Carlas Cookies Bakery

You Pick Your Treat

Choose your butter tart format – classic clamshell packs, gift boxes, or party platters made for sharing.

Carlas Cookies Deliver

We Bake & Pack Fresh

Pick your preferred flavours or go with our bestsellers. You can also add a message card or upgrade to premium packaging.

Carlas Cookies Enjoy

You Enjoy Every Bite

We bake fresh in Toronto using real Canadian butter and ship across Canada or prepare for local delivery and pickup.

🍁 Baked in Toronto – Canada & USA Delivery – Guaranteed Fresh

We partner with a trusted network of couriers to deliver your Gourmet Butter Tarts across Canada and the USA — whether they’re heading to a downtown office, a remote team, or multiple branches. Each box is carefully packed to ensure your desserts arrive fresh, secure, and beautifully presented, no matter the season or destination.

🏬 Prefer local pickup? Preorder pickup is available Tuesday–Friday in Vaughan, ON for customers who wish to collect their order in person.

💬 Have specific needs or want to tailor a custom or corporate order? FAQ or contact us directly — we’ll help create a plan that fits you or your team perfectly.

🍯 What Makes Our Single Flavour Quick Pick Butter Tart Box Special?

Each box highlights one perfect flavour, baked with the same small-batch care that made our butter tarts famous. They’re:

  • Hand-crafted with our signature gooey filling from scratch
  • Made fresh in Toronto using premium Canadian ingredients
  • Baked in small batches for perfect flavour and consistency
  • Encased in our flaky, never-soggy pastry crust
  • Free from preservatives and artificial fillers

Loved at festivals, markets, and pop-ups across Ontario — one bite and you’ll understand why Canadians can’t get enough of our award-winning butter tarts.

September - October seasonal butter tarts for blog
Two hands holding gourmet butter tarts from Carla’s Cookie Box — one topped with marshmallow and chocolate, the other with a drizzled chocolate finish.

🍪 Gourmet Butter Tart Flavours That Deliver

We offer a rotating mix of best-sellers, depending on seasonal availability:

  • Plain – Smooth, rich, and timeless
  • Pecan – Roasted crunch on buttery filling
  • Raisin – A classic twist with plump raisins
  • Nutella – Chocolate hazelnut meets Canadian tradition
  • Salted Caramel – Buttery, sweet, and lightly salted
  • Toffee – Deep caramelized flavour with a soft finish

If you’re looking for more variety or seasonal releases, try our Butter Tart Platter or Personal Dessert Subscription for rotating monthly drops.

📦 How It’s Packaged

  • Toronto-area delivery or pickup: Tarts arrive in a clamshell container—fresh, unwrapped, and presentation-ready.
  • Canada-wide shipping: Each tart stays in the clamshell and is wrapped and cushioned in a sturdy shipping box for safe delivery.
  • Gift upgrade: Add our signature pink CCB gift box at checkout for a polished final touch.

Orders are carefully packed from our Toronto kitchen and arrive fresh, ready to enjoy.

🎁 Our Single Flavour Quick Pick Butter Tart Box are Perfect For:

  • 🎂 Birthdays, thank-you gifts, and cozy dessert nights
  • 🏢 Staff appreciation and easy client gifting
  • 💌 Sending sweet surprises to friends and family
  • ☕ Pairing with coffee, tea, or weekend brunch
  • ✈️ Shipping across Canada—beautifully packaged and travel-ready

Need variety for a larger crowd? Try our
Build Your Own Butter Tart Box
or add a
Mini Butter Tart Platter
for sharing.

🛒 How to Order

✔️ Choose your favourite single flavour
✔️ Select box size (6 or 12 butter tarts)
✔️ Pick delivery or local pickup in Vaughan, ON
✔️ Optional: Add a gift note at checkout
✔️ Enjoy Canada’s most loved butter tarts—freshly baked, shipped with care

Premium Butter Tarts from Our Large Dessert Subscription

Butter Tart Flavour Descriptions

Please Note: Not all butter tart flavours are available at all times. Flavours are rotated based on the season and availability.
Only the flavours shown in the flavour selection grid are currently available to order.
If a flavour is not visible in the grid, it is not available at this time.

Click the arrow beside any section to expand and explore our flavours.

All Butter Tart Flavours (A-Z):

All Flavours (A–Z)

Apple Pie – Spiced apple chunks baked into the maple-rich butter tart filling.
Apricot – Tangy apricot jam layered over soft and chewy maple filling.
Boston Cream – Vanilla custard filling with chocolate drizzle on top of our tart shell.
Brownie Explosion – Gooey brownie chunks and chocolate drizzle on a maple base.
Canadian Duo (Nanaimo) – Chocolate coconut base with a creamy custard layer and maple topping.
Cappuccino – Coffee-infused tart with a smooth, maple-butter base.
Caramel Glazed Walnut – Golden caramel poured over crunchy walnuts.
Cherry Pie – Maple base topped with tart cherry preserves.
Chocolate Dipped Strawberry – Strawberry tart dipped in chocolate and Valentine sprinkles.
Chocolate Lindt – Filled with premium Lindt chocolate layered over maple filling.
Chocolate Lovers – Rich chocolate top over soft maple tart.
Churro de Leche – Cinnamon-sugar tart topped with dulce de leche and a churro piece.
Cinnamon Bun – Brown sugar filling topped with cinnamon icing or glaze.
Cookies N Cream – Crushed chocolate cookies over vanilla cream on a maple base.
Dulce de Churro – Spiced tart with dulce de leche and a churro stick (same as Churro de Leche).
Eggies – Crushed mini eggs and sprinkles for a festive spring finish.
Lemon Coconut – Tangy lemon curd topped with toasted coconut over maple base.
Lemon Zest – Bright lemon curd topping over buttery tart shell.
Nutella – Chocolate chip butter tart topped with a thick swirl of Nutella.
Peanut Butter & Chocolate – Creamy peanut butter and chocolate chips in every bite.
Pecan – Packed with pecan pieces inside the filling—not just sprinkled on top.
Plain – Classic gooey butter tart with a buttery, flaky crust.
Pumpkin Pie – Smooth pumpkin puree with cinnamon and spices over maple base.
Raisin – Filled with juicy raisins that soak in the sweet maple base.
Raspberry White Chocolate – Tangy raspberry swirled with creamy white chocolate.
Rocky Road – Chocolate tart with marshmallows and crunchy bits.
Salted Caramel – Sweet maple filling topped with a rich, salted caramel glaze.
Strawberry Sundae – Topped with strawberry preserves and a hint of vanilla.
Toffee – Buttery, chewy toffee blended into the maple-rich filling.
Turtle – A rich mix of chocolate, caramel, and pecans for a candy-inspired bite.
White Chocolate Reese’s Cup – Peanut butter and white chocolate with festive sprinkles.

Specialty Butter Tart Packs:

Traditional Pack

Plain – Classic gooey butter tart with a buttery, flaky crust.
Pecan – Packed with pecan pieces inside the filling—not just sprinkled on top.
Raisin – Filled with juicy raisins that soak in the sweet maple base.

Fan Favourites Pack

Plain – Classic gooey butter tart with a buttery, flaky crust.
Pecan – Packed with pecan pieces inside the filling—not just sprinkled on top.
Salted Caramel – Sweet maple filling topped with a rich, salted caramel glaze.
Toffee – Buttery, chewy toffee blended into the maple-rich filling.
Peanut Butter & Chocolate – Creamy peanut butter and chocolate chips in every bite.
Nutella – Chocolate chip butter tart topped with a thick swirl of Nutella.

Baker’s Choice

Plain – Classic gooey butter tart with a buttery, flaky crust.
Pecan – Packed with pecan pieces inside the filling—not just sprinkled on top.
Caramel Glazed Walnut – Golden caramel poured over crunchy walnuts.
Turtle – A rich mix of chocolate, caramel, and pecans for a candy-inspired bite.
Toffee – Buttery, chewy toffee blended into the maple-rich filling.
Surprise Butter Tart – A rotating seasonal favourite handpicked by our baker.

Seasonal Flavours:

🧁 January & February

Plain – Classic gooey butter tart with real maple syrup.
Chocolate Dipped Strawberry – Strawberry butter tart dipped in chocolate and Valentine sprinkles.
Cherry Pie – Maple base topped with cherry jam for a fruity finish.
Dulce de Churro – Cinnamon-spiced tart topped with dulce de leche and a churro stick.
Chocolate Lindt – Filled with premium Lindt chocolate over our buttery maple base.
Brownie Explosion – Topped with brownie chunk and chocolate drizzle on rich maple filling.

🐣 March & April

Plain – Our original soft-set tart with buttery maple goodness.
Eggies – Spring sprinkle party with crushed mini eggs on maple tart.
Blueberry Pie – Blueberry topping layered over sweet tart filling.
Lemon Coconut – Tangy lemon curd and toasted coconut on maple base.
Rocky Road – Chocolatey tart with mini marshmallows and crunchy bits.
Cookies N Cream – Crushed cookies folded into vanilla cream atop the tart.

🌼 May & June

Plain – Always soft, buttery, and maple-sweet.
Churro – Cinnamon-maple tart with a churro chunk on top.
Canadian Duo – Inspired by Nanaimo bars—chocolate, custard, coconut over a maple core.
Raspberry White Chocolate – Tangy raspberry swirled with creamy white chocolate.
Chocolate Lovers – Deep, fudgy chocolate over soft butter tart base.
Biscoff – Buttery tart filled with creamy speculoos cookie spread.

☀️ July & August

Plain – Our signature maple tart that melts in your mouth.
Strawberry Sundae – Topped with strawberry preserves over our maple-butter centre.
Apricot – Tangy apricot jam over soft and chewy tart filling.
Cherry Pie – Cherry topping on a classic maple base.
Blueberry Pie – Summer blueberries layered over maple filling.
Lemon Zest – Tart lemon curd over the classic maple tart shell.

🍂 September & October

Plain – Sweet maple tart in our signature buttery shell.
Caramel Glazed Walnut – Toasted walnuts glazed in golden caramel over maple tart.
Apple Pie – Spiced apple chunks embedded in gooey maple butter tart.
Pumpkin Pie – Pumpkin puree with fall spices layered over our tart base.
Cinnamon Bun – Brown sugar filling with icing or cinnamon-sugar topping.
Chocolate Lovers – Rich chocolate top over the original maple tart.

🎄 November & December

Plain – Simple, nostalgic, and always made with real maple syrup.
Raspberry White Chocolate – Tangy raspberry swirled with creamy white chocolate.
White Chocolate Reese’s Cup – Peanut butter and white chocolate over maple filling with festive sprinkles.
Turtle – A rich mix of chocolate, caramel, and pecans for a candy-inspired bite.
Cookies & Cream – Crushed cookies on vanilla cream and maple tart base.
Cappuccino – Coffee-infused tart with a smooth, maple-butter base.
Boston Cream – Vanilla custard filling with chocolate drizzle on top.
Chocolate Lovers – Fudgy and rich, with chocolate layered on maple filling.

Butter Tart Flavours

 👩‍🍳 The Carla’s Cookie Box Difference

At Carla’s Cookie Box, we believe dessert should never be basic. That’s why every cookie is made by hand, using real ingredients and zero preservatives — just like the ones we grew up with. We’re proudly Canadian, family-owned, and passionate about dessert done right. 🍪 From Pop-Up Events across Ontario to online Dessert Subscriptions, our mission is to spread joy one box at a time. 🌾 We support local farms and source ingredients right here in Ontario whenever possible — because what’s good for the community is good for the cookie.

FEATURES:

  • SIX Award-Winning Handcrafted Gourmet Butter Tarts per box
  • Use Locally Sourced Ingredients
  • Supports Local Farmers

FAQ: Single Flavour Butter Tart Box

Can I pick up my order and where?
Are these full-size butter tarts?
How many tarts come in a box?
Can I choose more than one flavour?
Are seasonal flavours available?
Is gift wrapping available?
Do your butter tarts contain lard?
Are your butter tarts nut free?

Shipping Info

🎥 How to Order & Shipping – Watch Before Checkout

Questions about ordering, shipping dates, or FAQs?
Watch these quick videos:

  • How to Order – Step-by-step checkout guide
  • Shipping Explained – Delivery timing & method
  • FAQ Highlights – Quick answers to top questions

🚚 Shipping Info

We ship fresh from Ontario every Wednesday & Friday. 📦 Rates are calculated in real time—no surprises. 🇨🇦 We ship across Canada & the USA with ClickShip couriers.

🏬 Pickup Option

Preorder pickup available Tuesday–Friday in Vaughan, ON. Select Pickup at checkout to choose your preferred date and time.

Choosing Your Delivery or Pickup Date:
At checkout, select shipping or pickup. A calendar will appear for date selection.

🎥 Watch: Shipping Explained

📦 Reminder: Shipping date is not your delivery date unless it’s a HAND DELIVERY to Toronto, Vaughan, or Brampton.

Still unsure? Check our full FAQ or visit our Help Page.

Additional information

Additional information

Weight 3 lbs
Dimensions 10 × 8 × 4 in
Ingredients

Brown Sugar, Butter, Cider Vinegar, Eggs, Flour, Ontario Maple Syrup, Salt, Vegetable Shortening

Add On Ingredients

Caramel, Chocolate Chips, Coconut, Lemon Curd, Nutella, Peanut Butter, Pecans, Raisins, Raspberry Sauce, Sea Salt, Strawberry Sauce, Toffee, Walnuts

Customer Reviews

4.9
Based on 264 reviews
5 star
87
87%
4 star
12
12%
3 star
1
1%
2 star
0%
1 star
0%
1-5 of 264 reviews
  1. A

    Website a bit finicky when trying to make changes

  2. LW
  3. CG
  4. CG
  5. AC

    Ordering was very easy and delivery was on time.

Allergy Alert! All Items are made in a facility that handles: peanuts, tree nuts, soy, milk, eggs, wheat and any other known allergies.

Related Products

Assorted gourmet butter tarts from Carla’s Cookie Box in six flavours including classic, pecan, toffee, peanut butter, chocolate, and maple, arranged in a circular pattern on a white background
★★★★★

Butter Tarts – Build Your Own Box | Award-Winning • 6 Per Box

Price range: $22.00 through $80.00

baker's choice for category page
★★★★★

Wholesale Award Winning Butter Tarts

Stores, Restaurants & Cafes Only - Min 2 cases

Stack of thick gourmet fatties cookies from Carla’s Cookie Box, featuring assorted Fatties cookie flavours with chocolate, peanut butter, and caramel toppings
★★★★★

Fatties Cookies – 6 Soft, Chewy and Thick

$30.00