Name: Bundle & Save — Pick Your Favourite Butter Tarts, Cookies & Fatties
Brand: Carla's Cookie Box
Price: 74.7 CAD
Availability: InStock
Rating: 4.67 (459 reviews)

BIG FLAVOUR. PREMIUM INGREDIENTS. BUILT TO IMPRESS.

Three Favourites, Already Chosen

Your bundle comes pre-selected with 6 butter tarts, 6 gourmet cookies and 6 Fatties — 18 treats total.

Bundle & Save Automatically

Enjoy special bundle pricing compared with purchasing all three products separately. No promo code needed.

Choose Shipping or Pickup

Have your treats shipped to you or select local pickup in Vaughan for a convenient way to get your order.

Packed Fresh

Carefully packed to help your treats stay fresh from our bakery to your door.

❝ Real Reactions from Real Customers ❞

Real Words. Real Reactions. Real Reviews.

🍪 Three Carla’s Classics. One Easy Bundle.

Sometimes the classics are classics for a reason. This bundle brings together three Carla’s Cookie Box favourites in one easy order, making it perfect for sharing, gifting or simply stocking up on the treats everyone already loves.

You’ll get 6 Plain Butter Tarts with our signature rich, gooey filling and flaky pastry crust, 6 Chocolate Chip Gourmet Cookies baked soft and chewy with plenty of chocolate in every bite, and 6 Chocolate Chip Fatties — our thick, loaded 6 oz cookies made for serious cookie lovers.

18 handcrafted treats in total
Three of our most familiar and crowd-pleasing flavours
Pre-selected so there’s nothing extra to customize
Perfect for families, office treats, gifting and dessert tables
Special bundle pricing compared with purchasing each product separately

Everything is baked and packed by Carla’s Cookie Box using the same premium ingredients and small-batch approach found throughout our bakery. It’s an easy way to experience our butter tarts, gourmet cookies and oversized Fatties together in one convenient bundle.

Want even more choice? Explore our gourmet butter tarts, soft gourmet cookies or browse our catering collection for larger gatherings and celebrations.

🍪 Three Carla’s Classics. One Easy Bundle.

💗 Bundle & Save — Classic Carla’s Cookie Box Favourites

Our Classic Favourites Bundle makes it easy to enjoy three of our most-loved bakery staples together. You’ll receive six Plain Butter Tarts, six Chocolate Chip Gourmet Cookies and six Chocolate Chip Fatties — 18 treats in total at a special bundle price.

Everything is baked and packed by Carla’s Cookie Box in Vaughan, Ontario. Whether you’re sharing with family, sending a gift or simply stocking up on favourites, this bundle gives you a little bit of everything without having to build the order yourself.

Planning something bigger? Explore our personal catering collection or visit our corporate gifting and catering collection.

Ingredients & Allergens

Ingredients

Butter Tarts:
Wheat flour, sugars (brown sugar, Canadian maple syrup, granulated sugar), butter (milk), eggs, vegetable shortening, apple cider vinegar, vanilla extract, baking soda, baking powder, salt.

Chocolate Chip Gourmet Cookies & Chocolate Chip Fatties:
Sugars (brown sugar, granulated sugar), wheat flour, chocolate chips (cane sugar, unsweetened chocolate, cocoa butter, whole milk powder, soy lecithin, vanilla extract), butter (milk), eggs, vanilla extract, salt, baking soda, baking powder.

Nutrition Information:
Looking for nutrition facts? View our complete Nutrition Guide →

Love ❤️

Very good! Tons of Reese's pieces in it! Would definitely recommend!

Very tasty! Would highly recommend!

Cookies are delicious and a decent size! Just not sure they're worth almost $5 per cookie. I do appreciate the work that goes into making them though. Would recommend if you are buying for an event, or just to treat yourself once in awhile!

Peanut butter tarts.

So far, I think this is my favourite tart. Not too much peanut butter but just enough to marry well with the butter tart filling. Absolutely yummy!

Everyone I shared with love them has did I

Everyone I shared with love them has did I.

Ok, not fill to the top like they show. All sunken in.

Salted Caramel will be in my regular rotation!

Salted Caramel will be in my regular rotation! Yum!!!!!! 😋

Delicious

Delicious

Amazing Tarts

The tarts were delicious! I got the cherry, turtle and raisin tarts. They weren't overly sweet, but just sweet enough. The raisins ones had so many raisins in them! Lots of filling in them too! Would recommend if you want to treat yourself as they are pretty pricey. Not sure if the price of $54 was a good price, but I do appreciate the work that goes into making them. Would recommend to give a try!

I ordered the butter tarts and they were absolutely fabulous

I ordered the butter tarts and they were absolutely fabulous. I also ordered the cookies and I love them as well. Your order came quickly. Can’t say how great your product is. I since ordered again.

Delicious

I can’t say enough about this delicious treat. They arrived at my home in a a box. They were perfect. I shared them with my family and loved seeing their faces as they bit into them.
They are a great gift or just enjoy yourself!

Best Gift EVER!

Got these as a gift for someone and they were over the moon about it. I got to share them as well and let me say they are worth EVERY penny even though pennies are discontinued :D The packaging was gorgeous too! I will be a repeat customer.

They were okay….

Amazing

This a really great product, I love them and will be my 1st dessert or snack in mind.

Thanks so much, Steve. We’re so glad the cookies have become your go-to dessert or snack. That’s a pretty great spot to earn, and we really appreciate you sharing it with us.

Thanks again for the kind words!

These tarts are so good. Highly recommend them.

These tarts ate so good.

Hi Guy, thank you! We’re so glad you enjoyed the tarts and really appreciate the recommendation. It’s always nice to hear when someone enjoys them enough to want to share the word.

Thanks again for giving our butter tarts a try!

The BEST

Absolutely, without a doubt, the best butter tarts I have EVER had. Arrived “on ice”, vacuum sealed and super fresh!!

Hi Kim, thank you so much! We’re so glad you loved the tarts. Hearing that they’re the best you’ve ever had means a lot to us, and we’re happy they arrived fresh and ready to enjoy.

We really appreciate you taking the time to leave this review!

They are really good, I enjoyed every flavour I tried my favorites being the peanut butter flavour and the nutella flavour.

I love the quality of your buttertarts

I love the quality of your buttertarts. What i find appealing is your thick filling and the variety you offer.
Very delicious, rich and filling.

Hi Rue, thank you for the lovely review! We put a lot of care into making our butter tarts, so it’s wonderful to hear that you enjoyed them.

Thanks again for taking the time to share this with us. We hope to bake for you again soon!

They were amazing

They were amazing, tasted so good.will definitely buy again

Delicious! Best tasting butter tarts I have ever

Delicious! Best tasting butter tarts I have ever had!

The tarts were as good as advertised

The tarts were as good as advertised. My favorites are the originals (plain, raisin and pecan). Not a fan of the peanut butter.

Hi Robert, thank you for taking the time to share your feedback! We’re glad to hear the tarts were as good as advertised, and it sounds like the classic flavours were the standouts for you. We appreciate you giving the Peanut Butter a try as well.

Thanks again, Robert. We hope to have the chance to bake your favourite flavours for you again!

Fantastic butter tarts

Fantastic butter tarts. I sent them to my 95 year-old father who loved them!!!

It brought a smile to his day.

Delicious tarts

Great presentation of delivery. And very tasty butter tarts. The ones with raisen are my favorite.

Buttery and flaky

Buttery and flaky. But I found them a bit to sweet. I am looking forward to trying your thick cookies!

They came in one piece

The butter tarts are great

Wow

Wow, these buttertarts are AMAZING!! The flavour & texture is perfect. Such a wonderful treat!! Thank you so much!!

The cookies are a perfect partner for a cup of coffee or tea

The cookies are a perfect partner for a cup of coffee or tea. They are soft and have so much flavour. Self control is needed to limit myself to just one a day.
I

The fatties cookies are spectacular! And the butter tarts are their awesome selves

The fatties cookies are spectacular! And the butter tarts are their awesome selves, as usual
1

Great butter tarts

Easy to order and received it pretty quick.
The butter tarts was amazing good balance between crust and filling

I am sorry but they were awful

I am sorry but they were awful. The insides were tolerable but the pastry was like eating cardboard. The flavour basically ruined the whole tart. Not enough butter or pastry. I literally tried one bite of each one of the flavors and had to throw them out. I was really looking forward to these as butteryarts are my favourite and was very disappointed.

Leah, thank you for giving our butter tarts a try. We understand you were looking forward to them, especially as butter tarts are a favourite of yours. While ours weren’t to your taste, we appreciate you sharing your honest feedback about the pastry and filling.

Trop

Trop bon

Delicious!

Delicious as always!

Yummmm

Delicious and love the thin buttery crust ❤️

The tarts were really quite good

The tarts were really quite good. Thoughtful packaging to endure the shipping. If Carla’s products were available in-store I would likely purchase again. Otherwise, I did think it was an expensive purchase that I likely won’t make again because of the expense. They were good though!

Excellent!

Really good! Only problem was I over-indulged!

Delicious

Delicious

Let’s see I started with the combination of butter tarts

Let’s see I started with the combination of butter tarts, which were excellent then a few selected brands then my last order and this was my third order, pecan butter tarts. I have never tasted better butter tarts ever in my whole life.

Just got my order and they are soooo good

Just got my order and they are soooo good. Generous filling, great flavor, and not over priced. Will definitely be ordering again

Delicious product

Delicious product. Price is a little too much to have it delivered would be ideal if we had one in Winnipeg. But the variety was nice

Yummy tarts!

The tarts were fabulous! Well packaged, timely delivery.

Everything I’ve tried has been delicious

Absolutely love Carla’s Cookie Box! Everything I’ve tried has been delicious, fresh, and full of flavour. So many amazing flavours to choose from! I can’t wait to try more! The butter tarts are to die for! I’ve been dreaming about them since the last time I had one, so I had to order more! ❤️

Yummy cookies

Cookies were great , My grandkids loved them , I’m a butter tart lover 😊

The butter tarts were amazing

The butter tarts were amazing. They beautifully packed. I had ordered them for my birthday and they arrived well before my birthday. They froze beautifully. Some of the best butter tarts I have ever eaten.

The butter tarts were too big and they were so sweet that the flavours did not come through

The butter tarts were too big and they were so sweet that the flavours did not come through.

The best butter tarts that I’ve ever had!

The best butter tarts that I’ve ever had! Perfect buttery crust and delicious fillings, full of flavour.

These are best around there is no

These are best around there is no better

I can't eat many of them

I can't eat many of them. So I give them away.. Everyone loves them..

Incredible butter tarts! Really enjoyed the

Incredible butter tarts! Really enjoyed the seasonal favourites! All the butter tarts are always incredible! Such a special treat! Thank you!!

Unfortunately by the time I received order the crust was soggy and the inside chewy

Unfortunately by the time I received order the crust was soggy and the inside chewy. Not very fond

I would not be inclined to order again

I would not be inclined to order again. They did not deliver order in time of my event and their communication and ability to resolve issues are very poor

The cookies were amazing

The cookies were amazing, 1 is filling and soft.
Great for on the run, especially since each ine is wrapped individually.

They are delicious true heaven

They are delicious true heaven.

BUY NOW

Your cart is empty

Best Selling Butter Tarts ⭐

Best Selling Butter Tarts ⭐

Estimated total

Bundle & Save — Pick Your Favourite Butter Tarts, Cookies & Fatties

Bundle & Save — Pick Your Favourite Butter Tarts, Cookies & Fatties

Guaranteed Safe Checkout

Customers are saying