Carla's Cookie Box

Quick Pick Fatties - 6 Soft, Chewy and Thick

Name: Quick Pick Fatties - 6 Soft, Chewy and Thick
Brand: Carla's Cookie Box
Price: 33.0 CAD
Availability: InStock
Rating: 4.33 (3 reviews)

$33.00 CAD

Sale Sold out

Shipping calculated at checkout.

Cookie Selection Chocolate Chip Turtle Reese Biscoff Oreo Nutella Variety

Product Details

✨ Reviews 🍪 Flavour Description 👉 How to Order

🍪 Quick Pick Fatties Cookies – our thickest, chewiest cookies, ready to go and hand-crafted in Canada.

Thick, rich, and indulgent in every bite. These cookies are intentionally soft-baked with a gooey center — never dry or crumbly.

A ready-made selection of our most popular flavours, baked fresh in small batches for a bold, bakery-style experience.

View full details

🍪 Fatties Cookies – Thick, Chewy, 6-Ounce Gourmet Cookies Handmade in Toronto

If you're serious about cookies, meet the heavyweight champion. Our Fatties Cookies are big, bold, and unapologetically indulgent—each one weighing in at 6 ounces of gooey, golden perfection. Handcrafted in Toronto using locally sourced ingredients and semi-sweet chocolate, these oversized cookies are baked fresh in small batches and shipped across Canada in a premium mixed box.

❝ Real Reactions from Real Customers ❞

Real Words. Real Reactions. Real Reviews.

Why Cookie Lovers Can’t Get Enough of our Fatties Cookies

Extra Thick, Extra Chewy – We took our classic cookie recipe and made it chunkier for a heartier bite and richer texture.
Handmade in Canada – Proudly crafted in Toronto using locally sourced ingredients from trusted Canadian suppliers.
Pure Cookie Goodness – No fillings or stuffings—just thick, golden-baked dough with a soft centre and crisp edges.
Small-Batch Quality – Each cookie is hand-scooped and baked to order for that fresh-from-the-oven taste.
Nationwide Delivery – We ship across Canada with fast, trackable delivery through our ClickShip network.

How It Works

You Pick Your Treat

Choose your desserts, then select Shipping or Pickup at checkout. A calendar will appear to select your preferred date.

We Bake, Pack Fresh & Ship

We ship fresh from Ontario every Wednesday & Friday. Shipping rates are calculated in real time at checkout — no surprises.

🏬 Pickup Option

Preorder pickup is available Tuesday–Friday in Vaughan, ON. Select Pickup at checkout to choose your date and time.

🍁 Baked in Toronto – Canada & USA Delivery – Guaranteed Fresh🍁

We bake our desserts in small batches in Toronto and ship across Canada and the USA using trusted courier partners, with real-time shipping rates shown clearly at checkout.

Packaging update:

We’ve decided to bake our butter tarts in individual tins and ship them in-tin to ensure minimal touchpoints, better protection, and maximum freshness during transit. This helps preserve the delicate crust and gooey filling from oven to doorstep.

As we complete this transition, some orders may still arrive gently unmolded. Both versions are baked fresh and are the same size, recipe, and quality.

Friendly reminder: Your shipping date is not your delivery date unless it’s a local hand delivery to Toronto, Vaughan, or Brampton.

Fatties Flavours

Quick FAQ

Yes, our Fatties are now stuffed. They're a thicker, triple-sized version of our classic cookie—rich, chewy, and full of flavor with no added fillings.

Yes! You can choose 1-3 flavours per box.

Yes! We ship Fatties nationwide using reliable carriers through our trusted couriers. Each box is carefully packed for freshness.

Each Fatties Cookie weighs nearly 6 ounces—about three times the size of our regular cookies. Thick, decadent, and made to impress.

Yes! Fatties are premium cookies and anar now included in our subscription plans. You can subscribe right on this page.

You can find full details on ordering, shipping, ingredients, and policies on our main FAQ page here:

👉 https://carlacookiebox.com/faq/

You can also reach us anytime at support@carlacookiebox.com

Ingredients

Sugars (brown sugar, granulated sugar), wheat flour, chocolate chips (cane sugar, unsweetened chocolate, cocoa butter, whole milk powder, soy lecithin, vanilla extract), butter (milk), eggs, vanilla extract, salt, baking soda, baking powder.

Allergens

Contains wheat, milk, eggs, and soy. Some flavours may contain peanuts and tree nuts.

Made in a facility that processes peanuts, tree nuts, milk, eggs, wheat, and soy.

Nutrition Information:
Looking for calories, serving sizes and nutrition facts?

View our complete Nutrition Guide →

Love ❤️

Very good! Tons of Reese's pieces in it! Would definitely recommend!

Very tasty! Would highly recommend!

Cookies are delicious and a decent size! Just not sure they're worth almost $5 per cookie. I do appreciate the work that goes into making them though. Would recommend if you are buying for an event, or just to treat yourself once in awhile!

Peanut butter tarts.

So far, I think this is my favourite tart. Not too much peanut butter but just enough to marry well with the butter tart filling. Absolutely yummy!

Everyone I shared with love them has did I

Everyone I shared with love them has did I.

Ok, not fill to the top like they show. All sunken in.

Salted Caramel will be in my regular rotation!

Salted Caramel will be in my regular rotation! Yum!!!!!! 😋

Delicious

Delicious

Amazing Tarts

The tarts were delicious! I got the cherry, turtle and raisin tarts. They weren't overly sweet, but just sweet enough. The raisins ones had so many raisins in them! Lots of filling in them too! Would recommend if you want to treat yourself as they are pretty pricey. Not sure if the price of $54 was a good price, but I do appreciate the work that goes into making them. Would recommend to give a try!

I ordered the butter tarts and they were absolutely fabulous

I ordered the butter tarts and they were absolutely fabulous. I also ordered the cookies and I love them as well. Your order came quickly. Can’t say how great your product is. I since ordered again.

Delicious

I can’t say enough about this delicious treat. They arrived at my home in a a box. They were perfect. I shared them with my family and loved seeing their faces as they bit into them.
They are a great gift or just enjoy yourself!

Best Gift EVER!

Got these as a gift for someone and they were over the moon about it. I got to share them as well and let me say they are worth EVERY penny even though pennies are discontinued :D The packaging was gorgeous too! I will be a repeat customer.

They were okay….

Amazing

This a really great product, I love them and will be my 1st dessert or snack in mind.

Thanks so much, Steve. We’re so glad the cookies have become your go-to dessert or snack. That’s a pretty great spot to earn, and we really appreciate you sharing it with us.

Thanks again for the kind words!

These tarts are so good. Highly recommend them.

These tarts ate so good.

Hi Guy, thank you! We’re so glad you enjoyed the tarts and really appreciate the recommendation. It’s always nice to hear when someone enjoys them enough to want to share the word.

Thanks again for giving our butter tarts a try!

The BEST

Absolutely, without a doubt, the best butter tarts I have EVER had. Arrived “on ice”, vacuum sealed and super fresh!!

Hi Kim, thank you so much! We’re so glad you loved the tarts. Hearing that they’re the best you’ve ever had means a lot to us, and we’re happy they arrived fresh and ready to enjoy.

We really appreciate you taking the time to leave this review!

They are really good, I enjoyed every flavour I tried my favorites being the peanut butter flavour and the nutella flavour.

I love the quality of your buttertarts

I love the quality of your buttertarts. What i find appealing is your thick filling and the variety you offer.
Very delicious, rich and filling.

Hi Rue, thank you for the lovely review! We put a lot of care into making our butter tarts, so it’s wonderful to hear that you enjoyed them.

Thanks again for taking the time to share this with us. We hope to bake for you again soon!

They were amazing

They were amazing, tasted so good.will definitely buy again

Delicious! Best tasting butter tarts I have ever

Delicious! Best tasting butter tarts I have ever had!

The tarts were as good as advertised

The tarts were as good as advertised. My favorites are the originals (plain, raisin and pecan). Not a fan of the peanut butter.

Hi Robert, thank you for taking the time to share your feedback! We’re glad to hear the tarts were as good as advertised, and it sounds like the classic flavours were the standouts for you. We appreciate you giving the Peanut Butter a try as well.

Thanks again, Robert. We hope to have the chance to bake your favourite flavours for you again!

I order tasty snacks from all over the US and Canada These plain butter tarts are extremely

I order tasty snacks from all over the US and Canada
These plain butter tarts are extremely addictive.
I always bring a pack or two to work with me and I've actually had a coworker tell me that its the first time they have had a desert taste so decadent

Lily

Hi the tarts were very good.

Hi Sandy, thank you so much! We’re happy to hear you enjoyed the tarts. We really appreciate you taking the time to share your feedback with us!

The butter tarts arrived as promised with a cooler pack

The butter tarts arrived as promised with a cooler pack. I was able to keep them in the fridge for a while until I enjoyed them with a friend of mine who loves butter tarts! We both found them delicious. As my friend said it was the perfect amount of filling and crust.

Hi Debra, thank you so much! We love hearing that you and your friend enjoyed the tarts. There’s nothing better than sharing a box with someone who loves butter tarts too!

Thanks again for taking the time to share this with us, Debra!

OMG scrumptious

OMG, I bought the fatties, the regular chocolate chip cookies and the tarts and they were absolutely scrumptious.My diabetic husband who is not a big sweet eater couldn’t resist them either. Definitely worth the money and will be ordering again

Hi Maureen, thank you for sharing this! We’re especially happy to hear your husband couldn’t resist them. That’s a pretty good sign! We appreciate you giving us a try and coming back for more.

Very excellent

Very excellent profuct

Exceptional

Exceptional. Buttertarts stand up and cheer!

Hi Mark, thank you so much for the fantastic review! We’re so glad you enjoyed the butter tarts. That means a lot to our little bakery.

Thanks again for your support, Mark!

Very tasty treats wow love the variety flavors

Very tasty treats wow love the variety flavors and Holy big tarts they are delicious

Hi Lisa, thank you for sharing such a sweet review! We really appreciate you giving us a try and taking the time to share this with us. We look forward to baking for you again!

All tasted

All tasted amazing

Hi Ben, thank you for the lovely review! We appreciate you taking the time to share this with us. We hope to bake for you again soon!

Easy website

Easy website, fast delivery and great updates!

Hi Karen, thank you for taking the time to leave us a review! We’re happy to hear everything was easy from placing your order to receiving it. Keeping customers updated throughout the process is something we really care about, so it’s lovely to know you appreciated that too.

We hope you enjoy your next box just as much!

For the times I have received your tasty tarts

For the times I have received your tasty tarts, there have never been any problems. I will keep ordering from you folks, so keep up the wonderful work.

Fran, thank you! It means a lot to hear that you’ve had a great experience with us every time. We’re so glad you’ll be coming back for more tasty tarts, and we’ll keep doing our best to make every box just as good.

Thanks again for your continued support, Fran. We really appreciate you!

Delicious tarts but shady customer service

Delicious tarts, but really poor customer service. When I emailed to say that part of my order was missing, I was presented with an impossible set of conditions to satisfy. Specifically, they demanded a photo of the package after it was opened but before it was unpacked. Seriously? How am I supposed to have that, especially when it takes a day or two to get an email in response? Nice loophole for never having to address a missing item.

Hi TonjaK, thank you for your feedback. we’re glad you enjoyed the butter tarts. We do want to clarify that our missing-item documentation requirements are not introduced after a claim is made. The policy is provided on our packing slips and in multiple areas of our website. The requested photos are intended to be taken when the package is opened, rather than after waiting for a response from our team. They allow us to compare the contents as received with our packing and fulfillment records and properly investigate whether an item was omitted. Once an order has been completely unpacked, that verification becomes much more difficult. These requirements are applied consistently to missing-item claims and are not intended as a loophole to avoid resolving legitimate issues.

Received in excellent shape

Received in excellent shape . Very well packaged.

Well packaged! Would buy again

Everything was well packaged and arrived with zero breakages or losses. It also survived the summer heat during transit. Would 100% buy from here again.

Customer Review — Disappointing Subscription Experience
I ordered a three-month butter tart subscription from Carla’s Cookie Box as a gift and paid the full subscription amount upfront. Their website clearly states that subscriptions are paid once upfront, with no hidden fees, and that the monthly deliveries are shipped directly to your door.
I received the first month’s delivery, but nothing after that.
I have contacted Carla’s Cookie Box multiple times about the missing deliveries. Unfortunately, the responses I have received have been generic, seemingly AI-generated messages that don't actually address the problem or tell me when the products I already paid for will be shipped.
What makes this even more frustrating is that I can see the subscription/order information on their website. It shows that the second month was pending and apparently being prepared, but it was never shipped or delivered. Now the third month is showing as being scheduled as well, while I still haven't received the second delivery and have received no meaningful response from the company.
At this point, I have paid for three months and received only one.
I understand that shipping delays and mistakes can happen. What I find unacceptable is paying upfront for a subscription, not receiving what was purchased, and then being ignored when trying to resolve the issue. A generic automated response is not a solution when the specific issue is that paid-for products have not been delivered.
I’m leaving this review because I think customers should know what my experience has been before purchasing a subscription. I hope Carla’s Cookie Box addresses this and either fulfills the subscription that I paid for or provides an appropriate refund.

Hello! thank you for sharing your experience. We do want to clarify that the three-month subscription was not paid in full upfront. Only the first shipment had been billed and paid for at the time of this review, and the subsequent subscription shipments had not yet been charged. We understand the subscription schedule may have been confusing, and we appreciate the opportunity to clarify the billing status.

Disappointing experience ALL AROUND

Customer Review — Disappointing Subscription Experience
I ordered a three-month butter tart subscription from Carla’s Cookie Box as a gift and paid the full subscription amount upfront. Their website clearly states that subscriptions are paid once upfront, with no hidden fees, and that the monthly deliveries are shipped directly to your door.
I received the first month’s delivery, but nothing after that.
I have contacted Carla’s Cookie Box multiple times about the missing deliveries. Unfortunately, the responses I have received have been generic, seemingly AI-generated messages that don't actually address the problem or tell me when the products I already paid for will be shipped.
What makes this even more frustrating is that I can see the subscription/order information on their website. It shows that the second month was pending and apparently being prepared, but it was never shipped or delivered. Now the third month is showing as being prepared as well, while I still haven't received the second delivery and have received no meaningful response from the company.
At this point, I have paid for three months and received only one.
I understand that shipping delays and mistakes can happen. What I find unacceptable is paying upfront for a subscription, not receiving what was purchased, and then being ignored when trying to resolve the issue. A generic automated response is not a solution when the specific issue is that paid-for products have not been delivered.
I’m leaving this review because I think customers should know what my experience has been before purchasing a subscription. I hope Carla’s Cookie Box addresses this and either fulfills the subscription that I paid for or provides an appropriate refund.

Hi Tammy, thank you for sharing your feedback. We’re sorry for the confusion around your subscription. We checked your account and can confirm that only the first box has been billed and shipped so far. Your next billing and shipment are scheduled for September.

We apologize that our earlier responses didn’t make this clear, and we appreciate you giving us the opportunity to clarify. Thank you!

You must've sent this to me in error

You must've sent this to me in error. I have already written a review

Great experience ordering from the site

Buying from the site right down to the tracking and delivery of the tarts. They were carefully packaged to avoid breakage

Hi Karen, thank you for sharing your experience with us! We also put a lot of care into packaging, so we’re happy to hear the tarts arrived safely.

Thanks again for your support!

Not worth the money.

Almost no accountability and poor customer service. Package came over a week late and were too warm from sitting outside (waste of money paying for the cooling sleeve packaging) and frankly could not rate the butter tarts as they were past their best. Overall, not worth the money and will never buy from them again.

Hi Wayne, thank you for taking the time to share your feedback. We’re sorry to hear that your order didn’t arrive as expected. Our butter tarts are baked fresh, vacuum sealed, and made to travel safely at room temperature. The ice packs are there to help reduce exposure to higher temperatures during transit, although they can thaw along the way.
We appreciate you sharing your experience with us. Thanks again!

Easy to order and fast

Easy to order and fast delivery

Spent $45

Spent $45.00 to get this product sent to us. Terrible! I paid the extra for the ice pack, the product was delivered mushy, and ordinary. Threw it all away!

Hi Erica, thank you for giving our butter tarts a try and for sharing your honest feedback. Our butter tarts are baked fresh, vacuum sealed, and made to travel safely at room temperature, so the cold pack is an added layer of protection rather than something that keeps the tarts chilled for the entire journey. We really appreciate you taking the time to share your experience with us. Thanks again!

Poor value

Not good value. The different flavors were very similar. Dubai is not worth the extra $

Hi Victoria, thank you for giving our butter tarts a try and for sharing your honest feedback. We understand that the flavours didn’t feel different enough for you.
We know everyone’s taste and preferences are different, but we really do appreciate you taking the time to let us know how you felt about your order. Thanks again!

Tarts were delicious

Tarts were delicious. Nice and deep. Variety

Hi Alice, thank you so much for sharing your review! We’re so glad you enjoyed the butter tarts and loved the variety. We really appreciate you taking the time to share your experience with us.

Worth Trying!!

I ordered both 6 pack of Butter Tarts and 6 pack of Gourmet Soft Cookies!! Carla's Cookie Box kept me informed about my order and shipping, communication was great!! Has some good deals as well and the shipping of my order came decently packed and no damage!! Little pricey for having Cookies and Tarts shipped out of Town and Order but was curious about the rave of reviews on how Delicious Carla's Tarts and Cookies were. It was definitely worth buying and Trying!!!

Hi Christine, thank you so much for giving both our butter tarts and cookies a try! We’re glad you decided to see what all the rave reviews were about. Thank you for supporting us!

When my tarts arrived

When my tarts arrived, I was a little worried about shipping and we live way down by Brockville Ontario. I was a little worried, but they were absolutely so fresh and so tasty and so creamy my favourite is Biscoff and turtle so delicious. Definitely gonna be ordering it again.

Hi Vicky, thank you so much for sharing this! Biscoff and Turtle are such good choices! We really appreciate your support and would love to have you order from us again.

We did not enjoy

We did not enjoy.

Hi Daniel, thank you for giving our butter tarts a try. We understand they weren’t to your taste, and we appreciate you taking the time to share your feedback with us.

Thank you again for giving us try.

BUY NOW

Your cart is empty

Best Selling Butter Tarts ⭐

Best Selling Butter Tarts ⭐

Your cart

Estimated total

Quick Pick Fatties - 6 Soft, Chewy and Thick